News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:G is for Google by Spooky23 on Monday August 10, 2015 @06:27PM (#10037864)
Fiber is the hint about what this really means. Capital intense businesses like ISPs or car companies are expensive to operate and the financials would drag down Google.

In this model, the big shareholders get to dilute risks in these ventures, while retaining the ability to exponentially increase their personal wealth.

Re:G is for Google by vonmoltke on Monday August 10, 2015 @06:35PM (#10037920)
This reorganization makes no difference on the financials. The release explicitly stated the company is trading at the conglomerate level.
Re:G is for Google by fredkbloggs on Monday August 10, 2015 @09:16PM (#10038561)
Right, this is about power. Specifically, it makes clear that Larry and Sergei are now in the capital allocation business. When you buy a share of Alphabet, you are buying shares in Larry and Sergei's opinion about what should be done with money. If you think they're much better at spending money than you are, this is a great opportunity. If you don't, it isn't.
Re:G is for Google by minthd on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @05:41AM (#10039901)
>> If you think they're much better at spending money than you are, this is a great opportunity. If you don't, it isn't.

It's not that one-dimensional . Their company does have resources that enable them to do things you and others cannot do.

Re:G is for Google by chetanahuja on Monday August 10, 2015 @09:31PM (#10038604)
Well you're still mostly investing in the growth potential of Google's existing businesses. Don't forget that Alphabet still completely owns all the money-making businesses of Google.
Re:G is for Google by fredkbloggs on Monday August 10, 2015 @09:39PM (#10038632)
Wrong. You cannot have your profits and let someone reallocate them for you too.

You would be right if you owned a controlling interest, but you don't. Because you don't, all the profits of the money-making businesses go where Larry and Sergey want them to go. That's not (necessarily) going to be your pockets. If you owned a controlling interest, you could throw them out if you're unhappy with their performance as capital allocators, but you don't and you can't. So those profits are worth little or nothing to you, both now and in the future, because you aren't entitled to receive them.

Re:G is for Google by mattlutze on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @07:40AM (#10040273)
> So those profits are worth little or nothing to you, both now and in the future, because you aren't entitled to receive them.

You invest in a company assuming it will increase its value over the time you hold your fraction of ownership. Parent isn't saying you're entitled to dividends, but was observing that the decision to buy Alphabet stock will likely mostly be made on the expectation of the money-making businesses continuing to grow, and only minor-ly on the hope that one or more of the ventures takes off and significantly increase company value.

Perhaps I'm reading it wrong but I didn't see an expectation of dividends in the parent's comment.

Re:G is for Google by hluska on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @01:43AM (#10039290)
This is only true if:

a) Neither executive nor any member of the board has any concept of fiduciary duty.

b) They can keep any mismanagement out of audited financial statements.

Re:G is for Google by fredkbloggs on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @09:28AM (#10040859)
Malice is not required. All they have to do is be wrong.
Re:G is for Google by Ankaios on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @12:17AM (#10039062)
That was already clear.
Re:G is for Google by S4M on Monday August 10, 2015 @06:41PM (#10037952)
Yes, I guess the ones that are getting affected are the Google (not Alphabet) employees, since now it must be much more complicated for an engineer working on a Google project to be transferred to something more sexy such as the Self Driving Car. Disclaimer: I don't work at Google and don't know anybody who does, so I might be totally off.
Re:G is for Google by trhway on Monday August 10, 2015 @09:01PM (#10038507)
i guess the employees will now also get a clear feel who of them is "maker" and who is "taker" :)

By the way - who is inheriting the piles of money accumulated in the tax heavens? I think that is another elephant in the room. The GoogleX+Fiber+... is obviously a money hungry black hole, so would they be able now to redirect/invest this money from abroad straight into hat loss generating business without incurring the taxes?

Re:G is for Google by joshstaiger on Monday August 10, 2015 @10:02PM (#10038696)
Only if it is invested offshore. If it comes back to the US, it will be taxed. Same situation as before.
Re:G is for Google by 001sky on Monday August 10, 2015 @08:29PM (#10038399)
While you are right in your comment, in so far as what you have written, the implication that [this] "reorganization makes no difference on the financials" is not strictly speaking true.

Going forward, this re-organization may very well allow capital allocation to be done at various legal entities a-la project or structured finance. That way, the risk/return of the various projects can be traded on more efficiently to the benefit of both investors and google/alphabet shareholders.

This is relevant in the larger context for asset intensive, long-time maturity investment areas --like fiber, self driving cars, etc -- that have fundamentally different economics than the core business (search/ads/youtube etc).

Re:G is for Google by eldavido on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @12:53AM (#10039158)
This is a good point in an otherwise PR- and spin-heavy announcement. If Google plans to pursue capital-intensive projects a la Fiber, it'd be better to have those separated to allow use of (much cheaper) debt capital collateralized by very narrow slices of the business. Is this what you mean by "project finance"? I've heard that term before but not sure what it means.
Re:G is for Google by anjc on Monday August 10, 2015 @09:01PM (#10038513)
> That way, the risk/return of the various projects can be traded on more efficiently to the benefit of both investors and google/alphabet shareholders.

