Re:IKEA Gets Deeper into the Woods
by dang on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @09:05PM
(#10007470)
This story was wrongly buried by user flags. I'm guessing this was because of the WSJ paywall. This is not a legitimate use of flagging on HN.
Academic journals that are truly locked down are one thing, but nearly every media paywall has a standard workaround. This is the case with NYT, Economist, New Yorker, WSJ, and other sources. fillskills was entirely right to post this article, which is interesting and on topic.
It's fine to help other users get to read the article. It's not fine to take threads off-topic by complaining about paywalls.
When I have time, I'm going to update the FAQ about this, but anyone who wants to can read through the many previous discussions we've had about it [1]. As far as I'm concerned the question is settled: we're not going to impoverish HN by banning sources of good stories that are readable by everyone with known workarounds. Good stories are scarce enough as it is.
Re:IKEA Gets Deeper into the Woods
by kiiski on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @09:28AM
(#10003218)
Wikipedia has this[1] (sourced [2]):
> On July 21, 2015, the operators blocked access to the service from all Finnish IP addresses, stating on Twitter they did this in order to avoid escalating a dispute they allegedly had with the Finnish government, that they refused to provide additional information on.
Re:IKEA Gets Deeper into the Woods
by jessaustin on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @08:02AM
(#10002803)
My impression is that IKEA products already use a bare minimum of wood. If they make things even thinner, there won't be much reason to shop there instead of just buying the cardboard stuff at Wal-Mart.
Re:IKEA Gets Deeper into the Woods
by blackbeard on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @08:15AM
(#10002846)
I've stopped buying IKEA products for this reason. They are never durable. The unit surfaces get pitted and discoloured easily and things warp over time. It's crap basically. I have to replace it all every 4-5 years.
The last cycle I threw some cash at some quality solid wood products. They're a better investment.
Re:IKEA Gets Deeper into the Woods
by onion2k on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @08:44AM
(#10002990)
They're a better investment.
They're a different investment. Furniture (outside of antiques) has practically no resale value. If you move around a lot, and value your freedom and mobility over most other things, Ikea is pretty much perfect. It's designed to be for the short term.
Re:IKEA Gets Deeper into the Woods
by Brakenshire on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @08:28AM
(#10002899)
I've had quite a lot of good furniture from there, which has lasted more than a decade. I think they carry crap and they carry things which are well made and well designed.
There does recently seem to be more crap, though. I tried to buy a floor lamp from there a couple of months ago, and they seemed to be basically not charging enough to be able to make their designs to a decent standard. If you're going to make a floor lamp for £30-40, just make it simple, don't put in a lot of hinges which aren't properly secured or balanced, or snake-like fittings which make loud groaning noises every time they are moved. Ironically I got something less ambitious and better designed from the local anonymous hardware store. Disappointing to see a company like IKEA which is supposed to be all about thought-out industrial design making mistakes like that.
Re:IKEA Gets Deeper into the Woods
by blackbeard on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @09:31AM
(#10003237)
Yes definitely. I have a floor lamp from them as well and the metal was so thin it folded the first time it was moved so now it's a metal and duct tape lamp :)
Re:IKEA Gets Deeper into the Woods
by jinushaun on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @10:56PM
(#10007802)
What are people doing to their IKEA furniture? Mine have seen six apartments in 10 years and are still basically new. Never understood why they have a reputation for "falling apart".
Only Target and Walmart furniture have fallen apart on me--usually within less than a year.
Re:IKEA Gets Deeper into the Woods
by toomuchtodo on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @02:42AM
(#10008298)
How much do you spend moving your quality wood furniture? Your moving budget is my IKEA budget every time I move (I donate my still-very-much-intact IKEA furniture).
Re:IKEA Gets Deeper into the Woods
by simi_ on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @12:09PM
(#10004309)
I'm not entirely skeptical of how ethical their exploitation will be conducted, I'm just raising the point that we're a country with heavily affected (ex-)forests. Moreover, there's a rich recent history of external interests being facilitated by our ultra-corrupt government, to rather devastating effects.
Re:IKEA Gets Deeper into the Woods
by SixSigma on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @07:42AM
(#10002722)
Vertical integration is so passé. Now you've got two problems, you'll end up competing with your other wood suppliersor supply your furniture competitors. Using the profit from your core business to prop up the weak one; whichever way round that ends up being.
The world just spent the last decade de-integrating.
Re:IKEA Gets Deeper into the Woods
by hessenwolf on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @08:38AM
(#10002942)
Tell that to the supply line risk manager at Boeing or Airbus. They might look like they are not vertically integrated, but the level of control they have muddies the water.
Academic journals that are truly locked down are one thing, but nearly every media paywall has a standard workaround. This is the case with NYT, Economist, New Yorker, WSJ, and other sources. fillskills was entirely right to post this article, which is interesting and on topic.
It's fine to help other users get to read the article. It's not fine to take threads off-topic by complaining about paywalls.
When I have time, I'm going to update the FAQ about this, but anyone who wants to can read through the many previous discussions we've had about it [1]. As far as I'm concerned the question is settled: we're not going to impoverish HN by banning sources of good stories that are readable by everyone with known workarounds. Good stories are scarce enough as it is.
1. https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&prefix&page=0&dateRange=...
Apparently archive.is blocks Finnish IP addresses. Additionally, my ISP does not even resolve an A record for archive.is. No idea why.
> On July 21, 2015, the operators blocked access to the service from all Finnish IP addresses, stating on Twitter they did this in order to avoid escalating a dispute they allegedly had with the Finnish government, that they refused to provide additional information on.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archive.is#Worldwide_availabil...
[2]: https://twitter.com/archiveis/status/623524336184524800
The last cycle I threw some cash at some quality solid wood products. They're a better investment.
They're a different investment. Furniture (outside of antiques) has practically no resale value. If you move around a lot, and value your freedom and mobility over most other things, Ikea is pretty much perfect. It's designed to be for the short term.
There does recently seem to be more crap, though. I tried to buy a floor lamp from there a couple of months ago, and they seemed to be basically not charging enough to be able to make their designs to a decent standard. If you're going to make a floor lamp for £30-40, just make it simple, don't put in a lot of hinges which aren't properly secured or balanced, or snake-like fittings which make loud groaning noises every time they are moved. Ironically I got something less ambitious and better designed from the local anonymous hardware store. Disappointing to see a company like IKEA which is supposed to be all about thought-out industrial design making mistakes like that.
Only Target and Walmart furniture have fallen apart on me--usually within less than a year.
https://www.google.com/search?q=romania+deforestation
If I'm going to consume professionally made content, I at least want it to be stolen first.
Corollary: this is why I'm sure to never be paid for my own work.
The world just spent the last decade de-integrating.
Also, it's "mainstream" again, with Apple as the trendsetter.
http://www.strategy-business.com/blog/Vertical-Integration-2...
http://business.time.com/2012/03/16/how-apple-made-vertical-...
Boeing and Airbus do not build their own engines for instance.