How do you expect to get taken seriously when you use such hateful terms against your opponents? The problem here seems to be bureaucratic inflexibility that's unresponsive to unique local conditions (even though the general principle might be a sound one), not jackbooted thugs brutalizing anyone who suggests desalination might be more sustainable than well-digging.
The problem here is the unresponsive nature of governance when there are jurisdictional conflicts. Why do you feel the need to treat it as a personal moral conflict when there's no evidence that that's what's going on? It doesn't seem to me that you're interested in addressing the actual problem, just in using it as a means to demonize other people with whom you disagree.
As I said in my comment to the other poster, we have accepted having become a neutered society where the ideological extremists (from all angles) win because you, I and the next guy are socially neutered.
We don't fight for anything and accept such nonsense as "bureaucratic inflexibility that's unresponsive to unique local conditions". NO, that's bullshit that ought not be tolerated. And that's precisely the attitude that lands us in these kinds of problems.
What you wrote is wonderful and sounds like it ought be be read sipping ice tea while reading Plato's Republic on a green lawn on a nice Sunday afternoon in a gentle breeze. In other words, neutered intellectualism.
And, while we do that, HALF THE TREES in a forest are DEAD.
So, yes, maybe it's time we stop tolerating and rationalizing billion dollar websites and killing half the trees in a forest, get a little angry, sound a little less erudite and fix the problem.
Look, I view these issues not with my eyes but rather with my kid's futures in mind. We have reached the peak of the ridiculous in this country. We can't get anything done. We can build anything, we can't grow anything and we are at a point where people actually get angry at a guy calling an agency "nazi's" in a figurative sense when, the real issue is that HALF A FOREST was destroyed and a town stands to also be destroyed in the process.
So, what should we focus on? The language and semantic choices or the real problems? Do we vote for politicians who sound, well, political and neutered, or do we want people with fire in their eyes who are going to plow through the nonsense and fix problems. I have to tell you, my conversation with my Mom and Dad last night, life long Dems, was an eye opener. They've lost all trust in the political class. All of them.
You can hate me. That's fine. Now go focus on half a forest being killed due to either the lack of an ability to make sensible decisions or, possibly worst, decisions driven by ideology regardless of the consequences they might bring. Focus on that. Please.
C'mon.
“Never use a big word when a little filthy one will do.” ― Johnny Carson
It's OK, I get it. In today's society it is better to come of in alignment with the cult and neutered than to actually have a pulse.
I'm not 20 years old any more. I don't need to impress anyone. I'll leave carefully written prose to business emails, letters and contracts. If my post offended you, well, I am truly sorry. Sorry because you are choosing to focus on the messenger and not on the issues.
That said, if we are talking about antagonism and HN, well, when it comes to topics outside of tech it is almost a sport to down-vote or berate anyone who does not align with a certain ideology.
In the over six years or so I've been reading HN I have yet to see any "we" coming down to say "We'd appreciate it if you wouldn't post like this here" in any of those cases in defense of being accepting of alternative points of view.
I go back to USENET days. HN is definitely better than any of that, by far, however, there's an underlying accepted ideology that is promoted here and everything else is rejected and attacked in various overt and and not-so-overt ways. That aspect is not very different from the kinds of things that could happen on USENET. Granted, public discussion boards are horrendously difficult to run. I get that part.
Discussions on HN are thoughtful when it comes to matters of technology. Outside of that HN is very intolerant of alternative points of view. People can find themselves defending from personal attacks instead of engaging in discussing the issues. Something like this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-4EDhdAHrOg
HN is the person with the nail on her head. She is happy for the split second the guy comes in to alignment with her point of view. Outside of that, when an alternative point of view is offered, not happy at all.
Before anyone says anything --because I KNOW someone will jump on the keyboard and attack the choice of videos-- no, this has nothing to do with women. It's just a convenient illustration that came to mind.
Anyhow, time to move off this thread.
Your comments are problematic not because of any ideological views, but because they stopped being civil and substantive.
The answer to both those questions is "yes".
I'm done. Thanks.
P.S. I'm curious, what personal attacks are you referencing?
There's a real problem here, which is often studied under the name 'public choice theory.' I appreciate that you feel frustrated by the web of sociopolitical constraints that you feel trapped in, as do I. But where I disagree with you is in thinking that the problem exists because people are not emotional enough.
I do not, by any stretch, want to compare this to the Holocaust. But there's a lesson there that I learned from watching a video by this Arab author who is Islamic yet quite vocal about fighting islamic terrorism. I wish I could remember her name.
She said something to the effect that moderate majorities never matter. And she used examples such as various genocides throughout history to demonstrate her point. In the case of what happened in Germany, she, quite correctly, said that while the vast majority of Germans did not agree with the Nazi's and were "moderate" their inaction, their lack of engagement, their passive compliance, their lack of "fire in their eyes" made them irrelevant. Moderates do not act and by not acting they serve no purpose when faced with something even as horrible as a genocide.
