A very big problem is that drug dogs will alert when the handler gives it subtle clues. This is done to get probable cause for a search when there is nothing more than an officer's hunch or just a desire to hassle a particular individual.
The primary trouble I see is that there is no penalty for re-training dogs like this.
>This is done to get probable cause for a search when there is nothing more than an officer's hunch or just a desire to hassle a particular individual.
that claims that this is done purposefully. That's what I was wondering about, not the overall efficacy of drug dogs.
https://youtu.be/w-WMn_zHCVo?t=3m35s
It happens.
http://www.ucdmc.ucdavis.edu/welcome/features/2010-2011/02/2...
There are many examples that have been caught on camera, I see that another commenter posted a link to one of them on this thread.
When you see things like the handler returning to a previously cleared spot and indicating that the dog should check it again; three or four times until the dog alerts, you can assume that the handler has a severe short term memory problem and he just forgot that the dog had previously checked the area and failed to alert. I think it's more indicative of the officer hinting to the dog that "this is where I want you to alert" and their training reinforces the idea that if the dog does what's expected, there will be a treat.
My last dog picked up on so many of my personality traits/tells-- I felt quilty.
(My cat--whole nother story.)
Even more so, I think that is actually what is happening here. An officer is acting as a tier 1 filter, and then the drug dog is acting as a tier 2 filter, further reducing the number of false positives, which in a "legal and ethical" sense, we generally feel are worse than false negatives.
If the officer is acting as a filter, then it seems to me like this is a search, and not allowable, because it would be subject to all the usual objections to random searches. You might be right, but if that is the only way for these searches to be better than the officer's guesses, it seems that drug dogs would not be allowed to 'sniff' in public without warrants.
I say this because it is possible (and indeed likely) that the officer is also better at guessing who has drugs than a coin toss.
Full Disclosure: I have never used or trafficked contraband, but I do not support random searches or the use of drug dogs in public without a warrant, regardless of their effectiveness.