Funny how the original Manifesto for Agile Software Development mentions individuals and interactions over processes and tools, yet we resort to the later to manage the former constantly. I would think by now the irony would at least be obvious.
Also, we're one of the few industries where our managers don't have the expertise of those they do manage. So its no wonder they try kindergarten management techniques.
I've had some awful managers in my career. One was formerly an elementary school teacher. She, very predictably, treated everyone like they were in elementary school, going so far as to give people gold stars for things. When called out on it, she confessed she really had no idea how to manage adults.
I've only had two excellent managers in my career, people who had studied management, were also technical, and cared about being effective at their jobs so the people they managed could be effective as well. These folks had formal training, undertaken of their own initiative, and it absolutely showed in all facets of what they did. Top notch folks!
I suspect this lack of training is an American phenomenon, but have no data to back up the claim.
Training is expensive and increased productivity is hard to measure - coupled together you see training as a cost with no tangible benefit.
They then just expect their employees to learn everything in their own time (which from your employers perspective, is free). There's a kind of horrifying logic to it really.
Managers start to feel like bosses when they don't have any technical background. The teams they manage are usually made up of juniors without much technical experience either, they'll be programmers rather than engineers reinforcing the "pop culture" Alan Kay talks about.
Actually, I would argue that most employees don't know what they want their manager to be. If they did, they would remember that and be better managers later.
I don't think that's true. I think most managers, however, when they become managers, learn what their managers expect them to be, which may not be what their employees want them to be.
If that's how stand-ups are treated then I'd say they're being done incorrectly. The point is to create visibility within the team. People know what's going on and can help, adjust their plans accordingly, etc. We do them even when the boss is out of the office.
All the agile talk is about empowering teams; yet the boss is monitoring every step. I'm with the OP; its another way to supervise.
Also, what is it with software developers that they allow themselves to get treated like children?
First we had to stand up every day and report what we did yesterday, you little child who we can't trust to work so we will micro-manage you.
Now you want us to put a smiley on a board every day like a pre-schooler so we can know when you're becoming a problem. Thank you, little software developer.