Re:Show HN: Shape-powered movie search
by bgnm2000 on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @02:02PM
(#10043128)
Our DB is still growing - but more importantly, a full max shape will be unlikely to yield results - as a perfect average is also unlikely. Movies only appear when their dimension is equal to or greater than the shape you search by.
Re:Show HN: Shape-powered movie search
by dvirsky on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @02:06PM
(#10043160)
I was just joking, of course, but it is my favorite movie of all time, and it does rank very highly on all dimensions IMO :) Anyway, nice project. What are you using for auto-completion?
Re:Show HN: Shape-powered movie search
by deluvas on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @10:54AM
(#10041486)
I've found a movie that caught my attention, but I couldn't find any link to the imdb page - I wanted to read more about it, so I decided to select the title c/p and Google it - but what do you know, you can't select text.
Re:Show HN: Shape-powered movie search
by hanniabu on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @09:43AM
(#10040965)
Pretty cool idea, but I haven't seen enough of these movies to know how well it's working though.
One problem I kept having is that the focus would get stuck in a different point than the one I'm trying to move. Sometimes the focus would be on a point that wasn't even the last point I moved.
Re:Show HN: Shape-powered movie search
by sp332 on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @01:12PM
(#10042690)
I don't think it works well. It has Erroll Flynn's Robin Hood as very rewatchable (I liked it but it's not that rewatchable). Also Seven Samurai and Monty Python's Holy Grail as having very low rewatchability... as if.
Re:Show HN: Shape-powered movie search
by bgnm2000 on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @02:04PM
(#10043140)
Right now the results are based on ratings - so we only have a couple hundred users - all of which have not rated every movie. This is mostly a proof of concept until the rating counts grow.
Re:Show HN: Shape-powered movie search
by bgnm2000 on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @02:13PM
(#10043221)
We use the free TMDB API. I'm not sure I understand what you're about how to rate a movie? The full shape is a perfect movie, and an empty shape would be a terrible movie.
Re:Show HN: Shape-powered movie search
by sp332 on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @01:23PM
(#10042782)
I think it's more about priority. You might want to see a Romeo & Juliet movie with good characters even if it's not original. Lots of mystery movies have surprise endings and aren't rewatchable. You might feel interested in a super-original movie even if it's not very enjoyable.
Re:Show HN: Shape-powered movie search
by bgnm2000 on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @02:02PM
(#10043131)
This is exactly right - we like movies for different reasons, and pick things to watch based on those contexts - so thats what shape search focuses on.
Re:Show HN: Shape-powered movie search
by IanCal on Thursday August 13, 2015 @06:20AM
(#10053164)
I think this is more just about the wording, but a choice of "enjoyable or not" doesn't make much sense to me. If I'm after something really original, I'll enjoy it because it's original. I "enjoy" watching sad documentaries. A split between enjoyable or not is equivalent to "do you want a film you will like" to me. The converse of most of the options seem like universally negative ways of describing a film. Changing enjoyable to fun would make more sense to me, I'm definitely sometimes in the mood for fun films and other times in the mood for serious films. I may also choose between simple and complex films, for example.
To be more constructive, to emphasise the tradeoffs, perhaps you can't have everything maxed out? Force more of a decision between things.
Re:Show HN: Shape-powered movie search
by bgnm2000 on Wednesday August 12, 2015 @11:34AM
(#10048272)
Thanks! In the search by shape you should be able to set a time-range, but we wouldn't make an axis for it in the shape itself as it probably wouldn't impact the experience of the movie on universal / timeless scale.
I'm curious, what did you do to try to find it?
Please fix this.
One problem I kept having is that the focus would get stuck in a different point than the one I'm trying to move. Sometimes the focus would be on a point that wasn't even the last point I moved.
Few questions:
How many movies list do you have? I mean this will able to let me know that there are few movies which this site might not be showing.
And how do you rate a movie in different corners of the shape?
* isn't enjoyable
* is unoriginal
* I wouldn't want to watch it more than once
* has poor characters
* no story
Splits between serious / silly, or sad/happy might make more sense.
To be more constructive, to emphasise the tradeoffs, perhaps you can't have everything maxed out? Force more of a decision between things.