News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

mapumpum

Re:Do Bitcoin Markets Have a Conversion Tort Problem? on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:27PM (#15638730)
All these legal theories will not matter, because the entire problem will immediately become dangerously political.

When the protesters started marching in 2011 in Syria, Bashir thought that he could solve the problem by putting a lot of them in jail. Well, outside the small area that he still controls today, the entire Syrian police force has been exterminated. They are all dead now.

The political situation in many countries is already explosive without provocation. The state-sanctioned banking system is generally hated. Too many people already are looking to overthrow the ruling elite. All that they still need, is a flimsy excuse.

Re:Do Bitcoin Markets Have a Conversion Tort Problem? on Monday November 06, 2017 @03:05PM (#15638582)
So, now you need the identities along the transmission chain too, up to: 1+3¹+3²+3³+3^n = (3^(n-1)-1)/(n-1).

It only makes the problem worse. Most of these identities cannot be recovered. It is not realistic to believe that the first 3 identities in the chain will be recovered. It may very well end up being identities further down the chain.

Furthermore, you will still need to try until you can find an identity in a jurisdiction in which you can sue.

Imagine that you find someone at step 12 with some fraction of the coins, who lives in Japan, and who bought the coin fractions at an exchange. Are you sure that the Japanese courts will cooperate with your recovery efforts?

By the way, the MPAA mostly stopped suing bittorrent users in Europe and elsewhere, because "Pirate parties" started springing up and gaining increasingly more elected seats. At that point, we are no longer talking about what the law would be, but what it should be, and things started looking bad for the MPAA. So, they backed off.

Suing lots of random people on rather flimsy grounds would very soon get political too.

Furthermore, as Von Clausewitz nicely argues in "Vom Kriege", war is just the continuation of the political negotiations but then by other means. So, that would be the next step, if even the political confrontation would fail. It was not that the MPAA was ever going to win.

Re:Do Bitcoin Markets Have a Conversion Tort Problem? on Monday November 06, 2017 @02:04PM (#15637964)
Imagine that on average 1 unspent output gets signed over to 3 unspent outputs. 1 -> 3 -> 9 -> 3³ -> 3⁴ ... 3^n outputs that would need to be restituted.

Imagine the average number of times that an unspent output gets spent a year is 50.

So, this means that after one year, it will be necessary to hunt down name, address, and whereabouts of up to 3⁵⁰ unspent output owners, many of which will turn out to be the same persons, but you cannot know that upfront. The more time passes by, the worse the problem gets.

So, that means that you could easily end up suing something like 100,000 individuals in 190+ jurisdictions.

That is even more unrealistic than the failed attempts of the MPAA trying to sue bittorrent users.

You see, someone sitting on stolen bitcoins will keep exchanging them back and forth for other cryptocurrencies until he has nothing left from his original stash. Therefore, you will most likely not even be able to sue the original thief.