GUIdebook sadly only goes up to 10.3 Tiger – would be really great if someone would pick up the work.
(I especially like GUIdebook’s comparisons of different system components like here: http://www.guidebookgallery.org/screenshots/splash I would argue that it’s immediately obvious which is the classy OS :)
Re:Mac OS Evolution: From System 1.0 to Snow Leopard
by Poiesis on Saturday December 19, 2009 @04:11PM
(#1005209)
I feel old.
Up until a few years ago I had original, shrinkwrapped Copland (what was to be the new Mac OS, pre-Next acquisition) demo disks. That isn't to say it was working code or anything, it was more of a promo "here's what it's gonna look like".
I'm so glad Copland didn't work out. Funny thing is, I actually have owned only Windows machines since about Mac OS 7 or 8, so I essentially haven't gotten to use the Mac since it's actually had the more modern architecture.
I do have an iPhone, though, so I guess that counts. :)
Re:Mac OS Evolution: From System 1.0 to Snow Leopard
by NathanKP on Saturday December 19, 2009 @02:33PM
(#1005064)
The oldest Mac system that I remember using was System 7.0. The screenshots took me back to the good old days when I was child in elementary school, playing around with Kid Pix. I remember I used to love using the "explode" tool.
Re:Mac OS Evolution: From System 1.0 to Snow Leopard
by stevejohnson on Saturday December 19, 2009 @05:34PM
(#1005317)
I'm slowly working on a similar app. It's not polished enough to even call it a beta yet, but you can check it out at [1]. I've got a nice tool plugin API, but my graphics system needs work. Improvements are in the works.
Re:Mac OS Evolution: From System 1.0 to Snow Leopard
by boucher on Saturday December 19, 2009 @07:16PM
(#1005454)
It's been so long that recalling all the reasons KidPix made me happy would be impossible. But I can remember spending hours using that app, doodling, making little movies, and just enjoying everything about it. Little touches like the "Oh No!" sound effect made the app so much fun to use.
The app was bought (along with the rest of Broderbund's IP) and resurrected a couple years ago:
Re:Mac OS Evolution: From System 1.0 to Snow Leopard
by rbanffy on Saturday December 19, 2009 @05:03PM
(#1005273)
Actually, the System lineage died with MacOS 9. Rhapsody and OSX are really direct descendants of NeXTSTEP and, thus, are a completely different family. OS 9 lived on, for some time, as a subsystem of OSX for PowerPC.
Re:Mac OS Evolution: From System 1.0 to Snow Leopard
by blahedo on Saturday December 19, 2009 @07:35PM
(#1005482)
True, especially if you're looking at what's "under the hood". But visually, there are a lot of continuities between the two, and of course the user base largely transitioned as if 9->X were just another upgrade like going from 6.0.7 to System 7.
Re:Mac OS Evolution: From System 1.0 to Snow Leopard
by rmason on Saturday December 19, 2009 @03:56PM
(#1005183)
Steve Jobs in his first meeting with execs after he came back said Apple products had lost their sex appeal. Take a look at the leap Mac OS made after he returned.
Re:Mac OS Evolution: From System 1.0 to Snow Leopard
by ja2ke on Saturday December 19, 2009 @07:14PM
(#1005451)
This is a great reminder of what's stayed the same more than what's different. Or, at least, how gradual the change has been. The jump from 9.x to 10.0 is surprisingly subtle compared to the jump from 9.x to Snow Leopard.
Re:Mac OS Evolution: From System 1.0 to Snow Leopard
by adamc on Saturday December 19, 2009 @03:36PM
(#1005156)
Wow, that was really a trip down memory lane. The first mac I ever owned (a Mac Plus) was System 6... inits and cdevs. I had a lot of fun learning to program on one.
Re:Mac OS Evolution: From System 1.0 to Snow Leopard
by city41 on Saturday December 19, 2009 @02:56PM
(#1005094)
I went to art school and was a designer for a short stint, where Macs completely ruled supreme. I learned and completely grocked the living hell out of OS7, 8 and 8.5. Despite their incredibly archaic architecture under the hood, they are still probably my favorite operating system. Interface wise, OSX has actually been a step back in a lot of ways.
Re:Mac OS Evolution: From System 1.0 to Snow Leopard
by ax0n on Saturday December 19, 2009 @04:57PM
(#1005264)
Really? The menu bar at the top is basically the same, albeit squishier than before. They added a dock, and a ton of chrome. I'm not seeing how anything was "a step back" by any means. The only irk I really have is lack of keyboard navigation on dialog boxen. I should be able to hit tab or arrow keys or something to switch between buttons on dialogs (example: the shutdown menu) - but that's always been the case, it's nothing new. Care to elaborate, or even take to task some of my assertions?
