jeremy6d
Well, of course you can't _say_ that. That's the whole point of the article: that "passion" is a euphemism for the signaling companies do. We want passionate developers, and we get to define "passion" for you.
What makes hiring so hard is that it's a gamble. Human beings don't come with specs you can evaluate to know whether or not they will help or hurt your mission. But, you know what, companies don't come with specs that will tell an applicant whether the job will enhance or stifle one's life. I wish we could stop playing these word games that imply there are rigid patterns to what makes a successful employment relationship, and instead put that energy into getting to know human beings as they are.
I suppose one can be passionate about programming without setting oneself up for exploitation. But how many of us are? How many of us lose ourselves in technical problems as an alternative to living more full, self-actualized and self-aware lives? How many of us tell ourselves we're passionate about code to explain away the shitty work we have to do?
But I kind of resent the gist of the point you're making: that if you're not going to be a top-notch wage slave, you better tell your employer up front. Says who?
Your statement implies we are supposed to meet some standard of professionalism--a standard we have no say in, I might add, and that employers often excel at defining--and that we owe a duty to others to signal when we don't meet that standard. That standard is precisely what the author of the piece is attacking: the idea that if you are normal and human, you aren't good enough.
Enough with the guilt and the elevation of tech work into inherent value and meaningfulness. Most of us do what the goddamn boss says. Leave that crap at work, and never stop pushing for less work and more pay. After all, they're never going to stop pushing for more value for less money.
>In aggregate, by choosing to use Facebook, and by providing feedback and usage data that shapes how it changes.
I simply draw a different conclusion from that than you do. At some level we have chosen it, yes. I'm not denying that, but instead trying to figure out whether that level is necessary. I appreciate the pushback!
All I'm suggesting is that we design the keys ourselves. If that makes communication more difficult, perhaps it's also true that not all communication needs to be universally legible.
Maybe. As somebody who's worked in content management system design for a great deal of his career, I'm not at all convinced that the ongoing enclosure of information into systems of formatting serves people. Instead, what you find is people jumping through hoops to fit their information into the format chosen by others. Paul Goodman critiqued the tyranny of format 50 years ago, and Douglas Rushkoff authored the natural extension of this critique in his seminal "Program or Be Programmed". The promise of the internet has to be more than giving people text boxes, or I give up. :)
> We've organized our info this way because we like it and it makes sense, it's no surprise that it's useful to the government as well.
Really? The users of FB have decided that this is the way they'd like to organize their information? Surprising. I never recall in my use of FB being given the ability to structure the format as I and my friends see fit. I must have missed something.
In all seriousness, I think we need to look very carefully at this coupling of value you speak of. There are almost certainly areas where the format chosen by an authority (a corporation, a government, any institution really) is that that free individuals would choose. But not every area, and as the information gets more personal, the format becomes more restrictive. I'm not sure where the line between sharing on one's own terms and another's terms gets crossed, but any network that can aggregate detailed information about BILLIONS of people has certainly crossed it. The question is simply whether or not we should be content with this situation.
What we need are tools that allow us to connect in ways that are difficult not only to detect but also to make sense of (not necessarily encryption, but an ad-hoc format that can't be easily parsed and aggregated). We need the ability to use the network for our own particular, peculiar interests rather than having to fit our interactions into some other authority's template for their interests. The idea that social networking never occurred before Friendster, FB, MySpace is ridiculous -- it just happened more informally before.
I'd like to see a return to this informal mode of using TCP/IP, where the internet itself is the social network rather than merely a transport layer for some centralized system. This may make it harder for everyday people to benefit, but it also means they learn how to drive before they use the roads. Social networking's hyped-up promise has always been to passively connect people, but the promise of the internet has always been to allow people to actively connect (or not connect). Once we have a broader suite of tools for this latter purpose, we'll see people reject centralized dossier services like FB.
What we need is a kind of guild for developers. We can't improve our conditions if it's all about maximizing our take home. We have to seek control over the way software development is performed, setting new standards for what is expected of clients and developers. We need to take charge of providing better educations for new developers. We need the open source model to become the primary way code is written, instead of something capital exploits in order to free ride on the "commons" of the community.
People who reduce it all to making a salary can go far, but they're not doing anything for the community who's shoulders they're standing on. Right now we have a scarce skill, but people are trying to find ways to deskill programming and make it a mindless commodity anybody can do. Maybe they'll figure that out one day. We should have a backup plan as an industry.
The concerns are not bullshit, but the way they are addressed is. But they're not addressing the issue as human beings but as ideologues whipping a fallen humanity into shape, so what do you expect?
The whole argument that society is riddled with privileges is not supposed to be an indictment of individuals. By it's very nature, privilege means that you don't have it because of something you did or are as an individual. It's a systemic feature of society, not some personal moral failing.
So if Ryan's article evinces sexism (and I question that greatly) the proper response is not to harangue him into self-censorship. This just bullies him for something he is not personally responsible for while driving the systemic problem deeper down. What we should be doing is having an open conversation about it.
But now we can't, because it's so objectionable to reflect the sexism we all have within us that we must pretend we're beyond it. How is this in the interests of genuine egalitarianism?