Re:Edward Snowden at IETF 93
by pfg on Friday August 14, 2015 @12:48PM
(#10061180)
I wouldn't classify statements like "we gotta start somewhere and then we've got to iterate from that point" or "It's better than what we have today" as a call to action to drop everything and start implementing DNSSEC as-is right away. I would interpret it as "yes, DNSSEC improves the situation in that it provides authenticated DNS replies (which - by itself - is an improvement, even though it's no magic wand that, alone, solves the cert trust issue), but there are legitimate concerns that need to be taken care of before it becomes really useful."
[ Parent
| on HN ]
"DNSSEC improves the situation" is (a) false and (b) a concession to the narrative that DNSSEC is worth doing.
Someone actively engaged in trying to prevent centralization of Internet trust, and decoupling it from the Five Eyes governments --- a worthy goal, I think --- should be adamantly against DNSSEC. But here's Snowden doing the opposite.
It's not because Snowden is disingenuous. I think he's a true-believer. It's because he doesn't understand DNSSEC.