News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by jammycakes on Thursday August 13, 2015 @08:35AM (#10053624)
In all these discussions about Windows 10 phoning home, there are a couple of things that I haven't yet seen properly discussed.

1. Do the different versions of Windows (Home/Pro/Enterprise/Education) behave differently? If so, how?

2. Do the pro/enterprise versions behave differently when they're connected to a domain?

I'd imagine that the answer to at least one of these questions would be "yes." This kind of behaviour would be a deal-breaker in many enterprises.

Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by blackbeard on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:18AM (#10053907)
We have an enterprise edition VM in test and it appears to react the same as Pro at least. Haven't tried home.

What is scary is the lack of GPOs to turn this stuff off which you'd expect in an enterprise product. Technically we can't apply policy to make this compliant with our data protection requirements.

Their funeral to be honest.

Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by ultramancool on Thursday August 13, 2015 @11:21AM (#10054874)
There's actually some GPOs to turn this stuff off. I'm running Enterprise on my desktop... the problem is that many of them don't work or only disable the UI, but still connect out to random Microsoft servers. How the hell does Microsoft think that's acceptable in an "Enterprise" product?
Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by uxcn on Thursday August 13, 2015 @01:02PM (#10055618)
This was something I was wondering about. It seems like any company that has proprietary data to protect or privacy laws to comply with (most) don't even have a choice. I personally don't use Windows a lot, but even knowing that information was being sent out by default would be a deal breaker for me.

Can you give some examples of the stuff that does actually have switches?

Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by ultramancool on Thursday August 13, 2015 @01:15PM (#10055722)
> Can you give some examples of the stuff that does actually have switches?

Yeah, if you disable the Search thing in the start menu for example, it _does_ stop sending your queries to Bing. That switch does work. It just sends a bunch of tracking info instead.

On Enterprise, you can also disable telemetry which does appear to work.

Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by api on Thursday August 13, 2015 @02:06PM (#10056092)
You mean this will chase MS out of enterprise? Awesome! It means we don't have to support them anymore!

(Supporting Windows is 10X more work than all other platforms combined due to stupid "can't reproduce here" problems on rotted and unpatched Windows machines and general Windows driver API hell. I am including Android and less-commonly-used OSS operating systems like FreeBSD and OpenBSD.)

Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by blackbeard on Thursday August 13, 2015 @03:01PM (#10056439)
I feel your pain. This is my life.
Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by api on Thursday August 13, 2015 @06:45PM (#10057655)
If you're ever in Irvine, California, e-mail [email protected] for a beer.
Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by electricblue on Thursday August 13, 2015 @08:43AM (#10053674)
I'd like to know the difference between free upgrades and Win10 installs with a real product key
Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by DrPizza on Thursday August 13, 2015 @11:32AM (#10054953)
There's no difference (obviously).
Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by ConceptJunkie on Friday August 14, 2015 @10:47AM (#10060359)
There _should_ be no difference, but who knows? Who can be sure?

MS probably doesn't even know. I recall reading that there were 6 different versions of the Service Pack update for Office 2000 depending on where you got them from, and they weren't all compatible with each other. Do you think after another decade of Monkey Boy and his winning business strategy of pitting all the departments against each other that they've improved? Nardella actually seems like a grown-up, but he's still a dyed-in-the-wool Microsoft exec.... less stupid certainly, but just as evil.

One of the biggest problems with Microsoft is that they are too big and disorganized. They have no vision, and no guiding principle, other than maintaining the lingering shreds of their monopoly. This is obvious from looking at the designed-by-committee, piecemeal UI for Windows, which is getting worse every release and not better. The best you can hope for for any particular feature from release to release is that it's just arbitrarily different and not broken or hidden or completely removed.

Windows clearly peaked with XP, but their UI peaked with Windows 2000. The only reason 7 is liked is because they backed off most of the bad things they did with Vista, and the only thing, the _only_ thing I think is better in Windows 8 than any previous version is Task Manager, which is not something I use often. But it is nice.

My #1 wish for Windows post-7 is that I could just use the "Classic" theme, but apparently Windows is now too sophisticated to do what it could do 15 years ago. Their UX department has gone totally off the rails or maybe was taken over by wild monkeys. Microsoft used to be _the_ place for good UI design back in the 90s. They were very scientific about it, and their designs were very well-thought out, based on CUA, and an absurd amount of user-testing and most of all, consistent. Not perfect, but they were very good. But as soon as graphics cards could do more than 256 colors and Photoshop was invented, everyone went wild and UI became the lawless, Wild West funhouse it remains today. Except in the past few years, everyone decided that the "flat look" is cool (news flash: it's ugly and hard to make out) and now we have UIs that are as usable and good-looking as Windows 2, but without the consistency.

