gergo_v
Utilizing the Simplicity of Go for Easy Development
German Conficker B infection drives ‘Count in Fives’ ad fraud botnet
I think this is either willful ignorance or a complete misunderstanding of the fraud ecosystem. It's not about click through rates by a long shot.
But since the OP's main argument seems to be how the bigger ecosystem of online advertising already accounts for fraud, let's take that further. With this attitude, he's effectively saying that:
- They're okay with indirectly sponsoring the spread of viruses and trojans (rationale being: it's cheap!)
- They're okay with paying some dudes with some smart scripts (eg. the fraud mechanisms) the same amount of money as hard-working content creators and publishers
- And they don't care enough about the budget either. Accountability is apparently a fairy tale in this context?
The industry is under heavy fire regarding this subject as it is, and I'm not sure whether this attitude is going to further the conversation.
Verizon, NetFlix, KFC ad-men pay traffic cons $500k a month
http://ipensatori.com/2015/03/20/google-update-to-software-d...
Dissecting a “Six-Figures-a-Month” video ad fraud operation
What Analytics can and can not do to help you find bot traffic?
Russian referer spam abusing the Huffingtonpost brand for profit
The referrer itself is not at all used in tracking the user - as the visitor data is usually aggregated by referring source. Fingerprinting and evercookies are much more common ways of tracking individual users, and you can bet that there are even more advanced methods available for government agencies with service-level access.
Not to mention the fact that brand advertisers are really picky on where they are being promoted. They're dipping their toes in real time bidding platforms, but that's a whole different beast to tackle.
Here's a short article explaining the process and the Verge covered the subject in length: http://ipensatori.com/2014/05/27/tech-support-scams-what-lie...
http://www.theverge.com/2012/5/10/2984893/scamworld-get-rich...
Add to that the fact that a lot of companies only care if the ROI is positive, no matter the cost, with the middlemen making money both on bot generated and human generated impressions, and you've got a whole messy business on your hands.
Source: our company just won 500k in investment at Slush to battle this specific problem.