Re:Mac OS Evolution: From System 1.0 to Snow Leopard
by dchest on Saturday December 19, 2009 @06:21PM
(#1005372)
Control+F7 (or System Preferences > Keyboard Shortcuts > Full Keyboard Access: All Controls). Then use Tab and Shift+Tab.
Also, for shutdown dialog (and other) navigation is not needed at all: Return = default button (Shut Down), Space = alternate (focused) button (Cancel).
Re:Mac OS Evolution: From System 1.0 to Snow Leopard
by ax0n on Saturday December 19, 2009 @10:58PM
(#1005713)
That tip on full keyboard access is pure win. If I could up-mod this comment a dozen times, I would! Many thanks! This has pestered me for about a decade now.
Re:Mac OS Evolution: From System 1.0 to Snow Leopard
by unalone on Saturday December 19, 2009 @03:55PM
(#1005179)
I'm in art school right now, and OS X was my first Mac. Would you mind telling me what you liked about older OS's that OS X doesn't have? I probably missed a generation of great ideas and I'd like to know what they were.
Re:Mac OS Evolution: From System 1.0 to Snow Leopard
by pc on Saturday December 19, 2009 @03:29PM
(#1005144)
This really drives home how bad the space-based ("Aurora"?) theme of 10.5 and 10.6 is: when we look at this in ten years, I think the screenshots of 10.5 and 10.6 will have aged the worst.
There's something timeless about the earlier Mac OS versions. 10.5 and 10.6 are just kitschy.
Re:Mac OS Evolution: From System 1.0 to Snow Leopard
by unalone on Saturday December 19, 2009 @03:55PM
(#1005178)
Really? I have the exact opposite reaction. Every development in OS X has made itself more subtle. Gradients are lighter, windows are softer... The unified 10.5 theme got rid of what I felt was a kitschy plastic feel in the system, and it created a much more intuitive menu set-up where buttons are a part of the top bar. 10.6 takes steps even further — I love the new Dock menus and hope that's the standard from which Apple develops its new look. Some things moved backwards — the new iTunes got more gradient-y and that's an issue — but in general Apple's design is growing more and more subtle.
The default backgrounds are a little silly, yes, but I think when we look back we'll view it like we view 60s typography — perhaps a bit gaudier than we needed, but it was done in a sense of fun rather than a sense of self-importance. The space-age design feels to me like a wink.
Re:Mac OS Evolution: From System 1.0 to Snow Leopard
by nonrecursive on Saturday December 19, 2009 @03:47PM
(#1005171)
I don't know, I don't really feel like an OS needs to look timeless. It seems strange to me to judge an OS's appearance based on how it will look in 10 years, when hardly anyone will care anyway.
Re:Mac OS Evolution: From System 1.0 to Snow Leopard
by blahedo on Saturday December 19, 2009 @07:39PM
(#1005488)
Agreed, but it's mostly in that awful background---I ditched that first thing, and everything else is pretty well in continuity with the previous versions.
GUIdebook sadly only goes up to 10.3 Tiger – would be really great if someone would pick up the work.
(I especially like GUIdebook’s comparisons of different system components like here: http://www.guidebookgallery.org/screenshots/splash I would argue that it’s immediately obvious which is the classy OS :)
Up until a few years ago I had original, shrinkwrapped Copland (what was to be the new Mac OS, pre-Next acquisition) demo disks. That isn't to say it was working code or anything, it was more of a promo "here's what it's gonna look like".
I'm so glad Copland didn't work out. Funny thing is, I actually have owned only Windows machines since about Mac OS 7 or 8, so I essentially haven't gotten to use the Mac since it's actually had the more modern architecture.
I do have an iPhone, though, so I guess that counts. :)
Apple sure has changed a lot since then.
(I love KidPix)
[1] http://www.steveasleep.com/splatterboard
The app was bought (along with the rest of Broderbund's IP) and resurrected a couple years ago:
http://www.mackiev.com/kid_pix.html
Not sure if it lives up to the original.
Anyone remember the OS X beta with the blue apple in the middle of the menu bar? Yikes.
Also, for shutdown dialog (and other) navigation is not needed at all: Return = default button (Shut Down), Space = alternate (focused) button (Cancel).
While OS X may be prettier than earlier MacOSes, conceptually, it's much closer to Windows than to the MacOS spirit.
There's something timeless about the earlier Mac OS versions. 10.5 and 10.6 are just kitschy.
The default backgrounds are a little silly, yes, but I think when we look back we'll view it like we view 60s typography — perhaps a bit gaudier than we needed, but it was done in a sense of fun rather than a sense of self-importance. The space-age design feels to me like a wink.
*I exaggerate a little, but I really didn't have a computer until right around this time, and it wasn't a mac.