graphific
Re:GitXiv: Collaborative Open Computer Science
on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:50PM (#9998236)
Nice post and especially your blog post "gitwikxiv". So many models & projects are already out there: PaperBricks, http://knowen.org/, https://www.authorea.com/, https://casetext.com/, https://www.sharelatex.com/, https://selectedpapers.net/, http://stacks.math.columbia.edu/, https://www.codalab.org/, https://pubpeer.com/, http://thinklab.com/publications
With GitXiv as one commenter also implied we really want to focus on building a bridge between the 2 core issues of making real research possible/replicatable: articles & code (of course with the 3th even more difficult problem to solve being "data"), as well as building a community around it. Another point of focus is making everything what goes on with GitXiv as transparent as possible, ie by having public "issues" at github (https://github.com/samim23/GitXiv/issues), and open discussions at our wiki: https://github.com/samim23/GitXiv/wiki/Thoughts-on-GitXiv
Jess: Let's have a hangout for sure!
Re:GitXiv: Collaborative Open Computer Science
on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:37PM (#9998084)
yes you nailed it. At the moment if there are multiple implementation the author can just (rather arbitrarily) add the github implementation he/she likes the most as "github" link, and other code implementations as side links. ie rnn-char (http://gitxiv.com/posts/W6Y3pLrEAG5jmuJzz/char-rnn) main and original torch implementation, with to the side extra info + links to pure python, chainer, caffe (apollo).
Maybe not the most elegant solution, but it works for now :)