News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

thowarray

Re:Chip Hall of Fame: Atmel ATmega8 on Tuesday October 31, 2017 @08:11AM (#15592614)
Great microcontroller, shitty article.
> Sure, but what's wrong with that?

Everything!

* You teach the child dishonesty (taking credit for someone elses work can terminate your academic career). * In this particular case, the child becomes the face of a marketing campaign (that's her actual contribution: selling a product). * Stories like this one put pressure on other children because their parents buy it hook line and sinker and want the same for their children.

Ok, another wunderkind story. At the age of 11:

* Knows how to program Arduino

* knows how to write Android Apps

* has a working understanding of chemistry

* is able to infuse carbon nanotubes with chlorine and build a disposable sensor from this.

* understands marketing enough to promote her product via the app stores (there really is no other reason for using a smartphone instead of three colored LEDs to display results).

Is anyone really buying this?

Here's a more likely story:

* Parents see scientific curiosity in her daughter, as well as the will to help people.

* Parents see a fear of lead in water and therefore a market for testkits

* Parents see that testkits already on the market suffer from being unreliable in untrained hands/too difficult to use.

* Parents have the idea for a better, "digital testkit", but that turns out to be way more expensive than anything that is already on the market.

* Parents then spoonfeed the idea to her daughter. They do the work, she gets the credit (and probably thinks that she did most of the work).

* The media picks the story up because "awwwww ... smart kid", resulting in free marketing for what would otherwise be a totally overengineered/overpriced product.