I'd thought Microsoft had run out of sharks to jump with Windows 8, but they keep finding more. But here's the thing. I still like Windows. I just wish I could make Windows look at work like it did when it looked and worked well (I'm not referring to the underlying technology, which is presumably improving all the time, although I still think Windows 8 is absurdly slow compared to 7 and much worse compared to XP... and I have empirical evidence. I do a lot of work in a Windows 2003 VM running on VirtualBox (long story) and it's much faster than the Windows 7 host and doesn't suffer from the, oh gee, everything's going to go "Not Responding" for 30 seconds to 2 minutes for no apparent reason that I see with the apps (at least MS apps) on the host.

Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by brudgers on Thursday August 13, 2015 @08:58AM (#10053764)
Discussions about differences in behavior among versions of Windows would not be as informative as a discussion of Windows in comparison to other OS's. Ubuntu bounces stuff off Canonical servers, iOS off Apple's iTunes and in-the-wild Android...well where to begin?

Facilitating high connectivity is what modern mass market operating systems do and Microsoft is playing catchup not leading a charge against anonymity. They couldn't if they wanted to. The commercial internet is built on tracking individuals and their behavior. I guess everyone would feel better if the Windows splash screen said "This OS Uses Cookies, by Continuing You Agree to Our TOS."

Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by Silhouette on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:06AM (#10053827)
Facilitating high connectivity is what modern mass market operating systems do

That's a bold claim, considering that until recently Windows was exactly what you used if you didn't want that kind of always-online emphasis and instead wanted to retain a degree of control and running your software locally.

Like many of the software companies moving in user-hostile directions, Microsoft's biggest competition is still themselves from a few years ago. And we know from both Vista and 8 that even Microsoft do not automatically have sufficient influence to get people to upgrade to a system that is perceived as being worse than what everyone already had.

[Edit: Perhaps instead of numerous people downvoting, someone could actually reply and say what they object to about this post? I don't think either my characterisation of Windows or my characterisation of Microsoft's competitive situation is unreasonable.]

Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by brudgers on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:27AM (#10053962)
Having owned 3.1, 95, 98, Me, 2000, XP, 7, and 8 boxes and been paid to use 2.0, NT and Vista, my experience has been that each version [except Me which was meh] has been significantly better...and the amount of improvement from version to version has been markedly increasing...that is, 8 a larger improvement on 7 than 7 was on Vista. People can legitimately disagree on the meaning of "user-hostile". If the way in which people have voted with their wallets in favor of convenience over anonymity, then the view that Microsoft's OS is user-hostile appears not to be in an ascendency [which I am not saying makes it wrong].
Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by Silhouette on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:39AM (#10054039)
If well-informed people have voted that way with their wallets, or otherwise, then I agree and of course that's their choice.

However, my big concerns with a lot of modern technologies are firstly that non-geek users don't understand what they are really signing up for and secondly that even if people do understand what they're signing up for it doesn't matter if effectively the only choices available to them all have the same problem.

I've lost track of how many friends and family have said just-plain-wrong things about what social networks do with their data, for example, or think that posting some comment on their Facebook page about how they don't consent to it will actually have any practical or legal effect.

And to pick on another example that's been much discussed recently, it won't matter that you have security and/or privacy objections to your car spying on you and phoning home with your location 24/7, if insurers are all offering car makers serious money to install those features, and since drivers are often required by law to have motor insurance they have no choice but to "opt in" if they want to drive at all. At that point, there is a complete failure of competition in the market, caused by the artificial distortion of having actual laws that constrain even well-informed people from making the choices they might otherwise prefer to make. We are fast heading that way with general computing as well, where for practical or even legal purposes we are required to do some things on-line, yet the only tools being offered to get us on-line come with these strings attached.

Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by brudgers on Thursday August 13, 2015 @10:29AM (#10054446)
I have an email address or two or more. Facebook, Google, Linkedin, Apple, Microsoft, etc. all have nodes in their graph irrespective of my use of their products or services. They have all read some fraction of my emails. There's location data on me going back potentially 18 years since I got my first cell phone. There's potentially IP logs going back to 1993 when I first went on the internet. I'm possibly in direct mail databases dating back to the early 1970's. Following the graph may lead to all last year's credit card charges of someone I worked with in 1987.

Windows 10 is a tempest in a teapot. It's removed the illusion of anonymity for some people. Not staying logged into Facebook just affects the ads that appear when I turn on JavaScript to see some web page. It doesn't remove my node from the graph. It doesn't even mean I'm leaking significantly less information, it just means that what I'm leaking is different.

