The primary trouble I see is that there is no penalty for re-training dogs like this.
>This is done to get probable cause for a search when there is nothing more than an officer's hunch or just a desire to hassle a particular individual.
that claims that this is done purposefully. That's what I was wondering about, not the overall efficacy of drug dogs.
https://youtu.be/w-WMn_zHCVo?t=3m35s
It happens.
http://www.ucdmc.ucdavis.edu/welcome/features/2010-2011/02/2...
There are many examples that have been caught on camera, I see that another commenter posted a link to one of them on this thread.
When you see things like the handler returning to a previously cleared spot and indicating that the dog should check it again; three or four times until the dog alerts, you can assume that the handler has a severe short term memory problem and he just forgot that the dog had previously checked the area and failed to alert. I think it's more indicative of the officer hinting to the dog that "this is where I want you to alert" and their training reinforces the idea that if the dog does what's expected, there will be a treat.
My last dog picked up on so many of my personality traits/tells-- I felt quilty.
(My cat--whole nother story.)