Re:Community service: Vetting my local library's children's ...
by pbhjpbhj on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:14AM
(#10053881)
Quoting myself:
>"it's right that information that is factually wrong gets separated" //
Addressing your second para, they'll find that the information doesn't tally, that doesn't mean the library is wrong necessarily - if you compare 2 websites you're as likely to find a conflict. Looking at publication dates and other indicators is an important part of research; realising a 1970s book won't have the latest info on Mars is a very important part of research and part of the process that children should go through. Insulating kids from the issues of verifying sources is right at some level (hence my comment quoted above) but ultimately one wants to have pupils finding conflicting sources.
>"it's right that information that is factually wrong gets separated" //
Addressing your second para, they'll find that the information doesn't tally, that doesn't mean the library is wrong necessarily - if you compare 2 websites you're as likely to find a conflict. Looking at publication dates and other indicators is an important part of research; realising a 1970s book won't have the latest info on Mars is a very important part of research and part of the process that children should go through. Insulating kids from the issues of verifying sources is right at some level (hence my comment quoted above) but ultimately one wants to have pupils finding conflicting sources.