News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

datadata

In addition to location mattering as others have pointed out, time also matters a lot. Charge up during the day, you might be using solar. At night, that isn't likely anymore.
Re:Large-scale ‘sand battery’ goes online in Finland on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @07:12PM (#32008044)
Newton's law of cooling just says that your loss is going to be proportional to the temperature difference. But 1) the capacity of the battery is also proportional to the temperature difference, so the loss as a percentage of total energy stored should be roughly a constant. 2) If the application is home heating, you can't heat the home to a higher temperature than the battery itself, and you also can't easily group together the energy into a higher temperature. You would on the other hand want a high temperature for the heat to transfer quickly from the convection medium to the actual houses. So starting hot would make a lot of sense despite the downsides?
I don't want Wayland to be exactly compatible with Xorg. Progress requires abandoning cruft and committing to a hopefully better design. I moved to Wayland 100% earlier this year and not looking back.
Re:Why I’m Cryptophobic on Thursday June 30, 2022 @02:54PM (#31936894)
In 1999, what web1 companies had cash flows or even a business model that could become profitable? In hindsight it is obvious because we know that things worked out, but at the time it was just speculation, and the crash was the market calling it worthless. Similar objections then around what underlying value is and how the tech was useless. The ways to monetize often were invented much later (eg search ads).

If you were a middle age farmer, sure you might like to look at or smell a flower but you would be crazy to say stop growing wheat and plant tulips. But as society advances markets can emerge to serve needs of people that were not possible before.

I agree crypto tokens is just speculative investing. But that doesn't imply that the value doesn't stick-- it doesn't have to either collapse to zero or go up forever. Monetary premium is a real thing and necessary for humans to transact. You can't predict what money we will use in the future.

Re:Why I’m Cryptophobic on Thursday June 30, 2022 @02:24PM (#31936459)
Flowers were not a commodity before there was a market for them. Internet did not have commercial value before the speculative wave, in fact very little profits were made even by the end of the dot com boom. Agree there is rife speculation in crypto, but rife speculation does not prove that there won't be future sustained value. When dot com boom imploded it was because people similarly thought there was no value in the internet.
Re:Why I’m Cryptophobic on Thursday June 30, 2022 @02:17PM (#31936352)
The physical inputs to bitcoin are decentralized and robust against disruption. You don't need to be a miner yourself to store or transact.

> You need fiat to buy energy.

This is a circular argument and not true. You can buy energy today with gold or bitcoin.

Re:Why I’m Cryptophobic on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:20PM (#31934778)
Excellent point. This also lends to it being easier for US tax subjects to use the dollar as a unit of account and ignore its (small, but not insignificant and always trending downward) value changes. I think a crypto wallet app that optimized for this problem would be super valuable, e.g. making doing taxes of these transactions seamless, and suggesting paying using a currency that is optimal for taxes (e.g. realizing a loss if that is possible, because then your purchase would come with a tax credit.) There are also efforts by legislators to enable de minimis exemptions for crypto transactions (taxes waived if the transaction size is sufficiently small)
Re:Why I’m Cryptophobic on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:14PM (#31934667)
> The notion of property rights is only relevant with a central authority who is able to enforce it.

The innovation of bitcoin is precisely making this statement no longer true. The "property" might only be digital data, rather than physical things, so you can argue that it is no longer true in only a limited context, but it is not longer absolutely true.

Re:Why I’m Cryptophobic on Thursday June 30, 2022 @12:03PM (#31934484)
Whenever this comparison is drawn, it must also be pointed out that after the speculative bubble, the Netherlands has remained for centuries the center of a profitable and stable flower industry that was born in that time. The collapse was real and the speculation was real, but the emergence of a new industry was also real. This is also similar example to the dot com bubble.
Re:Why I’m Cryptophobic on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:54AM (#31934318)
For daily transactions at the current gold price, it would be extremely hard to do this sort of measurement that way with any precision without very specialized equipment. A gram of gold (around $60) is a reasonable daily transaction size and has a volume of 0.05ml. In order to distinguish metals of similar densities, you'd have to be able to measure just a fraction of that volume accurately. Maybe there is some clever system to scale this down, but wasn't obvious to me.
Re:Why I’m Cryptophobic on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:43AM (#31934126)
Modern art reproducers can make copies of the Mona Lisa that experts can't easily distinguish from the original. This kind of replica fraud happens often in the art world. I find it interesting to try to justify the value of the original when it is almost zero cost to have an exact replica of the original. The scarcity is not real, or at least the scarcity of being able to enjoy the intrinsic value of looking at the painting is not real. When you remove that part, the value lies only in being able to verify the authenticity of the work, rather than in its quality as art.
Re:Why I’m Cryptophobic on Thursday June 30, 2022 @11:42AM (#31934093)
> For crypto to have value, someone else needs to pay Dollar/Euro/whatever at an exchange. That's the value of crypto - the exchange rate.

This is true for every economic good, including paintings. Whether the value is "inherent" or not is irrelevant, you need a transaction or the value is just theory. Culture could also forget about the significance of the Mona Lisa, it has happened before, see for example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archimedes_Palimpsest, a mathematical text that our culture considers having very high value, but was overwritten into a prayer book by a culture that considered the work less valuable than the material it was written on.

> The only atmosphere being cleaned is that which passes through the machine.

