Re:Edward Snowden at IETF 93
by tptacek on Friday August 14, 2015 @12:20PM
(#10060983)
His support isn't lukewarm. Also: now, when DNSSEC is almost dead, is the most important time to ensure that it actually becomes fully dead. It's like a zombie. You have to cut off the head and burn the body. DNSSEC is still intact and twitching.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I wouldn't classify statements like "we gotta start somewhere and then we've got to iterate from that point" or "It's better than what we have today" as a call to action to drop everything and start implementing DNSSEC as-is right away. I would interpret it as "yes, DNSSEC improves the situation in that it provides authenticated DNS replies (which - by itself - is an improvement, even though it's no magic wand that, alone, solves the cert trust issue), but there are legitimate concerns that need to be taken care of before it becomes really useful."
"DNSSEC improves the situation" is (a) false and (b) a concession to the narrative that DNSSEC is worth doing.
Someone actively engaged in trying to prevent centralization of Internet trust, and decoupling it from the Five Eyes governments --- a worthy goal, I think --- should be adamantly against DNSSEC. But here's Snowden doing the opposite.
It's not because Snowden is disingenuous. I think he's a true-believer. It's because he doesn't understand DNSSEC.