News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

karmawhore

I've tried to keep my mouth shut as I believe I am probably the only dissenting opinion that reads HN.

I work in Intel. My name appears on several FISA orders issued in the last 10 years. My rewards for doing my part to keep the USA free, may land me behind a desk as an analyst the rest of my life. On Dec 2, I was pulled out of my assignment and returned to the States. I had 35 minutes notice to pack two suitcases - no contact with friends, no ability to communicate - ghosted.

I've lived a good life, I've done my job, I don't agree with everything my employer has done, but, my belief is that it was all done for the greater good. If I didn't believe that, I would have quit years ago. I don't make a rockstar programming salary though I do have good benefits. Does that make up for the money I could make? Maybe.

You know what I was offered? A desk or a new identity, relocation benefits and early retirement because of the possibility that my name could be released.

Do I agree with Wikileaks? I believe there should be some accountability for things the government has done. I believe Wikileaks should follow through on their promise for Bradley Manning's defense, though, I think what he did was reprehensible. I hope the money he made was worth it even though I doubt he'll ever see it. Maybe that 11 digit number will hold some solace for him that he was that close to the money.

While I may not agree with what you are saying, I'll fight to the death to protect your rights to say it. I get extremely irritated when I see the US Flag being burned in protest, but I wouldn't have you arrested for it, and would fight to protect you should the police try to arrest you.

Freedom of Speech is a right that we have. Taking classified documents and handing them to someone to have them released doesn't fall under Freedom of Speech nor does it really fall under the Shield Law.

There are things that were kept from the public that I believe should be kept private. Releasing the cables will do nothing but embarrass the USA with the dealings that they have to do on a daily basis to keep other countries happy -- and it cost me my job. Is it important to know what concessions were made with one country to get inspectors in to view another country's nuclear reactors? The bulk of the 250k cables is just backdoor dealings with other countries.

If you applied for a job with two tech companies and the recruiters from each talked with each other and opted to trade you for someone they wanted more, even if you were happy with either one, do you really want to know that you were worth less than the other person?

The DDOS attacks really do nothing. Paypal would have released the funds eventually, even though the account probably pointed to the Swiss bank account that was shut down. Visa/MC probably did get pressured but made a business decision to shut down a proxy company where you don't even know what percentage made it to Assange. Will the DDOS make Visa/MC turn on the merchant account? Doubtful. Will it make it harder for small businesses to get merchant accounts? Probably. Companies that take any donations will probably need more tax forms, etc. If they aren't selling a verifiable service or product, I think the rules just got tougher. Posting the 2000 credit card numbers during their protest surely didn't help their cause.

Who will step forward and start a new payment system with the safety and security of the existing systems that won't terminate organizations that are political dynamite? Summer YC 11 perhaps?

What did the DDOS do? In my opinion, it will bring the very thing that no one wants... government regulation. The days of the anonymous internet are coming to a close. For a group of people that don't want laws controlling what they can and cannot do on the Internet, they have certainly pushed things in the wrong direction.

Will you sleep better at night once these cables are released? What if countries we made backdoor deals with decide to embargo the USA or worse, we decide to stop supplying Foreign Aid? What if that action leads to the USA reducing immigration or leads to more stringent borders? What if a regional conflict takes place because two countries we dealt with decided they didn't like the terms of the deal they accepted for peace? What if one country got shortchanged in a deal and now feels regret and decides to take action? What if that country decides to disallow US Citizens to leave the country and holds them as Political prisoners because they didn't like the deal they got? And this guy was there building a hydroelectric dam, or an irrigation system to help a country and is now held until the US meets that country's demands.

Why haven't the four newspapers that have complete copies been DDOSed for not releasing more cables? Why hasn't Assange released the password to his insurance file now that he's been detained and held without bail?

Sure some of my examples are on the edge of being realistic, but, none are a huge stretch from what could happen.

Re:Open Letter To Amazon on Friday December 03, 2010 @10:48AM (#1966225)
Wikileaks is under ddos. Amazon makes a ton of money during the Christmas holidays on their platform. ECS would have needed to redirect sysadmins from their normal tasks to monitor and segregate traffic to prevent any impact to their primary business.

