News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple's 30% by mikeash on Friday August 14, 2015 @12:57PM (#10061230)
In retail, you pay 50% because that's something like what it actually costs to sell stuff to people in a physical store.

The cost of selling software is almost zero. Unlike retail's cut of your selling price, Apple's cut is completely arbitrary and rather unjustified.

If you sell software directly to users, the cost can be something like 3%, depending on which payment processor you want to use.

What additional service does Apple provide for that additional 27% cut? The buying experience is easier, but this doesn't seem to translate into additional sales. You mention "massive exposure," but there's pretty much universal agreement among developers in the Apple world that the App Store's "marketing" bump is pretty much zero unless you're extremely lucky and get featured.

But hey, if it's worth it, then you should be able to let developers choose and they'll still go for it. On iOS, there is no choice. If you want to sell, it's either Apple's 30% or nothing. On the Mac, there is a choice (for now) and the trend now seems to be to choose not to use the App Store there.

Re:Apple's 30% by rgbrgb on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:07PM (#10061294)
It's definitely not 0 to build, maintain, and curate the App Store. Not even "almost zero".

>> The buying experience is easier, but this doesn't seem to translate into additional sales.

I'd like to see a source for this assertion. In my anecdotal experience of selling software on the App Store and not on the App Store, it's 10x harder to do it yourself (so for me worth the 30%). Reducing friction increases purchases -- that's why Apple, Amazon, and even Stripe now store consumer credit cards. That's not even taking into account how valuable being featured is.

Maybe 30% is not the right number, and I totally agree that the OS should not insist that your apps be procured through a blessed channel, but there's a huge difference in effort between setting up your own store using Stripe and selling on the App Store.

Re:Apple's 30% by mikeash on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:18PM (#10061372)
My source for the assertion is purely personal, from knowing a lot of developers who sell both in out of the store. Pretty much universally, if a product is available both through the Mac App Store and directly, the sales through the two channels are comparable. No, I have no numbers to back it up, just talking with people who actually do it.

Having done both, in terms of effort I'd much rather set up my own store.

Selling on the App Store is a horrible mess. Code signing, provisioning, verification, review, they do not make it easy at all. And good luck if you want to actually test the build you submit to the store.

Any competent programmer should be able to set up a web store without a great deal of pain.

I think there's a big disconnect here in terms of how different people approach and prioritize things. You're pointing to the submission process as an advantage. A sibling poster actually pointed to app review as an advantage. To me, they are both horrible disadvantages that make the App Store a terrible place for developers.

Re:Apple's 30% by replicatorblog on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:09PM (#10061306)
All your points are fair, but if Apple's value is just 3%, why don't we hear as many stories about other app stores? Android has a much larger userbase, but the common wisdom is that actual revenue in that store is much smaller.

Beyond the 3% in transactions you're paying for the review process, which while imperfect, makes parents pretty comfortable letting their kids pay $1M/day to the Clash of Clans/Angry Birds folks.

While getting featured is rare, you still need to pay the salaries of the editors who pick the best apps, the graphics artists who merchandise the collections, etc.

I also look at it as the subsidy that helps offset the cost of developing Objective-C, Swift, etc. You might argue that it's in Apple's best interest to develop that anyway, but I don't fault them for trying to recoup the cost.

Look at it this way, it's a progressive 30% tax that you pay if your successful, while keeping the cost of development low for beginners.

Really, I think the big thing you're paying for is access to a customer base that is much more likely to pay you.

I've had a couple products featured in the iTunes store despite not being super connected and had great success. I understand the frustration, but it's not like you're not getting anything in return.

Re:Apple's 30% by mikeash on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:12PM (#10061334)
Paying for the review process is not a feature! That's the software equivalent of how oppressive governments will execute a prisoner and then send their family a bill for the bullet.

Apple is making billions from the App Store. It doesn't cost anything close to that much for Apple to build their developer tools. They were giving those tools away for free long before anyone had even heard of iOS.

Re:Apple's 30% by icebraining on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:41PM (#10061526)
Paying for the review process is not a feature!

