News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by StavrosK on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @11:57AM (#10048440)
My thoughts exactly. How different from OS X can it be?
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by kitsunesoba on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @12:59PM (#10048960)
The biggest difference is that they'd have to write a new Qt or GTK+ UI.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by StavrosK on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @01:03PM (#10048997)
What's the UI written in now? Doesn't Qt work for all three platforms?
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by kitsunesoba on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @01:09PM (#10049053)
It's using Cocoa on OS X and WPF on Windows, in other words the UI toolkits that are native to their respective platforms. Qt indeed works everywhere, but by using it you make the tradeoff that your app doesn't really feel native anywhere (except maybe on Linux with KDE).

In short, using Qt would mean making concessions on UI quality.

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by cben on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @08:42AM (#10078857)
I find it hard to look at their windows UI and think "native".

I'm wrong, as it was explicitly designed in windows 8's "Metro" style in mind [https://github.com/blog/1151-designing-github-for-windows]. Nevertheless, the concept of a "native" windows style is currently such a mixed mess that I can't bring myself to think of this app as "native". I don't see why being native to Metro is desirable enough to give up the convenience of having a single cross-platform app.

[I'm not saying I don't like the design, I do. It's just that I care about its features — simplicity and github integration — as something I can recommend to git newbies — much more that "nativeness".]

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by dharma1 on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @09:45PM (#10051884)
I don't think non-cocoa or non-WPF necessarily means worse quality, you just have to do a bit more custom work. Take Slack (using the Electron framework), or Telegram's Qt client.

Having said that, Qt Quick Controls could definitely be improved by having better default desktop QML UI widgets.

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by kitsunesoba on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @10:15PM (#10051948)
I use Slack on a daily basis and I can't say I'm happy with it being an Electron app. For what it does it's very resource intensive and the way it disregards a lot of its host OS conventions isn't cool. If I wanted a web app I'd open another browser tab; there's no need for a goofy wrapper with half-hearted OS integration.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by dharma1 on Thursday August 13, 2015 @08:09AM (#10053520)
I also use it daily, and agree with what you are saying about it being a resource hog. That said, I find it pretty good for the most part, and being cross-platform for free is killer.

I'm on OSX and Linux, most of my team are on Linux, I'm not sure they would have taken the trouble to release a Linux version without Electron.

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by StavrosK on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @01:12PM (#10049079)
Hmm, weird, I thought Qt was pretty good at the native look and feel. Thanks for the info!
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by chrisseaton on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @02:25PM (#10049636)
I think the problem is that in user interfaces pretty good can be a million miles from good. It's like the uncanny valley in animation - the app feels wrong or ill but I can't quite tell why and it's very off-putting.

But maybe I'm too snobby about user interfaces.

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by Rapzid on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @05:04PM (#10050604)
I'm surprised they didn't build this on electron...
[deleted]
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by StavrosK on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @12:33PM (#10048771)
Huh? My question is "how hard is porting this to Linux, if there's already an OS X version?".
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by blkhp19 on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @02:23PM (#10049614)
OS X and Linux are not the same OS. The entire stack for writing GUI applications is completely different - as different as writing an iOS app vs. an Android app. OS X and Linux don't share the same kernel, the same foundation frameworks, or the same UI frameworks. The entire application would have to be written from scratch. If they're really ambitious they could probably share some Objective-C business logic, but anything that touches the UI is platform specific.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by StavrosK on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @02:27PM (#10049649)
They have a Windows version. Linux isn't less like OS X than Windows is.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by blkhp19 on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @03:37PM (#10050108)
Just because you can type "sudo" on both doesn't make them similar when it comes to making GUI applications. Again, the frameworks are completely different, meaning that a complete or nearly complete rewrite would be necessary.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by StavrosK on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @03:43PM (#10050145)
Again, not more than the one needed for Windows.
Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by eropple on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @04:31PM (#10050417)
Windows has an order of magnitude more users, and probably comparatively even more money than that.

The first step to getting commercially-focused software on your desktop OS of choice is being a desirable market to cater to.

Re: GitHub Desktop is now available by victorhooi on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @09:38PM (#10051869)
They are using the Cocoa toolkit on OSX - that is a Mac-specific thing and isn't available on Linux.