Tell HN: Curb Your Necroposting Aversion
This is directed at those hardworking forum admins among you. Please relax your rules on necroposting. A common scenario is someone asking how to do something. At the time, it either gets answered sub-optimally or not at all. Over time, it manages to get to top of the search engine results (why? no idea! but it does far too often). New solutions now exist but the forum admin has decided to lock down the thread to avoid necroposting, essentially wasting the SEO advantage they have unintentionally gained by not allowing useful answers to be posted, and subsequently making it harder for people to find answers.
Necroposting is definitely not that great in general, but there are circumstances where it's very helpful.
(
4 comments
| 8 points
| on HN
)
Even a manual WONTFIX is less rude.
I found this issue for a problem I had with MinIO. I wrote a prototype: docs first and screencast on how the API would be. I then asked the other user if they had implemented it and if the API I was thinking about would suit them as it suited me. MinIO's CTO replied that it was the correct usage, but that it was not on the roadmap, which is understandable.
I then started implementing the actual commands I needed first (host, ls, etc). Some time later, someone tweeted at us and asked how they could use the library. I then put it on PyPI (Python Package Index). I checked upon that person recently and they told be they've been using it for months without a problem. The other person also had commented and said they've been using it.
https://pypistats.org/packages/bmc
It's a really, really, small library for a niche need, also asked people for feedback here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26540342
Now I'm getting feature requests on that issue, but I'll soon do it properly in a repo to make it easier for people.