Wow, thank you — this comment made my day You absolutely figured out what I was going for: not an “answer machine” but a decision-support framework. Hearing that the Architect agent stood out means a lot — I spent a lot of time tuning it so the debate didn’t devolve into noise.
Love your persona ideas:
Vegas Agent — I’ve already sketched this one; implied totals + props are such a strong independent signal.
Scheme Analyst — great call, coaching tendencies are exactly the kind of qualitative-but-reliable context that would add depth.
Beat Writer RAG — 100%. Local intel is usually the sharpest edge before Vegas moves.
On your questions:
Weighting: That’s on the roadmap — I’m experimenting with letting users “slide” agent influence up/down depending on contest type (e.g. cash vs GPP). Right now weighting is implicit (Architect harmonizes), but user control feels natural.
Backtesting: I’m building a logging pipeline so I can track each agent’s outputs and compare to actual fantasy scoring. Goal is to see which personas would’ve been most profitable over a season, and surface that transparency to users.
The long-term vision is exactly what you called out — uncertainty exploration as a UI pattern. Fantasy is just the wedge.
Really appreciate the thoughtful feedback — curious if you’d personally want the slider/backtest exposed inside the debate UI, or as a separate “analytics view” afterwards?