News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Community service: Vetting my local library's children's ... by pbhjpbhj on Thursday August 13, 2015 @07:08AM (#10053327)
Yes, what struck me was that a book that is inaccurate due to subsequent increases in knowledge of the solar system is not necessarily wrong for the date of publication. A book - which is mentioned - that gives current [to the date of publication] theories is particularly interesting because this sort of information often seems to get lost and only the winning theory gets well recorded.

These sorts of books seem like a great educational opportunity helping kids to realise that not everything is known and what we think we know can be challenged and found wanting. It also quite clearly illustrates the problems of source materials in history.

So, it's right that information that is factually wrong gets separated but the approach as presented in the article seems narrow-minded.

One can't help but reflect on what will happen to the books she vetoes, they may well get passed on to third-world countries; I'm pretty sure that happens with "discarded from stock" books in the UK.

Re:Community service: Vetting my local library's children's ... by rotten on Thursday August 13, 2015 @07:20AM (#10053364)
On the other hand, some kid who is researching a report for school may actually need factual and accurate information. It seems possible they'll use the web to fill in the gap, but a lot of parents are very reserved about letting elementary school kids use the web, and many teachers require library research as part of the reports.

For that matter, suppose some kid compares what he learns on the web to what he learns in a library? He'll find the library is inaccurate and out of date and not to be trusted. A relic of days gone by. Soon he'll be part of a generation that sees no point in having libraries and our entire library system will be in jeopardy.

Re:Community service: Vetting my local library's children's ... by pbhjpbhj on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:14AM (#10053881)
Quoting myself:

>"it's right that information that is factually wrong gets separated" //

Addressing your second para, they'll find that the information doesn't tally, that doesn't mean the library is wrong necessarily - if you compare 2 websites you're as likely to find a conflict. Looking at publication dates and other indicators is an important part of research; realising a 1970s book won't have the latest info on Mars is a very important part of research and part of the process that children should go through. Insulating kids from the issues of verifying sources is right at some level (hence my comment quoted above) but ultimately one wants to have pupils finding conflicting sources.

Re:Community service: Vetting my local library's children's ... by maus42 on Thursday August 13, 2015 @03:49PM (#10056746)
I agree that the library should make sure that there's up-to-date information around for this. However, surely one of the purposes of doing library research for school would be to teach to take things like "when this book was published" into account.

For a bright student (older age groups especially) it might even proivde an opportunity to remark on how old theories get updated when there's new information available. Sending probes serves a purpose.