News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Neuroscience of Drumming by Cthulhu_ on Monday August 17, 2015 @05:56AM (#10072108)
Bit of a chicken-and-egg problem there; are they different because they drum, or do they drum because they're different? Same can be postulated about software developers; do they think different because they work with programming languages, or vice-versa?
Re:The Neuroscience of Drumming by rprospero on Monday August 17, 2015 @12:34PM (#10074197)
Since there's a lot of drummers checking in on this one, I thought that I'd come in from the reverse side. Rhythm never made any sense to me. When we were supposed to clap to the beat of a song in music class, I usually just cheated off the kids next to me and tried to match my hands to their own. If that failed, I'd just clap every time the person in the song said a word. For children's music, that was usually close enough.
Re:The Neuroscience of Drumming by zo1 on Monday August 17, 2015 @01:12PM (#10074502)
"If that failed, I'd just clap every time the person in the song said a word. For children's music, that was usually close enough."

It's not just children's music. Most songs you find today, if you listen closely enough, the words follow the beat. I.e. every once in a while, a word starts on the "one" beat.

And we take it for granted. You'll very quickly realize something is "off" if that's not the case. That's usually what you find in "artsy", "look at us we're weird and different" type of music. Annoying most times, and incredibly difficult to get right.

Re:The Neuroscience of Drumming by pbhjpbhj on Monday August 17, 2015 @02:41PM (#10075176)
I'm pretty arhythmic too, was about 14 before I learnt to skip - spent many humilating lessons at primary school when the teacher told us to skip (without a rope) and they didn't understand how I couldn't do it. I can't clap in time at all, nor dance (another point of childhood humilation).

As it happens I took classical piano as a teenager, but always had trouble with the rhythm.

When getting a medical exam for scuba there was a suggestion that I had an arhythmic heartbeat and I've always wondered if that could relate - perhaps my brain just can't do rhythm in any way at all ...

Re:The Neuroscience of Drumming by slfnflctd on Monday August 17, 2015 @08:53AM (#10072612)
A good question, the kind that should always be raised with these sorts of studies.

On the anecdotal side, I've played music with a lot of people over the years, and have long suspected there is some sort of inborn talent spectrum for both rhythm and pitch discernment (somewhat separately from each other, too). Practicing a ton will make a difference, but it definitely appears that certain skills come much more easily for some people than others. Good drummers are actually pretty hard to find in my experience, and they tend to be in high demand.

Re:The Neuroscience of Drumming by stef25 on Monday August 17, 2015 @10:23AM (#10073123)
When I was a young kid I took up drum lessons and immediately became very good at it. On the exams I always had 90% or higher, other kids really looked up to me and I didn't really understand the big deal. Didn't practise much at all, was never nervous, didn't see my achievements as anything special.

When taking lessons in a music school I also had to follow separate classes of music theory which I hated, so I wanted to quit. But my teacher desperately wanted me to continue and allowed me to follow his classes "unofficially". Then I started playing in bands and the other members were always really impressed. Again I didn't understand why.

I'm at best mediocre at everything else I do: other musical instruments, being a developer, these kind of logical reasoning intelligence & maths tests.

Don't really excel at anything at all but I always felt that playing drums was some kind of built in talent I had, so I believe there's a kind of person that's born with a real talent for rhythm.

Re:The Neuroscience of Drumming by JimiofEden on Monday August 17, 2015 @09:50AM (#10072923)
You do have to learn how to drum in the first place, and it's not something that's unachievable. So I'd argue it's because you drum.

When I learned how to play in the first place, particularly with jazzy bands and all that, it honestly felt like the mental rigors of studying, since I was trying to incorporate rhythms, as well as breaking them, all while giving a steady heartbeat to the band playing with me. Learning different techniques, handling, sticking, getting to the point where hitting the drum head at the precise location for the precise sound needed was a lot of multitasking to keep in mind, while holding steady notes on a snare or a hi-hat.

And the point was to practice all of this until it became second nature, and you didn't have to keep any of it in mind as you played.

So it'd be more fair to say that drumming kinda rewrites the way you think and redirects certain aspects of your mental faculties.

Re:The Neuroscience of Drumming by atom-morgan on Monday August 17, 2015 @09:38AM (#10072837)
Drummer here speaking. I would say it's like anything else. Drummers are different because they drum.
Re:The Neuroscience of Drumming by jonwachob91 on Monday August 17, 2015 @08:53AM (#10072610)
Not a chicken and egg problem, the evolution occurred during the egg lifecycle - thus the egg came first...

But we all get your point ;)