Again, not comparing this to a real genocide. I guess we don't have a comparable word for being responsible for the death of half a forest.
Yet the point is that a different attitude of active and passionate engagement against nonsense is badly needed. The moderates, the people who just sit idly by and let it happen. the people enough passion or "fire in their eyes" to oppose these forces quickly become irrelevant. And that pretty much describes every single professional politician. They've all been neutered by their need to survive by pandering for votes. And so, they do nothing and the extremists, just like the Nazi's, have free range to do as they wish.
This isn't a simple problem and, to be sure, we've created it or allowed it to be created for decades. And no, by "fire in the eyes" I don't mean Rambo. I mean passion to do the right thing. Which also means passion to demand responsible decisions while making common sense choices about issues in front of us. Killing half a forest is criminal.
"drought, pitch canker, and beetles"? It's not one word, but it's from the original post.
I see you're really worked up but I can't tell who you're trying to fight.
Is that what was said? I don't think it was. Unless you want to just assume the Coastal Commission and "other regulatory bodies" are "environmental nazi's [sic]". The laws and/or regulations causing problems here may or may not be originally linked to environmental efforts, but either way, blanket sentiments that regulation is bad, or good, don't really help and just add to the rhetoric noise that detracts from people getting the useful information needed to institute change, whther that be small scale and local, large scale and federal, or somewhere in-between.
There are of course many instances where regulations have become too complex and rigid and actually are detrimental to the public or environment, even if that's what they were meant to protect, but there are also many cases where the lack of regulation causes severe problems. Noting the cases that affecting you or that you've been exposed to and extrapolating a pattern exposing a problem with regulation or lack of regulation as a whole for the nation is rarely useful.
The proof is in the trees. Nobody could see past the rules/ideology to focus on the damage that would ensue from not finding a solution to the problem.
There's nothing wrong with regulations. Nowhere did I say that regulations are bad. It's more about being sensible about things.
Again, today, you could not build San Francisco. Period. You couldn't even start. Think about that for a moment.
We have allowed things to devolve to the point where we are damaging our ability to function and drive progress.
Take the Hyperloop as and example. Even if it is shown to work I'll bet it would be almost impossible to build because some group or agency is going to take extreme environmental positions. And so, instead of having a more efficient alternative system of transportation we will be stuck with freeways full of cars and trucks polluting our air.
We have become neutered as a society to the point that nobody wants to fight for anything. The most comfortable position to take is "hakuna matata", play some background music and let the extremists (from all ideological angles, BTW) take over.
Not good.
I think you need to start backing up your rhetoric with facts. As it stands, you are just spreading innuendo and FUD. Anecdotes about lifelong Democrat parents and a table full of relatives talking up Donald Trump are great stories, but that's all they are. It's obvious Trump has people interested, the polls show that. But if they are seriously considering Trump and his non-plans as a viable future after being Democrats, in what way are they not the exact people that caused the problems you seem to be railing against here?
> The proof is in the trees. Nobody could see past the rules/ideology to focus on the damage would ensue from not finding a solution to the problem.
You mean the trees, which as the OP mentioned, are having problems due to beetle infestations caused by drought? In what way is the drought the fault of environmentalists? Do you think a water plant in Cambria will somehow make the area no longer susceptible the massive ecological ramifications of a state-wide drought?
> There's nothing wrong with regulations. Nowhere did I say that regulations are bad. It's more about being sensible about things.
No, you just jumped from regulatory agencies preventing something to saying environmental Nazis prevented it. Perhaps you think the people at the agencies have the ability to ignore the law and carry out their own agenda, and there's no recourse? Forgive me if I'm having trouble parsing what your intention was with the original statement, the logic didn't seem sound to me, so I had to assume the point you were trying to make.
> Again, today, you could not build San Francisco. Period. You couldn't even start. Think about that for a moment.
Even if I accepted this completely unsubstantiated statement as truth, have you bothered to think about what it means? Since when do we just build cities like San Francisco? San Francisco is the way it is because it was built up over a couple centuries. Would we want to build a city with portions of it built to the standards of the 19th century? Even if we could build a large city to current standards, why would we? Why not build something better?
> We have allowed things to devolve to the point where we are damaging our ability to function and drive progress.
At some point you should really try backing up these expansive statements about the state of country with actual evidence. It might go over better.
You obviously haven't dealt with government enough then. I've done a ton of business with multiple government agencies over the last 30 years or so. My father for about 70 years and on three continents. Thinking that government agencies do not behave badly and above the law is, I am sorry to say, a really naive position that can only come from a lack of experience (and, in that case, understandable). Government agencies are people, not machines, and we are flawed in a million different ways.
If you don't think government agencies don't behave unethically or badly, just read this:
http://www.unclefed.com/TxprBoR/JWWade.html
And there are a million more like that if you dig far enough.