Everyone thinks they're sophisticated. They're correct. The people collecting data are sophisticated too. That's why they brought an AFV to the shoving match. Running away from the firepower effectively means living the digital life of Stallman. Networks are networks because every resource announces its presence.

Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by Silhouette on Thursday August 13, 2015 @11:00AM (#10054689)
Running away from the firepower effectively means living the digital life of Stallman.

Writing as someone who has been the victim of a data-driven screw-up and spent several months of having life turned upside down while trying to fix it, I am increasingly wondering if Stallman has been right all along.

More practically, privacy is not a binary measure. We all interact with other people and organisations, and data gets shared as part of those interactions, and often there's nothing inherently wrong with that; some degree of communication is both desirable and inevitable. That doesn't mean we should just give up and condone covert collection, arbitrary sharing, and unrestricted use of personal data by whichever disproportionately powerful organisations can get hold of it.

For example, Facebook can't effectively follow me around the web. I have installed simple browser plug-ins that mean it is not technically possible using the usual techniques like phone-home Like buttons. The sites I visit would have to actively and covertly send data about my visit to Facebook behind the scenes, and most sites aren't going to do that.

For the record, I do also have a problem with the likes of Google being able to operate a mail service that is actively scanning things I wrote or even blocking messages I've sent to colleagues, which they can do if a recipient of my message uses their service. In effect, they have co-opted someone else to provide data I might have sent that person in confidence, just as mobile apps scan my name and number from a friend's address book often without even their knowledge never mind mine. (Of course that kind of action is probably already against the law in my country, but that doesn't matter very much unless the relevant authorities have the resources to enforce that law effectively.)

I believe almost everything is better when essential infrastructure is neutral and serves a specific purpose. Organisations like Google don't so much blur that line as totally erase it, and because I have no way to know that I am participating in their system in the first place, in practice I can't even choose not to send that e-mail to that recipient. I'm sad that Microsoft now appear to be joining that group.

Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by brudgers on Thursday August 13, 2015 @12:26PM (#10055350)
Privacy is a cluster concept. Implicitly, it includes the idea of constraints on others. The most effective constraint is that others simply don't care and that's most of what privacy boils down to accept in a few corner cases covered by legislation and the existence of legislation implies that in those cases others do indeed care and hence the legal restraint.

It is clear that Stallman was and is right in regards to the technical dimensions. It's not like we can go back to the time when email was private. STMP never was, that's why Stallman chose his course so long ago. Email is more private today thanks to STMPS. The same is true for HTTP/HTTPS. But even in the old days, there was nothing to prevent someone from publishing your love letters in the school newspaper. It was just more difficult.

Privacy generally breaks into security or anonymity. The issues surround either authorization and identification. Both have always been mostly limited by interest more than anything else. Computers have reduced the cost of being interested and so long as we use computers the djinn isn't going back in lamp.

Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by Silhouette on Thursday August 13, 2015 @01:04PM (#10055639)
Privacy generally breaks into security or anonymity.

Privacy is much more general than that. It is about having control of what information about you is shared, who has that data, and how it can be used.

The legal protections for privacy cover a lot more than just a few corner cases as well, but they lag behind what technology can do in 2015 and need updating.

Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by anonbanker on Thursday August 13, 2015 @10:04PM (#10058270)
Living the Stallman lifestyle is fantastic if you embrace minimalism. It's definitely doable with ARM and MIPS chips, along with (actually secure) cloud storage and encryption.

Should you feel the need to use evil apps like Facebook or Google+, make sure the 3 or 4 account names are random (but pass their filters), and that you make sure LOTS of people use those same accounts. Just understand that social media is a drug, and you are a drug addict.

Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by ConceptJunkie on Friday August 14, 2015 @10:52AM (#10060391)
Perhaps you weren't aware that Microsoft has a monopoly. They've been milking that since the early 90s. Sure, they lost that iron grip on mobile, but they are still a monopoly on the desktop. The number of organizations that aren't part of the Office Hegemony, and therefore Windows, is still a very small number. If you get rid of the Apple marketshare, it's probably in the low single-digits, percentage-wise... if it even breaks 1%.
Re:Even when told not to, Windows 10 doesn't stop talking to... by mtgx on Thursday August 13, 2015 @10:47AM (#10054591)
Only in Enterprise you can fully disable "telemetry", but just in all the other versions expect most of this stuff to call home by default and send data to Microsoft. I wouldn't assume the opposite by default if I were you.