While it might be argued that it doesn't work as well as it should, or that it shouldn't be forced, it's certainly a feature. It's a mechanism that improves user confidence in unknown apps, making them more likely to make a purchase when they are uncertain. No different than having your business certified under some ISO standard, which also costs money, but is essential to getting some clients.

Re:Apple's 30% by mikeash on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:48PM (#10061575)
I'm starting to realize there is a massive disconnect between disparate communities here, sort of like when I came to realize that there are people out there who genuinely believe that the clouds that form behind airliners come from the deliberate spraying of mind-altering chemicals.

Apparently there are people out there who genuinely believe that app review is not an anti-developer requirement that Apple uses to further its own goals, but rather a pro-developer feature that's worth paying for. I don't know that I can usefully continue the discussion without spending some time thinking about this state of affairs first.

Re:Apple's 30% by s73v3r on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:27PM (#10061437)
And how much does it cost to maintain the distribution network? For bandwidth?

You claim they are making "billions" off their cut. So show it. Most sources show that the revenues are about at the same level as their costs. If you have something different, please feel free to show.

Re:Apple's 30% by mikeash on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:32PM (#10061472)
They're bringing in billions. I don't know what their profits are. But either their profits are huge, or the App Store is ridiculously inefficient in terms of cost, because payment processing and bandwidth just do not cost that much on relative terms.

I'm sure the App Store is breathtakingly expensive in absolute terms. But there's no reason it has to cost anything like 30% of sales. This stuff scales up sub-linearly, not super-linearly.

Re:Apple's 30% by s73v3r on Friday August 14, 2015 @07:01PM (#10063504)
So basically you do not have numbers to back up your claims.
Re:Apple's 30% by mikeash on Saturday August 15, 2015 @07:07AM (#10065062)
This is an internet discussion, not a scientific paper. I base my claims on long experience.

If that's not good enough for you, that's certainly your right, but it's a bit ridiculous of you to complain when you've offered no more support for your side.

Re:Apple's 30% by justwannasing on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:02PM (#10061260)
Anyone who thinks the cost of selling software is remotely near zero should be ignored. Ads need to be produced and thought up and salesmen need to be paid and packaging still must be done and and someone has to be in charge of all that, along with all the people beneath him.
Re:Apple's 30% by mikeash on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:09PM (#10061314)
Salesmen? Packaging? We may both be talking about "software" but you're talking about a completely different kind of product than what one finds in the App Store.
Re:Apple's 30% by replicatorblog on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:18PM (#10061378)
One of the reasons why the Apple app store is so popular is that Apple spends billions on TV/BillBoard/Magazine/Web advertising for the store and apps within it. It's a massive marketing/sales/"packaging" cost.
Re:Apple's 30% by mikeash on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:24PM (#10061418)
Which is great if you're one of the top apps and can get Apple's attention, but useless for 99.9% of developers.

I would also say that by far the main reason for the App Store's popularity is simply that it is the only channel for third-party apps on a massively popular platform. Apple could do nothing beyond making it available as an icon on the home screen and it would still be enormously popular.

Re:Apple's 30% by icebraining on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:42PM (#10061532)
on a massively popular platform

And that's part of what you're paying for.

Re:Apple's 30% by mikeash on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:53PM (#10061615)
If you want to say that you're paying for access, that Apple can charge what they like, and that 30% is good value for the money for that access, fine. I disagree, but I respect that argument.

But the person above was comparing Apple's 30% to retail's 50%, which is a bad comparison because retail's cut is largely based on the actual costs of selling.

Re:Apple's 30% by justwannasing on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:25PM (#10061425)
Who creates what you see on the App Store? Who wrote all that and designed it? Who wrote the code for the App Store? Are you saying no professional sales people were involved in this? How does anyone in the world know when a new item shows up in the App Store? Who pays for all those ads you see on TV and in magazines and online?
Re:Apple's 30% by mikeash on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:30PM (#10061459)
Is this just a terminology problem? "Salesmen" to me are the people in suits who you talk to when you want a piece of software that doesn't list a price and just says "Call for a quote." The people you're talking about are programmers.

How does anyone in the world know when a new item shows up in the app store? For 99.99% of apps, it's either word of mouth or marketing activities undertaken by the developer. Apple's own marketing is great if you're one of the favored few, but for everybody else it does nothing.