News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

notarandomer

Re:Machine Learning for MRI Image Reconstruction on Monday January 03, 2022 @03:03PM (#29785851)
Thanks for the comment! You're right, I was oversimplifying saying that default MRI would be fully sampled. My main point still stands, you can't just chuck ML onto current protocols to do a direct comparison with ML and more conventional reconstruction methods to give clinicians access to both and expect an improvement (beyond potentially denoising) because the conventional scans are already very good at what they do. Where ML can help is in cases where we can't produce conventional scans (e.g. with very short scan times or high temporal resolution).
Re:Machine Learning for MRI Image Reconstruction on Monday January 03, 2022 @12:24AM (#29777636)
"Default MRI" (i.e. fully sampled) should definitely be acquired when possible when testing this out to compare to gold standard. But the benefit of using ML methods in the fully sampled case would be minimal (maybe some denoising), whereas they have a much larger effect when acquiring highly undersampled data that traditional reconstruction methods fail at. It's also not always possible to get fully sampled reference data. For example in functional MRI you might not be able to get matched fully sampled data because the benefit of undersampling is in improving the temporal resolution. These cases are definitely more researchy and less clinical though, and in my work we add a 2 minute highly undersampled scan to current standard protocols and compare what we can reconstruct from our 2 minute scan compared with the fully sampled (but often lower resolution) standard scans.
Re:Machine Learning for MRI Image Reconstruction on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:46PM (#29776381)
Thanks! I agree taht generative models on their own are definitely more risky than methods that combine ML for regularization along with data consistency terms that force the reconstructions to be consistent with the acquired data.
Re:Machine Learning for MRI Image Reconstruction on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:42PM (#29776356)
Yes, accelerating MRI acquisition increases noise in the images as well as introducing aliasing artifacts. I think the issue is that some modern reconstruction methods (e.g. compressed sensing that was mentioned in the article) produce predictable biases, e.g. adding a risk of smoothing out details, but for ML we don't always know in what way it will bias the reconstructed image (add details, remove important information...), and I think that is what people often worry about.
Re:Machine Learning for MRI Image Reconstruction on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:24PM (#29776212)
I am surprised you are so certain in this statement. There is always a tradeoff between scan time and image quality. Clinical scans often have thick slices to keep scan times reasonable. Using advanced reconstruction methods, e.g. ML, you can get thinner slices in the same scan time. How would you balance the benefit of getting higher resolution in the same time as a standard lower resolution scan time if the higher resolution scan was regularized with a neural network? The doctor might miss small tumors due to low resolution too. I understand your concern, but I wouldn't dismiss it so outright.

Note, I am biased because I research MRI acquisition and reconstruction methods and I am rolling out trials of fast MRI methods (that use some ML in the reconstruction) to find out how robust the methods actually are in practice.