News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

oxplot

Re:Rivian S-1 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @08:20AM (#28728028)
> 'Go on youtube and search' is not evidence.

Yes it is. I even told you what to search for exactly and I've already pasted direct links to some of them in a sibling post.

> I was under the assumption that 'Level 5' robo-taxis were coming in 2020

Be prepared to be disappointed again and again when it comes to cutting edge of tech. You're not waiting for the next Xbox.

Re:Rivian S-1 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @08:10AM (#28727967)
> Idea of beta-testing on the public roads by creating consumer disinformation is outrageous and must be stopped.

Everyone driving the FSD Beta knows pretty well what they're doing and what the whole thing means, hence the very strict criteria the drivers must meet to have that feature enabled, so I don't know what disinformation you're talking about.

Calling it outrageous, dangerous, etc doesn't make it so, and evidently, after many month of FSD Beta, there is yet an accident to be reported resulting from use of it, in a world where every Tesla accident makes it to front page of the news. Is it an accident waiting to happen? Well, every time you get into your car, you're entering the accident lottery. It's all about the likelihood of getting into an accident and so far numbers are in Tesla's favor.

And how do you imagine a system whose improvements relies heavily on real world data is meant to obtain it without large scale participation? Have a hundred employees doing rounds in a test track?

The way I see autonomous driving through being well informed, and not speaking based on outdated intuitions, Tesla's pushing the envelope just enough to make meaningful progress toward full self-driving while not overly putting people at risk.

> It is beyond believe, how regulations are soft towards applications of technologies with direct effect on human lives.

Heavily regulating something that's in its infancy is the surest way to kill it. Those people who are constantly bitching about why robo-taxis aren't here yet even with lax regulations, can be certain to dream of it for the rest of their lives should walls be put up too early.

> In car touch interfaces are exciting for people who hate driving and love their phones.

Not only. I drive a M3 and I love driving it. I don't use my phone and nor find the urge to. I enjoy the lack of clutter, and the beautiful large screen when I need to use it. Every other car I sit in, feels like a 60s Russian rocket and stresses me out. Even Tesla's own Model S and Model X feels too cluttered now with the extra driver's dash screen.

> This will not work long-term. The Idea of vehicles as a SaaS platform also will not work. This will be CX hell and people will reject it.

Ye, that's what they said about SaaS on the Internet. Who would, in their right minds, give up control of their service and store their data and code at the mercy of a third party. Saw how that turned out.

Re:Rivian S-1 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:11AM (#28727209)
That's what well informed looks like from the outside!
Re:Rivian S-1 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:50AM (#28727119)
You seem to be hung up on SAE definitions and missing my point which I'm going re-iterate, maybe from a different angle.

Moving from supervising the car to not supervising the car isn't a binary flip where suddenly in one software revision, you can take a nap while yesterday you couldn't. It's a spectrum. And that's why SAE levels between 2 and 3 are poorly describing this (not to mention how poorly level 2 itself is defined, as it covers a huge range of functionality, from something a bunch of cheap sensors can achieve with graduate level of CS knowledge to something Tesla AI has achieved with FSD Beta which has required custom computers, millions of miles of driving data and some of the biggest brains in AI world).

Since it's a spectrum, the only variable changing is how likely it is you as the supervisor need to take over control *because* your car either made a mistake or was about to. That's all it's reduced to — how often does you car make a mistake. That's all level 3 and up is. All the descriptions and charts do nothing but fog up this, which is unfortunate. Once you have a car that makes very few mistakes, you don't need to supervise it because the probability of it making mistakes is less than you as a human driver at which point it's a better driver than you anyway.

You can of course argue that reduction in mistakes is itself functionality. Well, I make a distinction between continuous and minor refinements and major enabling technology, like vector reconstruction of 3D space from images of cameras, or AI based route planning, which given more data, can plan better.

As far as I understand from Tesla's progress, they need to merely cover ever more corner cases to go up the levels.

And on the topic of supervision: whether you have to keep your hands on the wheel or otherwise supervise the car has a lot to do with policy and regulation. You can have a car today that is safe enough to drive while you asleep and good luck trying to sell it without telling the customers they must stay alert. This basically makes level 3 as defined in SAE subject not only to actual capabilities of a car but the regulatory environment in which it's sold.

Re:Rivian S-1 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:47AM (#28726819)
FSD Beta (not Tesla Autopilot) drives door to door right now. Go on youtube and search for "FSD Beta 10" to get a feel of it. It makes mistakes enough that you need an attentive driver who can take over, so you still need a steering wheel. Level 3-5 is all about ever less driver intervention but as far as functionality goes, Teslas can drive autonomously on highways and urban settings across the entire US.
Re:Rivian S-1 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:42AM (#28726790)
> It’s not at all about mistake percentage

Yes it is and SaaS is very relevant. The very page you've linked lists all sorts of "features" up to level 2 but level 3 and up is all about whether the driver should take over if the car asks them to. In fact, re-reading the levels, FSD Beta is at level 3 because:

- You are NOT driving when the features are active (the car accelerates, stops, turns, gives way, negotiates with traffic, waits for pedestrians, changes lanes, follows navigation, etc.).

- When the feature requests, you must drive. Check. FSD Beta will prompt the user to take over at times when it can't figure out the way forward.

- These features drive under limited condition and won't do so if conditions aren't met. Check too. FSD Beta will only become available when it has a good sense of the environment.

Well, thanks for the refresher. So FSD Beta is clearly at level 3 now.