Regardless of whether it is free speech or not, things that are detrimental to their primary business or impact other clients, violate their T&C. I would have turfed them too.

The attack is politically motivated. You don't see anyone attacking tpb because they maintain a tracker link to the 1.3tb archive. The attack is specifically against the domain, causing wikileaks to jump around from provider to provider. The attack doesn't prevent the data from being distributed. Four newspapers already had complete copies - one of which hired 12-14 people to write an interface in Django to collate and categorize.

The DDOS does nothing but prevent the people that want to casually see what the fuss is about from seeing it.

If you're that concerned that the information should be free, grab the 1.3tb copy and host it. Yeah, that's what I thought.

Re:Some fun mathematical puzzles on Saturday November 20, 2010 @03:32PM (#1925243)
Truly brilliant people don't need to tell other people they are brilliant.
Re:Turning the tables on a ZeuS botnet on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @02:12AM (#1859459)
love the xdr on this link
Re:Interesting Reflections of an 18 year old Programmer on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @02:08AM (#1859452)
What are you doing now that earns $200000/month?
Re:Ask HN: What is so special in working for Facebook? on Saturday October 30, 2010 @11:46AM (#1851064)
I like their philosophy that you can make changes and push them often so that you do see immediate gratification that your work means something. A typical non-startup developer's work could take years before it ever hit a desktop.

While the stock options that others mention is a motivator, typically companies use options to buy down your salary. You would make $120k, but, we're going to give you $90k + $30k in options that could be worth more than $30k in a few years. Pre dot-bomb, extremely greedy employees would work for a .com, trade huge amounts of salary for options and live frugally until the IPO. I can think of one guy that worked for Real Networks for a few years that took 66% of his pay in options which were underwater when his options matured.

Options are a payment type and are a gamble on the employee's part. The employer believes that shared ownership will also motivate employees, which makes those options worth more.

Re:Is HN only about saying nice things about everything? on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @12:10AM (#1832929)
No, because he THOUGHT it was wrong or misinformed. Large difference between something being wrong and him thinking it is wrong -- unless he is always right.

If something is factually correct, and he disagrees with it and thinks it is wrong, it gets a downvote. I was actually more amused that he got upvotes as it sort of reinforces the point I was trying to make.

By his logic, if we disagree with his point, we should downvote him, whether his opinion has merit or not.

Re:Is HN only about saying nice things about everything? on Monday October 25, 2010 @11:38PM (#1832831)
Too many people downvote people that they disagree with which is the downfall of a karma based system. What if you disagree, but they are right? Why do you dislike the fact that someone may have an opinion that differs from yours?

Downvoting people you disagree with implies that you are always right. I bow down to your perfection.

Re:Reddit Founder: “I Wish I Still Owned Reddit Now” on Thursday October 21, 2010 @04:37AM (#1814737)
Months ago an SMS provider advertised on reddit. Rather than downvote or ignore the link, there was a veritable flame war of people signing up for the beta just to waste the advertiser's time and quite a bit of animosity going back and forth. Even though most of the people in that conversation wouldn't have utilized the service, they attacked the advertiser because anything involving SMS must be spam.

Having witnessed many cases where redditors attacked, I would never consider advertising there. I can only imagine most of their advertisers advertise once and never again.

Re:StackOverflow launches chat on Friday October 15, 2010 @12:51PM (#1795249)
With few exceptions, the midrange karma scored ServerFault users eschew more misinformation or guesswork than fact. One poster necroed a thread that was 13 months old and posted information that hasn't been true since the early days of Mysql 4.x. I debated whether it was worth correcting the post.

The barrier to entry should be karma < 50 or karma > 9000. Oddly, StackOverflow's userbase is considerably more accurate, but, the median range karma scored user generally has been upvoted and given points that don't correspond to skill or knowledge, but, answers posted by those higher karma users, correct or not are valued more highly.

Once someone figures out how to get people to answer accurately without having to receive the +1 carrot, then you'll have a community worth contributing to. Right now, all you need to do on SF/SO is answer first, answer often and use technical jargon.