I bet you could work on small polish issues like this for a lifetime and never finish. There's always something to improve.
Arguing semantics, maybe. But I think it is important to distinguish here. Polishing issues or enhancements or whatever you call it are things that do not need to be adressed, but they can. But bugs needs to be fixed. Choosing between what to do now is choosing between maintenance work and feature enhancement work, plumbing and UX.
I think it would be great if Github would hire and let him build these things, does not matter if he finishes in a month.
If it's reporting issues, discussion solutions, and reviewing patches, there are Issues and Pull Requests.
If it's for general discussions about the "future of the project" or bigger-picture topics, I'd use Discourse. It's a really nice way to organize discussions that are one step removed from code-related issues.
If it's for things where you need quick or real time feedback, there's IRC, Gitter, and Slack, all great options for messaging/chat.
More to the point: IRC (out-of-the-box) doesn't do archiving/search. Slack isn't self-host (which isn't an issue with people using github -- but it does introduce another vendor). Using external services forces you to maintain group membership, user-meta-data either in different user-databases, or via some form of federation.
No longer is removing a user/ssh-key from a github project enough to plug a hole in case of a hacked account.
Discourse isn't (that) bad -- but mailinglists are a lot better IMNHO. If you have a half-decent email program, like mutt, or even (al)pine.
At any rate, the ability to work via email (get bugs via email, close bugs via email) leverage what email is good at: off-line+synchronization. Which is one of the things git is good for. You know, distributed work.
https://slack.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/203772216-Using-...
https://auth0.com/docs/identityproviders
Not sure about authorization and group membership, channel authorization etc -- I assume you'll need to manage slack authorization with slack, and github authorization on the github side.
But fair's fair.
[ed: And now you have three providers:
This is what is appealing and Github offering a builtin-to-github solution for it, with linking to Github accounts, autoformatting etc (like in issues) and so on. There is so much potential.
The issue UI is a little forum-like but is pretty clunky, and, of course, doesn't interact with email very well. Plus you need people to manually tag each issue with 'discussion'.
Are there any UI tweaks that could simplify this? For example, a way to provide a 'new issue' link with default labels?
(Also, is there a good way to import data as issues? I have a tonne of mbox archives that need to go somewhere.)
I still think having an email interface (as in: in addition to a REST API) is very useful. Having a web interface as well isn't bad either.
It sounds like what you really want is nested threads and top quoting and/or interstitial quote/response features?
(Arguably what you really need is commonly called a conference.)
AWS enables us to do some pretty slick things, but OpsWorks is a giant bag of suck that frequently finds a way to drain my time troubleshooting why something crazy or random has happened on the production server--behaviors I never saw in my previous role running a bare-metal LAMP stack for 4 years. A tighter integration between our GitHub repo and a testing/build server... Swoon.
Anyway, if you want it today consider using our GitLab CI https://about.gitlab.com/gitlab-ci/ it is free if you bring your own runner.
After exploring Visual Studio Online (its free for 5 users), I am still not able to digest why there isn't a build and deploy system in GitHub.
There were great demos at Microsoft's BUILD15 for Automated Build and Release Management which demonstrates these features.
Bugfixes are not feature enhancements.
Also this makes you sound like a pleasant person to work with.....a real go getter.
* Github CI - simple CI for every language, integrating with:
* Github Artifacts - repository for versioned deployable build packages (binaries, tar.gz files, ios builds, android builds...), integrating with:
* Github Deploy - deploy tooling for deploying runnable artifacts or artifact combinations to either your own infrastructure, or to aws/azure/google, or:
* Github Cloud - instances/containers as a service
and the 'fork' button would be a pulldown that would include the options 'fork', 'fork and test', 'fork, test and deploy'. Now that's a nice little 3-4 year career.