nik12795
The video explains a lot but here are some highlights:
- A camera + raspberry pi are used for the gesture recognition so it can recognize my hand movements.
- To open the door, I used some metal wire, a pulley, and a motor. There’s a thousand ways to open a door, but how would you have done it? I also considered a linear actuator.
- I had trouble increasing the speed of the motor to open the door so instead, I made the total length of the metal wire shorter. Assuming the wind up speed of the motor is constant, reducing the length of the wire by 80% should make it 5x faster.
Any questions? Let me know.
There were 2 tubes for the ball, so they would need to be reloaded. But my friend Jason did have a design for how I could have 12-15 balls that would automatically feed in. Just didn't have time to implement it :(
Any thoughts about that?!
Confession: I’ve never seen Caddyshack. But after everyone telling me about my bags reference to the movie, I watched the clip where the golf bag shoots out the club haha and I can see the crazy coincidence
The video explains some parts of how I built it and shows it off more (I even got to bring it to England to show Rick Shiels, a popular golf YouTuber), but I’ll highlight a few other key points.
- Getting this thing to rotate and finding the right motor took me a lot of time. A bunch of stepper motors I tried initially were too weak and would “skip”. I did some MOI calculations and talked with some engineers (this math was new to me) and I eventually found a motor that was just barely strong enough. I threw a 10:1 gearbox on it to solidify the torque requirements and called it a day.
- The motor didn’t rotate very accurately in terms of degrees. So trying to rotate 30 degrees would actually rotate 30 degrees +- 4 degrees. Over time, there was a lot of drift and rotating a certain number of degrees became completely inaccurate. I came up with a solution where a microswitch was clicked every time a club went by. That way, the motor rotated until a certain number of clicks happened instead of X number of degrees. The video breaks this solution down more.
- The voice assistant software is Rhasspy, an open source offline voice assistant. It had to be offline since I wouldn’t have internet connection on the course. That runs on a raspberry pi and also has the microphone and speaker hooked up to it.
- Originally I was going to use a fancy microphone that has lights and that took up all the pins on the pi, so I planned to use I2C to send commands to an Arduino to control the motor (and solenoid valves which controlled the airflow to the air cylinders that actually shot out the club). I set all that up then changed the microphone at the last minute. If I had more time, I would have removed I2C and just used the Pi. Since I didn’t have time, the current implementation is a Pi and Arduino talking over I2C.
- The video shows how I 3D printed some parts to make the clubs stay aligned in one direction so they don’t smash into each other when they eject from the bag. Just wanted to call out I’m really proud of this solution :)
Show HN: I made a voice activated golf bag that shoots your clubs
- I didn’t know David Dobrik before this video and was thinking about how to contact him. I decided to make a TikTok explaining that I was building this ridiculous thing and thought he’d enjoy playing with it. It got over 4 million views and he commented on it and DMd me to figure out the details. You can view that TikTok here: https://www.tiktok.com/@nick_ohara/video/6985282649858329861
- The biggest problem I had was trying to create the explosives. I use Armstrong’s Mixture which is a combination of potassium chlorate (found in matches) and red phosphorus (found in the striker on match boxes; my research showed you need to scrape it off). It’s pretty difficult to get raw red phosphorus, so I tried another oxidizer, sulfur. It didn’t work and I didn’t have time to scrape a bunch of match boxes. After my TikTok went viral, I only had 1 week to finish the build and ship it to him, so I was super stressed. What ended up working best was crushing up match heads then CUTTING off the striker, taping them together, and smashing it with a hammer. Realizing I could cut the striker off instead of scraping it absolutely saved me.
- I originally used springs to power the hammer to cock it back but found they weren’t reliable enough. The springs would stretch too far and would get to a point where they wouldn’t spring back. So I used latex tubing which was much more dependable.
- Shipping this beast was super expensive. I had a custom crate built by some friends who made it for free. Two day shipping was $9,000 and 5 day shipping was $1,500. I obviously opted for the 5 day shipping.
- Once we arrived in LA on Sunday night, we tested some of the explosives with a hammer. The gun was shipped to David’s house directly, so we didn’t have the luxury of testing the whole gun beforehand. I ALWAYS wear safety glasses but forgot this one time. And this one time, the explosion had some shrapnel and it got into my eye. I went to the eye doctor immediately and they cleaned it out. I was very lucky it wasn’t anything major and also that we were filming on Tuesday, so I had a day to recover.
- I highlight a lot of things that went wrong at David’s in the video. But even with all those things going poorly, David was super accommodating, understanding, and patient with us despite being stressed with other bits he was recording and editing.
- Lastly, this project was super expensive. Somewhere around $8-9k. The actual cap gun was around $2,500 (parts, tools, paint, etc), shipping was $1,500, traveling was $3,500 (Airbnb, flights for me and my two friends who filmed, rental car), and then other expenses for filming gear, food, etc.
Show HN: I Built the World's Largest Cap Gun [video]
Plus, with something like this, there is a difference between the end user and the person purchasing the product. The purchaser might be a parent for their child but the end user is the child. I think there's a small percentage of end users who would actually use the product their loved one bought them.
So I guess overall it feels like it would be tough to gain traction and find product market fit.
I also point out that there are other ways to incentivize the driver to not text and drive, like having the driver pay a fee when they text and drive.
I appreciate the discussion but a lot of these comments are bringing up points that are clearly addressed in the video. Please don't just read the headline and comment; watch the video and then lets all have an informed discussion :)
I come to the same "less safe and problematic" conclusion at the end of the video (which was no surprise). It's a real problem and something worth thinking about, at least until self driving cars take over.