towhans
I can imagine having an in browser, framework level tool would know exactly which controller and which template generated this element and could target it more precisely while using less tool calls and less tokens. I haven't tested it yet but that is my expectation.
1/ How much Coins per commit will somebody get? It's totally subjective and decided ex post. How do you compare a patch with 300 lines of code to a bugfix that touches just one character? Or to a comment that sheds light on an important issue?
2/ How do business owners submit profits? Even if they are totally honest people - we live in a complex world where it might be very difficult to separate profits of one App from another.
All in all it seems to me that this is a great way to exploit young developers that want to learn but don't know their value yet. The Coins system tries very hard to give impression that it is fair. It's not.
The fact that I don't own my contributions is a total show stopper for me.
I like the overall idea - just not this particular iteration of it.
The speed argument also doesn't hold. If requests take too long to process then you have either problem with your API (doing something synchronously on server side which should be done asynchronously, granularity problems,...) or your server is freaking slow. At worst a request should take under 100ms of pure server time. Add latency and you have 300ms.