News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GitHub Puts Open Code of Conduct on Pause by zxcvcxz on Saturday August 08, 2015 @12:15PM (#10027697)
hugs plonh
Re:GitHub Puts Open Code of Conduct on Pause by ipsin on Saturday August 08, 2015 @12:21PM (#10027725)
Thanks, that's what I immediately thought.

If you know someone or have formed any kind of relationship with them, that sort of "virtual hug" can be appropriate, but in other contexts it can be a pretty damn creepy way to push buttons.

This is me violating your personal space.

Re:GitHub Puts Open Code of Conduct on Pause by xiaoma on Saturday August 08, 2015 @12:46PM (#10027832)
In Latino cultures, a hug would be completely appropriate. Why is it your culture that gets to decide? I find that attitude in itself offensive, especially considering we're talking about text.

If you get creeped out by even a virtual hug and see more open people as violators, that's your problem, not theirs.

Re:GitHub Puts Open Code of Conduct on Pause by d9h549f34w6 on Saturday August 08, 2015 @01:01PM (#10027888)
Exactly. I think this is the aspect that's "rubbed me the wrong way" about this CoC thing. I don't come from a culture where workplace physical contact would be seen as acceptable, but I'm not about to claim that that's some sort of human universal without a lot more research.

The sense I get from GitHub's CoC effort is that it's attempting to codify supposedly universal modes of proper human interaction without recognizing that it's sourced in a specific, local culture.

Re:GitHub Puts Open Code of Conduct on Pause by ipsin on Saturday August 08, 2015 @09:02PM (#10029152)
I will plead ignorance here. In Latino cultures, the individual is not allowed to refuse a hug from a stranger? Or it's considered to be extremely rude and insulting to do so?

Please lay it out for me, in as much detail as you're comfortable providing.

Re:GitHub Puts Open Code of Conduct on Pause by alextgordon on Saturday August 08, 2015 @12:52PM (#10027855)
It's an obvious restatement of American christian values. Any physical contact is implicitly sexually charged, and so even a reference to it is objectionable.

Of course if we're going to apply one religiously-inspired value system, then why not Saudi Arabian values?

Re:GitHub Puts Open Code of Conduct on Pause by bakabaka9 on Sunday August 09, 2015 @03:24AM (#10029769)
I second that. Not wearing towel on head sure is offensive! :)
Re:GitHub Puts Open Code of Conduct on Pause by skarap on Saturday August 08, 2015 @12:45PM (#10027825)
But it's not the only possible way to violate someone's personal space (or be creepy) in an internet discussion. You could say "Last night had this strange dream where you were being eaten by lion" or "I think I'll make a poster with your photo and put it on my bedroom ceiling". The possibilities are endless.

So you can either disallow all personal communication allowing only professional/on-topic stuff (maybe also making everyone use Esperanto so there are no misunderstandings) or you have real humans judging if someone is being a jerk based on their own understanding what "jerk" means.

The later is how the real world was doing it for thousands of years (though this is also changing). When a child goes to school she/he is expected to behave in some normal way - parents are supposed to help create that behavior when upbringing the child. And if at school the child does something bad, they call the parents and then the parents are expected to explain the child why it is bad and make sure that doesn't happen again.

Summoning the parents is (unfortunately) not an option here, but warning and banning people should work.