Re:How California Is Winning the Drought
by cjensen on Friday August 14, 2015 @03:18PM
(#10062234)
Yes, it's mathematically superfluous. Real human communication is an evolved trait which often is logically or mathematically weird. Ask a person how many brownies to bake for a party and they might say "at least 10 to 20." The "to 20" is mathematically without meaning, but it seems to communicate something.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:How California Is Winning the Drought
by jessedhillon on Friday August 14, 2015 @03:25PM
(#10062276)
Is "to 20" superfluous? If they had said "at least 10" that leaves you open to baking a thousand. The "to 20" caps the possible range and makes the statement more confined.
Re:How California Is Winning the Drought
by Scotlandr on Friday August 14, 2015 @04:02PM
(#10062558)
I don't believe that it does cap the range. I see it as:
At least x (where x = 10-20). X is the minimum, and you can always exceed it, whether it is a single value or a range.
If you bake 100 brownies, you satisfy the requirement of baking at least 10 brownies, as well as the requirement of baking at least 10 to 20 brownies.