datadata
datadata on Hacker News
In the gravity example, you have a clear way to make a prediction and test it. The concept of gravity can clearly map via perception to reality, and thus the truth.
Most of the questions in this article given as examples of massive disagreements however are not like this. They hinge on interpreting the definitions of concepts we have invented that do not map so clearly to reality. The debate is often entirely over the definitions of the concepts themselves, not over reality or truth. It is more about language than physics.
There is an objective truth for the physical reality of things, but that truth immediately gets murkier as you step away from physics or into more abstract concepts. It is important to establish that objective truth is out there, but it is not sufficient, as many of these questions (from the article) can't be directly answered by reality:
"Covid-19 escaped from a Chinese laboratory." is something that could be answered by reality one way or another, with a hypothetical perfect observer. A single fact could answer this question.
"Climate change demands a radical transformation of modern lifestyles." This question is about the future, rather than the past, so it depends on our ability to assess the truth about predictions of objective reality, rather than merely to analyze objective reality directly. Reality can help us build better predictive models, but it can't decisively say if this statement is true or not. You could say that the future is part of the objective reality, but here we are forbidden from being able to perceive it at all.
Finally, "Donald Trump colluded with Vladimir Putin to get elected." This one concerns only past events, it could definitely be resolved with knowledge about some specific fact from objective reality. However, in the absence of such a fact appearing we are forced to make decisions about the intents of people to make a judgement. I have trouble with the idea that this could be mapped directly to objective reality, ie something like collusion is an objective state of the brain that could be perfectly classified in theory. I think that our concept of "collusion" here is the problem-- it is simply not well defined enough to be used in a way that is not fraught with disagreement. Put another way, it is entirely possible that perfect observers of Trump and Putin would not agree with each other on this question, and that is a problem.
To summarize, objective reality is important, it really exists and can of course be used to find the truth in many ways. But we are stuck with concepts that are not part of objective reality, when those concepts show up in questions, objective reality might not be of much help.
Doesn't "past history" imply something that is no longer happening?
Are you implying that existing financial institutions have put this type of scam entirely in the past? Because they certainly have not.
It seems so obvious to us that this is a short term win at the expense of the long term. I wonder if data driven companies like this are locked into local minimums via tons of short term optimizations to boost metrics.
In optimization algorithms like stochastic gradient descent, some form of entropy (crucially temporarily decreasing fitness) or exploration (having parallel evaluations of the fitness function) is necessary to not get stuck. What mechanism incentivizes this in a large corporation, where every initiative must aim to improve the business and there is the capability to actually measure it all?
Rather than a ban, would a very large tax for any ad spend work as a policy? This would seem to both reduce the overall number of ads, and force advertisers to allocate more resources to making better targeted ads that are more profitable per impression. My opposition to ads is not that they have no utility, but rather there is not sufficient compensation for the human attention that they (nearly) freely exploit and waste.
Ironically there are even billboards about how other distractions like texting while driving kills.
Arguably nuclear is more abundant and lower cost.
The fact that we all seem to agree that rich countries will pay a premium to keep their rivers clean seems to at the very least undermine the central argument of the article that capitalism places zero value on preserving the environment.
I don't see your point? I didn't say that capitalism leads to conflict, merely that not pursuing economic growth should lead to being overwhelmed by those that do.
Sure, but that is not a stable solution. Defection is rewarded.
I don't disagree, but I think the Darwinian part transcends the idea of incentives. You wouldn't say that a tree has an incentive to reproduce, as a byproduct of a Darwinian natural selection they are guaranteed to have that property. Similarly, civilizations that have economic activity are guaranteed (in a Darwinian sense) to have economic growth.
The valuing of economic growth seems to be almost required as a Darwinian feature of nations. Resolve as a nation to value economic growth less than your neighbors, and you will soon be overpowered by them.
People might be able to see it coming, but could still be enticed by the riches to be made for a while by playing the game even while knowing how it ends.
I think article is saying the problem is not with the Jetsons, but with society. Meaning it is a problem we have realized the flawed vision of the future presented.
If you were an associate, wouldn't this make you more, rather than less, likely to assassinate him? I.E. if I don't take action I'll be thrown out a window next anyway?
> You can support immigrants being allowed to work without supporting all parts of the system!
This is my exact position. You are assuming I am against immigration. In the big picture, the system that makes immigration is not compassionate, but it would also not be compassionate in the small picture to stop immigration.
If the US is supporting the worse conditions that make taking the job the lesser evil, and benefiting from the resultant labor (as parent comment claims), then it isn't really compassionate to support that system, as the system depends largely on suppressing quality of life elsewhere rather than creating opportunity. An analogy is that it might be the lessor evil for an African centuries ago to get on a slave ship rather than to be murdered on the spot. That doesn't make supporting slavery compassionate.
It is possible that website loading is bottlenecked by latency and an irreducible number of round trips needed. Bandwidth is not obviously a bottleneck.
Cheaper labor is sought, but also workers are capable of doing more and more productive work due to technology. The net is economic growth. Maybe I am an optimist, but generally things have gotten better. For example poverty globally has been plummeting.
Given also this announcement is a new capability for how to get paid, not an impairment or obligation, I would hope it wouldn't have detrimental results.
You have said several times, "there is no regulation in cryto". If you know that this statement is not true, then why do you say it? Just say that there are many instances where lack of regulation has lead to bad results. I agree with that.
Do you honestly think there is zero accountability or regulations for all of crypto? Would not a single fee levied towards a crypto company for violation of a law invalidate the point you are trying to make?
I would agree with you that more regulation is needed, but to keep saying there is zero regulation is either ignorant or disingenuous. Regulation can also coexist with something that is decentralized and is not obviously adversarial, e.g. we have regulations for gold markets to prevent scams, etc.
This is what the arguments you are making sound like to me:
One single failure on an airplane can kill hundreds of people, even a single line of code could crash several planes. There are just thousands of accidents waiting to happen. Planes do not work. They have had a hundred years to make planes perfectly safe. Every year more and more people fly. It is a system designed to fail.
> smart contracts don't work and are broken
This absolute statement is asserting that ALL smart contracts don't work. There is overwhelming evidence of some smart contracts working just fine, and of course a lot of smart contracts also have problems. It is wild to just drop all of the nuance of such a complicated issue. What new technology has been flawless without any failures along the way?
From the article:
> Speed is one advantage of crypto payouts. Reach is another. Millions of talented freelancers live in countries where it’s hard, if not impossible, to open a local bank account. For example, a majority of the people in Djibouti, El Salvador, and Bhutan don't have bank accounts. With Stripe, freelancers in those countries are now able to receive funds via USDC in minutes. With the addition of USDC, Stripe cross-border payouts extend to more than 4.4 billion people in more than 110 countries—a majority of the world’s population.
Just like the ordinal number in the study of infinite sets
How would you tie housing costs to cars?
> Here's the number to pay attention to. CPI increases are accelerating
This by itself is not surprising. The fed has a target of 2% inflation which means that even in the best case, CPI will by an exponential that gains 2% per year.
When I was observing the 2017 total solar eclipse, my attention was interrupted for a few seconds by someone who was driving a car. Their headlights turned on as they kept driving, not stopping for a minute to see something that for a given place on earth happens once every four centuries. The few people dismissing this reminded me of that experience.