Re:Understand 1,700 Mechanical Linkages with These Helpful A...
by minthd on Sunday August 16, 2015 @08:30AM
(#10068730)
Why are mechanical solutions more reliable than a servo ? Aren't mechanical and moving parts less reliable than electronics , in general ?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Understand 1,700 Mechanical Linkages with These Helpful A...
by weinzierl on Sunday August 16, 2015 @12:41PM
(#10069376)
Aren't mechanical and moving parts less reliable than
electronics, in general?
I don't dare to answer this in general, maybe someone more knowledgeable can offer his or her opinion. In our case the alternatives were: 1. Simple gear and constant velocity three-phase motor[1]
2. Two axis mounting and two stepper motors.
First option has less parts and should be more reliable in theory.
That being said: I only know of commercially available solutions of the second kind. Maybe this has changed in the
last ten years, but our solution never made it to market.[1] Industrial three-phase motors are real workhorses, produced in large quantities since ages, relatively cheap and incredibly reliable.
Re:Understand 1,700 Mechanical Linkages with These Helpful A...
by sitkack on Sunday August 16, 2015 @07:13PM
(#10070620)
You can think of a mechanical solution as a straight line program with no conditionals. The servo solution has a feedback loop that will ultimately face an upset in the feedback loop, a broken sensor, worn brushes on the servo motor, over heated power transistors, etc. Both solutions will suffer from fatigue in the long term, but an active solution with electronics and a servo will suffer from a element failing and possibly causing the active solution to destroy itself.