tr3ndyBEAR
Taking our classification schemes as a fact about biology is confusing the map for the territory.
But you are correct that mushrooms (which is the fruiting body of some types of fungi) are separate from plants (and actually more closely related to animals. They're basically animals that digest things externally instead of having a stomach to digest things internally)
Just wanted to point out there's a huge difference here. Black communities in America very much live with the legacy, and remanifestation (I recommend reading The Color of Law), of slavery in their everyday lives. At one point in US history, nearly 10% of american identified as KKK members. Do you think all of them suddenly disappeared.
There's also huge legacies in our academia. Just a couple decades ago sociology was essentially the study of eugenics in our own country while anthropology was the study of eugenics in other countries. Even commonly used terms in statistics (e.g. regression to the mean) root from the study of eugenics. There's been much scholarship dedicated to clearly tracing these roots and a constant theme of antiblackness
PBS has a great history documentary called "American Experience: The Eugenics Crusade" that I'd highly recommend if you wanna start to dig at the heels of how deeply rooted this is in our culture
If improving worker safety (in this case, literally saving hundreds of lives each year) and paying workers a living wage makes your already heavily subsidized company go bust, maybe the company shouldn't have existed in the first place?
Worker's health shouldn't be an economic externality
> Live in a rural area.
The only reason this might be true is because colonizers killed off or enslaved all the people who lived in places you can grow food. That's why the only places the San maintain their ways of life are mountains and deserts. But originally they lived in all sorts of ecosystems
> No education except what you can do yourself.
They have education... they educate themselves and even if not they can still send their kids to western schools. Also, why wouldn't they be able to get books?
> No travel
A foraging society travels every day. Native americans traveled great distances between seasons. During winter and fall many peoples lived in large urban centers (cities). Some of these cities were larger than European cities. People got around and you got to experience much more cultural diversity than the average industrial citizen does today
> No music except what you can make yourself
indigenous music... exists. And its often a central part of their culture. Music used to be more plentiful than it is today. In large part because they had so much more leisure time
> No shoes.
I don't know where you got this one from
> No food that didn't grow within a few miles of you
Like I said earlier, indigenous peoples absolutely did interact with other peoples and trade has always been a thing even before agriculture. Many peoples had large portions of their calories coming from trading
> You will eat the same 12 things your whole life. No spices, no seasoning, probably no salt either. No cooking oil.
Indigenous peoples had a much more varied diet than modern western people do. They knew hundreds of plants, fish, birds, reptiles, and even bugs. Part of the reason they enjoy better food security than their industrial counterparts is because of how varied their diet is. If their hunt is unsuccessful, if the sweet potato harvest was small this season, if their staple foods burned down, etc then they had a ton of backup foods and things we consider delicacies today. From acorn flour to lizards to even ants. And they also used spices extensively in tropical areas because it keeps food better preserved and safer
> Healthcare is whatever you can assemble at home. Dental problem? Sharp rock. Cancer? Goodbye. Infection? Goodbye. Same for your kids. Be sure to have extras to replace the ones who die.
I don't know where to start with this one. For one, hunter gatherers enjoyed much better dental health than their agricultural counterparts [1]. They also had many medicines and techniques for oral health that modern science is still learning from. For example the miswaks (a chewing stick) that's still widely used in Muslim parts of the world was found to be more effective than brushing your teeth [2] and has been recommended by the WHO.
> No shampoo. No soap.
No need! Your skins microbiome is essential to your health. Studies have found it to be really lacking diversity in Western populations compared to non-western populations. Two studies that censused populations of hunter gatherers both found zero cases of any level of acne [3]. One of 1200 Kitavans, and one of 115 Ache over 843 days. Both peoples across the globe from each other yet no instances of acne. This seems to be true for many of the skin diseases we face
Also it's not true that they had no soap. Indigenous peoples know which plants have saponins and other anti-microbial properties and use them as needed
> No bed. You sleep on skins.
lol
> No AC, ever. No thermostat. No heat but fire and body heat.