In spite of my grumbling I like living in California. We were in a financial mess because cut taxes and spend Republican governor and Bush's recession. But we took redistricting away from the legislature and threw the republicans out and now we are fiscally sound. We may have some annoying regulations, but everyone has access to health insurance, free if you are poor. Nobody dictates what a woman can do with her body. We have Silicon Valley in the north and lala-land in the south. It aint perfect, but the weather sure is nice. (OK, maybe a little more rain.)
http://www.wnd.com/2014/10/irs-seizes-life-savings-for-depos...
Nobody is suggesting dropping regulations, destroying our environment or going anarchist. But a situation like the one you described ought to make everyone angry. The damage caused through inaction (or whatever the mechanism may have been) is inexcusable. The people responsible ought to suffer consequences, perhaps even be fired. Killing half a forest is, well, criminal. And that is, per your account, what they did.
I'd like to think we agree. Perhaps I am more passionate about confronting ineptitude than you might be or perhaps I am much older and I've seen enough of this that I've just reached a limit. I love nature. Killing half a forest should not be taken lightly.
Except that those cities were shitholes for a significant chunk of their lifespan.
Here's a good example of that era:
Pittsburgh circa 1940: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/06/05/historic-pittsburgh...
Look familiar? Beijing circa 2013 http://www.cnn.com/2013/01/29/asia/gallery/beijing-smog/inde...
This is what you get without regulations.
Maybe we have too many regulations, but too few is just as bad, if not worse.
Unfortunately climate change may mean that the forest may be gone in a few decades. The pines need the Cambria micro-climate with its morning fog and moderate temperatures. A series of extended droughts will kill them all.
Private corporations aren't any better, honestly. You don't have to look too hard to find examples of greed leading to severe environmental damage, present and future.
There is no feasible way that a desal plant will be built before the end of the drought (if the drought ends soon) or that a hastily built desalination plant will be a sufficient supply for the population.
And FWIW, if every tiny town like Cambria tried to deSal their way out of the drought, the entire coastline would be mutilated with the brackish desal byproduct and residents would continue to use water like there was no drought. Santa Barbara's desalination plant is only expected to be able to supply the city with 30% of the water needs. SB is 1/400th the population of California, so there would need to be about 1,200 desalination plants the size of Santa Barbara's (which has cost about $75million so far). A larger reservoir system is needed to sustain the current population of California and it won't matter until after rain replenishes the existing one.
> He has voted Democrat all his life. So he's so pissed off at the result of tens of millions like him (both Republican and Democrat) voting for the same party for a lifetime that he is finally pissed off enough to vote for someone that is politically centrist. AMAZING! He probably doesn't even see the cognitive dissonance and blames everyone but himself. You reap what you sew.
People should be angry at the 2-party pendulum system that offers voters a false choice. It's mostly created by state-level politics (the state level political parties get to choose whether people of other party affiliations are allowed to vote in their primary), but is heavily reinforced at the federal level by the winner take all effect of the Electoral College[1][2]. Political parties have destroyed most of the choice of representation at the federal level and what is left has been destroyed by the dirty nature of a hyper-polarized electorate. The parties are the problem and your parents are part of them.
Voting for Trump doesn't fix anything. It is a vote of frustration, nothing more. It doesn't address:
* the electoral college,
* the hyper-partisan electorate,
* the fact that Congress will still be nearly 50/50 Republican and Democrat,
* the majority party in the Senate will be unable to break a fillibuster,
* voters won't magically more rational or more interested in long-term investments as opposed to stopgaps
* Congress won't suddenly give up pork-barrel spending
* the 60% of apathetic and disaffected US voters don't magically show up to the ballots
* fix the US Government's procurement systems
* fix labor contracts and pension costs
* reduce the 300,000 criminal penalties for federal laws on the books including mandatory minimums which prevent judges and prosecutors from seeking and arriving at rational punishments
* improve mental illness treatments so the penal system isn't burdened by people who can't possibly control their own actions
* illegal immigration (even if you think it's a major problem)
* ISIS won't be intimidated by a loudmouth who tries and comically fails to hide the fact that he is old and losing hair on his head
It might make your parents feel good for a few months, but then it will sink in that the two major parties will re-absorb most of the Trump voters by moving their platforms only the minimum amount needed to appease most of them (a la Republican party after 2009-2010 Tea Party movement).And Trump, as a hypothetical president, would still be president without allies in Congress. And I honestly worry about a guy who can't express a thought accurately and precisely as the head diplomat and a man who tweetstorms insults at a woman who asked completely legitimate questions of him as Commander in Chief of the country with the most advanced military, a nuclear weapons arsenal.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ross_Perot#1992_presidential_c... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_presidential_ele...
For the record, I have serious criticisms of California politics, also, but the Coastal Commission is low on my list. {CEQA, and Prop 13, and the inability of the California legislature to raise taxes if needed} are high on the list. Anyone who lives within sight of the coast already knows about the Coastal Commission.