News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

taylorscollon

Re:Enough with Basic Income on Sunday September 11, 2016 @04:30PM (#12475514)
I wrote a longer rebuttal to this (it's in the responses section of Colin's original piece), but here's an excerpt on the issue of political vulnerability which is his main line of attack.

"It is broadly true that the more people who benefit from a government program, the more popular the program usually is. Social insurance programs that benefit the middle-class and the poor are usually politically durable.

American social security, for example, is less politically vulnerable than food stamps, in part because food stamps will never benefit most middle-class people. UBI, however, is more like social security than it is like food stamps. The middle-class may not need UBI, but UBI would still benefit them.

A comparable case is the status of single-payer health insurance programs in countries that have them. Most middle-class and rich people in these countries don’t need single payer healthcare — nearly all of them would have employer coverage if single payer didn’t exist. And yet there is broad support across classes for single-payer in these countries, in part because it (like UBI) benefits the middle-class. Universal healthcare is in these countries what conservatives would malign as “a sacred cow”.

None of this is to say that UBI would be politically invulnerable. Even the most durable social insurance programs are often put at risk.

[...]

But Colin appears to think UBI would inevitably become means-tested to only benefit the poor. Financial pressures, he says, would cause voters to limit the program. But Colin doesn’t make it clear why middle-class voters would react in this way, stripping themselves of a direct cash benefit. This is certainly not typical voter behaviour, and I am skeptical that a popular turn against UBI is inevitable or likely."

Re:What Is the Public Value of Philosophy? on Sunday April 19, 2015 @02:39PM (#9404235)
Gravity exerted force before Newton formalized its effect. I think Newton's contribution was still valuable.
Re:What Is the Public Value of Philosophy? on Sunday April 19, 2015 @02:35PM (#9404213)
This is a false dichotomy. Frege was a mathematician and wrote philosophy attempting to explain what a number was. Questions about which domain this effort ought to be bucketed in don't have an answer.
Re:What Is the Public Value of Philosophy? on Sunday April 19, 2015 @02:20PM (#9404148)
This is a worthwhile point. People have a misconception about what philosophy is because pop 'philosophy' like Zizek is more about generating controversy than useful inquiry.

It's like someone who has only ever seen click bait dismissing journalism as pointless.

Re:What Is the Public Value of Philosophy? on Sunday April 19, 2015 @01:13PM (#9403891)
You're arguing against taxes, not philosophy.
Re:What Is the Public Value of Philosophy? on Sunday April 19, 2015 @01:05PM (#9403854)
Aristotle gave us logic, which is the basis for rational inquiry in all fields. Also an important contribution.
Re:What Is the Public Value of Philosophy? on Sunday April 19, 2015 @01:03PM (#9403849)
Not sure this is the strongest argument for philosophy. Philosophy is valuable when it is directed to the inquiry of truth for the sake of discovering truth, not for some immediately practical application. This sort of exercise pushes against the limits of thought, and that leads to interesting and important places.

This isn't just true in philosophy. In the early 20th century physicists announced they had solved almost all of the problems in physics. One thing they hadn't got around to yet was figuring out the position of electrons at a given time. But it was popular to regard this is a trivial problem. How they bonded was a more practical issue, and they had solved that one. But those who pushed on with this seemingly trivial problem discovered that it wasn't trivial at all.

Turning unknown unknowns into known unknowns is not necessarily practical, but it is certainly valuable.

Re:Show HN: Slack Meets GitHub Issues on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @05:58PM (#9148007)
'Your marketing page sucks' is true, but not useful or insightful.

My suggestion is something like: 'Your chats, to-dos, and project management -- free, and in one place.'

That is compelling enough that I might sign up and try it.

Contrary to some of the advice on here, I would not try to explain how this product works in any great detail on the homepage. This is because it seems (I haven't tried it) like a complicated tool.

Focus on building a solid onboarding process that walks users through the usage of the product. This will be more useful to your users than any video or screenshots.

This is all without having tried the product or knowing too much about the space/your ideal users, so take it with a grain of salt.