Precisely why hunter-gatherers are the ultimate eco-friendly society lol. But seriously tho, they constructed their shelters in ways that make a natural sort of AC system (the way that termites build their mounds and the way that modern western architects are trying to replicate). They have many other solutions to cold as well. Not to mention the human body adapts in a lot of ways to different climates (have you ever seen a Russian swim in a sub-zero lake?).
> No retirement - work until death.
Like I said, they work much less. In most societies the elders are well respected and play other important roles. As multiple studies have found, the biggest predictor of how long you'll live is your social network/community. Being able to grow old in a community of people you're extremely close with is something I wish our society still allowed us to do
> No police. Someone threatening you? I hope your family can back you up. You will be called upon to do violence. There will be no morality in it, only advantage.
This is a western bias of how, not only human nature, but nature itself works. Cooperation is a powerful force that is constant throughout nature. It is selected for in everything from slime molds to ants to naked mole rats. Darwin wasn't even a Darwinist. He recognized the importance that cooperation plays in evolution. The idea that competition is the driving force in evolution is one that runs deep in our evolutionary biology because for most of it's history, evolutionary biology in America was done by white Southern landowners. It wasn't until a Northerner got in that theories of group selection and kin selection started to be looked at. Now even game theory recognizes the importance of cooperation for survival
> You could easily - easily! - work 15 hours a week and live at this consumption level (in fact, far beyond). And, eating better than a !Kung would be extremely simple on $5 per day.
Good luck affording 100% organic, wild caught, no pesticides, etc food. Did you know that since 1914, the mineral content of our vegetables has decreased by over 90% [4]?
[1] https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2013/02/24/1726888... [2] https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/000163500429398 [3] https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamadermatology/fullarticle... [4] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6163803/
However, a mistake in this analysis was quickly pointed out. That 15-20 hours figure only represented the time necessary to gather food. It ignored the time necessary to gather firewood, take care of children, prepare food, etc.
So Sahlins went back to his analysis and took those factors into account. When taking those factors into account, the !Kung (and most San peoples that have maintained their traditional foraging societies) worked 40 hours to meet all their basic needs. However, when looking at the time spent by Western peoples outside of formal work doing informal work (laundry, cooking, etc), their workweek shot up to 80 hours.
In the end, the San (and likely most foraging societies) worked half as much as us, enjoyed great health [1], and even had better food security [2] (contrary to common assumptions about foraging societies).
The questions this opens up, in my view, are: 1) If our society is so much more efficient now than societies were before civilization, why is it that we have to work so much harder to meet our basic needs? 2) If it's not the majority benefiting from this increased efficiency, who is? 3) Is our industrial society more efficient after all?
[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30511505 [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3917328/
edit: 15-20 hours a week not a day
The big thing missing from this conversation is how the US/multi-national corporations use international organizations like the IMF and World Bank to force "structural adjustment" policies that end up degrading labor protections, forcing countries to privatize all gov't functions, etc. We have played a big role in the destruction of their "situation". Both historically through colonialism and still actively today with IOs and structural adjustment policies
Not to mention all the fucking coups the US enacted and supported: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_r...
[1]https://interestingengineering.com/a-tesla-model-3-produces-... [2] https://www.consumerreports.org/car-reliability-owner-satisf...
In addition, studies like this one (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/1745-9125.1...) have found that the relationship between crime rates and undocumented immigrants actually decreases
As someone who came to America undocumented at the age of 5, my personal intuition is that undocumented people tend to be more fearful of authority and therefore more likely to avoid getting in trouble
It's really telling when you realize how much America had an influence on Nazism.
Hitler himself praised the US racial quotas at the time
I think it's a little misguided to say that China's innovation is solely due to corporate espionage. States have always been effective at spurring innovation when it's needed. We only need to look as far back as America's highly productive and innovative war economy to see that
You can read the wikipedia page for "corporate personhood" if you want to learn more about the history of it and specific cases and rights afforded to corporations.