How would this make any difference for the costing of projects (or businesses, now)? In terms of risks and returns. Its not like new businesses under Alphabet will be boostrapped, they'll still be the same drain/boon on resources that they always were.

Re:G is for Google by SapphireSun on Monday August 10, 2015 @10:00PM (#10038690)
Not if they allow sub-ventures to be financed semi-independently.
Re:G is for Google by moritzplassnig on Monday August 10, 2015 @06:51PM (#10038002)
It will have an impact - they will break out the Google Financials in Q4 & overall be more transparent about the different projects.
Re:G is for Google by Spooky23 on Monday August 10, 2015 @07:46PM (#10038231)
It will when Google is manufacturing cars, or is joint venturing with a car company to manufacture them.

The Google guys are smart. You don't do something like this without a long term strategic aim.

Re:G is for Google by johnchristopher on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @05:28AM (#10039857)
What about this post from a month ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9889942

> There is no strategy. The thought of Google having a central product management strategy -- and successfully executing it across many teams -- is hilarious to people who work there. It's chaos that outsiders try to read into.

This is a consequence of bad internal economics and incentives. Google PMs and engineers are incentivized to create new products and ship them by quarterly deadlines (perf/promo cycles) rather than align their teams towards a cohesive user experience. Thinking this way would occasionally cause teams to, gasp, not build a product they wanted to build. Everyone needs to ship something, ideally something new. After all, you don't get promoted for deciding not to build something. I've seen awful products/implementations go out the door and get killed or reimplemented soon thereafter. And people still list these as "achievements" on promotion packets (and they get promoted despite the product failing!).

The company is kind of trying to address this by changing promotion criteria, but it's culturally ingrained and won't change for some time.

Re:G is for Google by fixermark on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @08:07AM (#10040362)
It's one anon's opinion based on their observation and may not be reflective of a larger reality.
Re:G is for Google by toomuchtodo on Monday August 10, 2015 @09:45PM (#10038651)
There was speculation on the last Tesla call that they're going to do another equity round (to which Elon said he couldn't comment). Would be interesting if this was part of the strategy, as Tesla is extremely capital intensive at the moment with the gigafactory and other manufacturing spend. Google almost did acquire Tesla before it's successful Hail Mary in 2013, so the idea isn't without merit.
Re:G is for Google by dragonwriter on Thursday August 13, 2015 @03:21PM (#10056576)
> This reorganization makes no difference on the financials.

In the short term, it doesn't. But it may be preparation for something in the longer term that does.

Re:G is for Google by anjc on Monday August 10, 2015 @08:54PM (#10038489)
Google could go public though, right? (The new Google)
Re:G is for Google by justincormack on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @04:45AM (#10039741)
No they need the cash it produces to finance the rest of the businesses.
Re:G is for Google by dragonwriter on Thursday August 13, 2015 @03:24PM (#10056594)
They could get that through dividends even if Google went public.
Re:G is for Google by xbmcuser on Monday August 10, 2015 @11:34PM (#10038958)
It wont as they dont need it to Google Fiber on the other hand need capital investments so probably will.
Re:G is for Google by arihant on Monday August 10, 2015 @06:40PM (#10037946)
I don't think there would be a difference on financials. Alphabet is worth exactly as the old Google, and is currently operating exact same businesses.

Separating Fiber is important for other reasons, most notably, saving themselves from conflict of interest/anti-trust lawsuits.

Re:G is for Google by eldavido on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @12:57AM (#10039173)
No it isn't. Clearly Google's management believes the new structure is accretive to shareholder value otherwise they wouldn't have done it.

I really wonder about this though. Conglomerates have a mixed track record [1] and from where I sit, it's not clear Larry/Sergey are better capital allocators than the public markets.

[1] Brealey & Myers "Corporate Finance" has a good section on this topic, comparing big Asian conglomerates like Samsung, LG, Yahama, etc. to American public companies over time.

Re:G is for Google by Aloha on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @02:57AM (#10039455)
Regulatory costs can be an huge drain on long term profits, and I'd count anti-trust as a regulatory cost.
Re:G is for Google by setpatchaddress on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @01:05AM (#10039193)
Nope. If there's an antitrust issue (I'm not saying there is), it's still all the same company to the DOJ. Google is too visible to play that particular shell game and get away with it.

If this was in preparation for spinning Fiber off, sure.

Re:G is for Google by T2_t2 on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @05:23AM (#10039851)
Which might make sense. Perhaps more broadly, they see the advertising entities as a whole that is complete, e.g. the value of these is strong, and not likely to be anything more than incremental (in the case of Youtube, that increment is still likely thousands of percents) nor to need any capital or debt for the foreseeable future.

Fiber, cars et al could be spun off, which would create share holder value without dividends, and allow these units to leverage debt rather than capital. Cars, Fiber, the WiFi balloons, could all be spun off at a point where they need capital and debt, and not drag down Alphabet.

Fiber with an IPO and access to debt as its own needs dictate might grow a lot faster than fiber waiting for capital from Google.

Maybe that is Google's plan: get them ready for IPO, then set them free and take an interest?