Re:Rivian S-1 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @02:26AM (#28726445)
The only difference between level 2 and up is whether the system needs attention should it make a mistake, and ATM Tesla must have a fully attentive driver at all times. The problem with the SAE levels is that level 2 covers such a broad category of autonomous capabilities that it’s kind of meaningless calling a car level 2. There are cars at level two manufactured a decade ago and Tesla FSD is also level 2 and the latter may as well be a spaceship in comparison. Knowing there are 5 levels and Tesla is at level 2 does not in any way give one a notion of how autonomous the car is, only that it may make mistakes x% of the time.

An analogy with a SaaS is having a full featured service that’s available 99% of time and dismissing it as every other toy service out there, only because it’s not available 99.99% of the time. That’s the situation with Tesla more or less. Granted the march towards more 9s is going to take some time.

EDIT: I looked up the "Tesla admitting level 2" and it's in regards to their *current* Autopilot software that's been around for years, not FSD Beta which is currently only rolled out to a few thousand people in US. So seems like you're not understanding the difference between Autopilot and FSD Beta. I recommend again that you watch "FSD Beta 10" videos on Youtube since you evidently have not.

EDIT: removed hostile comment

Re:Rivian S-1 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @12:54AM (#28726065)
Sure, hence "pending software". And if you happen to follow their progress on youtube (just search FSD Beta 10), you'll see just how advanced it already is. And it's getting better at an exponential rate.
Re:Rivian S-1 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @12:52AM (#28726059)
You will never hear about all the times it's saved people's lives and avoided accidents, so until you show me that it has in fact increased accident rates, a link to a video means nothing, unless you are a journalist and your newspaper is on the verge of going under, in which case you need some juicy drama to sell ads.
Re:Rivian S-1 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @12:51AM (#28726051)
They are, and it's true, even TODAY, and I'm going to repeat it every chance I get, because I've learnt that it takes repetition to correct misunderstanding and ignorance! Just go on youtube and search for FSD Beta 10. Yes, it makes mistakes, and yes it has a long way before you can sleep at the wheel but it's doing door to door driving today across the entire US, like no other car even comes close to doing.
Re:Rivian S-1 on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:42PM (#28724936)
> Thank you, Elon - you saved a lot of money and ruin decades of car UX

The motivation behind a single touchscreen (from the horse’s mouth) is the gradual move to full self driving. Given that all Teslas are capable of fully autonomous driving, pending software, it doesn’t make sense to pollute the car interior with controls that will become obsolete during the lifetime of the car, not even accounting for extra cost associated with manufacturing dozens/hundreds of extra parts.

Now if others are copying it without understanding why it’s done that way, it’s on them.

Re:Iceland almost gets female-majority parliament on Monday September 27, 2021 @06:11AM (#28668965)
Dig down enough and all so called merit comes down to luck. And no, we shouldn't push for putting all lucky people in power.
Re:Abusing AWS Lambda to make an Aussie search engine on Monday September 27, 2021 @04:04AM (#28668235)
oooo, neat! — reminds me of some similar work I did building a search engine which went a step further and ran on S3.

https://blog.oxplot.com/the-art-of-barebackness/

> Self-driving cars can wait.

Absolutely not!

> Nothing of importance depends on it.

Lives of 35000 people a year does.

Tell HN: Curb Your Necroposting Aversion

This is directed at those hardworking forum admins among you. Please relax your rules on necroposting. A common scenario is someone asking how to do something. At the time, it either gets answered sub-optimally or not at all. Over time, it manages to get to top of the search engine results (why? no idea! but it does far too often). New solutions now exist but the forum admin has decided to lock...

( Read More... | 4 comments | 8 points | on HN )
Re:Show HN: Load env vars from variety of sources with ease on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @04:15PM (#28449318)
I see the confusion. The loading happens inside of the application so no other process can see the values.
Re:Man can change his pupil size on command on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:20AM (#28401308)
That requires you crossing your eyes, or look past the image, which makes your vision double.
Re:Man can change his pupil size on command on Wednesday September 01, 2021 @09:20PM (#28387645)
I am the only person I know in my group of friends who can change the focus of my eyes independently of the distance of the object I’m looking at. In other words, I can make vision go blurry (wide eyes open) without it going double.
Re:Remind HN: .com prices increase Sep 1, 2021 on Monday August 30, 2021 @11:25PM (#28363636)
If you have a domain that you know won't be going away, you can renew it for up to 10 years in advance. Cloudflare currently has the lowest price for .com.
I don't know if their claim of extra protection is valid or valid to the claimed extent, but if so, it's well deserved and this is BS news.
Umm, they are already pretty intimidated. As Starlink stands right now (in beta with partial constellation in service), it's superior to all of those combined. Those guys are shitting their pants right now scrambling to either block SpaceX from moving forward (by whining to authorities) or setup their own competing constellations.
Re:Tools to Run Kubernetes Locally on Friday August 06, 2021 @02:05PM (#28090829)
If you're on linux, `kind` is the way to go
> why don't we just fix Earth?

If you’re truly interested to know the answer to this, you can find it aplenty online. And it’s not because it’s “sexy”.

I recently used `git bisect` to find the latest compatible code revision for a DB snapshot by checking the db migrations applied in that snapshot. Bisecting 80K commits takes a few seconds. Magical stuff.
Yep, I made something similar out of cardboard for myself and used it in office in the past. I'm super sensitive to motion in my peripheral vision.
Re:Australia’s trash bin-raiding cockatoos on Friday July 23, 2021 @08:18AM (#27929843)
These are some of the most annoying birds here in Oz, probably right behind Magpies.

I've seen them destroy/pull off the outer plastic trim on a car roof like they had pliers for beaks. They're pretty meaty and large and are not scared off easily. Loud as fuck too.

Older »