This is like saying that the only gasoline that is consumed is that which is burned up in a car. 1) A car can still be useful without consuming all gasoline in the world. This machine could be economically viable given carbon credit structures as well, it doesn't have to scale to solve the problem on its own, it just has to be efficient enough to be worth building (I'm not claiming that it meets this criteria). 2) Clearly we could actually use up the majority of gasoline on earth, there is no reason why scaling something that much is impossible.

> with currents and what-not, meaning this machine needs to be all over the globe to make meaningful impact.

Are you really saying this is an obstacle-- that if we wanted to make 1 million of these machines we would be unable to distribute them, and that furthermore we would completely clean the co2 from the atmosphere over a single country before the currents and what-not would bring in more co2 for the machines to consume? If this is true, then why do we care about co2 emissions in other countries currently?

> We don't know the emission cost of producing these machines - but it certainly isn't zero. We also don't know the emission cost of the energy being produced to power these things (which even with geo-thermal, is not zero either).

I agree that we need to know this and the other factors and that they are larger than zero, but it is critically important to know the actual values, or at least a rough estimate. How are you so confident whether it would work or not without knowing them, or even giving an estimate and doing the napkin math?

I challenge you to actually do the napkin math here, rather than continue to state your claim that it achieves "nearly no results" without anything quantifying what that means. You might actually be right, but I don't really find your arguments persuasive at all. Regarding sucking all of the atmosphere through a machine, it is unclear why that is either impossible or necessary for this to be useful.
By waste heat I meant that geothermal energy would eventually be released into the environment regardless of if humans extract useful work from it on the way. My assumption was that the article was talking about the waste of energy in this sense. My own opinion is that the waste heat from energy usage is negligible relative to thermal contribution of carbon emissions. I wrote a comment a few months ago here with some questions about this kind of metric, as someone apparently working in this space I would be most curious about your opinion on these things: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30989744
> It would quite literally be better to not even build it in the first place it seems

You have to quantify these things in some way, otherwise you are making purely subjective claims. I don't think this project does a good job of using data to quantify that it is useful, but it is even less legitimate to dismiss it in the same way. How do you measure that a Data Center would be a better use of this power? How would a prototype of a project that "packages" energy for transport also not just be perceived as a total waste of effort?

Shouldn't the comparison be carbon removed by this per unit energy used vs carbon produced by hydrocarbon powered power plant per unit energy created? E.g doing the math with some looked up data, this removes 1 ton of carbon per 2.5MWH. One ton of coal generates 8.1MWH. One ton of goal generates 2.4 tons of CO2, So it my math is correct (please verify), this already runs at an efficiency ratio of (8.1 (MWH) / 2.4 (tons CO2) / 2.5 (MWH / tons CO2) ) = 1.35, which being larger than 1 already, means that hypothetically you could power this via a coal plant and have a system that is net carbon negative and/or has some extra power remaining? Obviously we shouldn't do that, but to me the energy efficiency here is pretty impressive.
> Not so quick. Does a layman have any reference point to what is considered "a lot" of carbon?

I don't think a comparison to another producer of carbon would actually help a layman. Whether that is a lot or not would depend on the cost and energy used by the plant itself, which isn't really given in this article.

> That may be so, but this still doesn't make this a good use of that surplus.

Why? Suppose there is no other demand for that energy. What is actually wasted in that case? How do you measure what is "good"?

> Car emissions are really good on average. As technology progresses, it might be fathomable that 7,900 cars, or eventually 79,000 cars produce the same amount of emissions as today. This "metric" sounds impressive, but it's useless.

Thankfully that's why the article first gave the metric in tons of carbon, which has no such ambiguity.

> So why are we not just using the geothermal energy powering this thing to charge electric vehicles or power homes?

My understanding is that there is generally an over supply of renewable energy in Iceland. Historically it attracted location agnostic consumers like aluminum smelting and bitcoin mining as consumers of this energy, because there wasn't any other demand for the renewable energy in Iceland.

> DAC’s energy usage, particularly when it’s considered in conjunction with the (relatively minuscule) amount of CO2 it’s capturing, is its biggest drawback. Sourcing the energy from renewable sources helps, but it’s still not unlimited nor free.

What are the actual downsides of energy usage here given that the enterprise is strongly carbon negative? Given that it is consuming geothermal energy in Iceland, 1) wouldn't the energy become waste heat in the environment regardless, 2) Is there a consumer of the energy that would be "better"?

Re:It is your responsibility to follow up (2019) on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @09:17PM (#31915318)
Not sure about that. The additional messages can be automated, especially by those who send tons of emails (salespeople and recruiters, for example)
Re:It is your responsibility to follow up (2019) on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @01:30PM (#31910555)
Interesting, I had always thought the term came from the actual example of Boston: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boston_Common, and the depletion of resources in Rapa Nui is another prime example of a failure case. In any case, we have useful concepts that come literally from myths, e.g. "Faustian bargain", maybe this concept will eventually go that way?
Re:It is your responsibility to follow up (2019) on Tuesday June 28, 2022 @10:44AM (#31908345)
This feels like a tragedy of the commons. The person being emailed has a finite amount of attention. Sending additional emails will only prioritize your topic for their attention until everyone does this trick, at which point the advantage of multiple emails will converge back to zero.
Curious to what degree and how you think web of trust idea could help here? Assume you could use it to prove whether an article was signed or not by a real person. I think this would solve the problem of articles being published with a false author attribution. However, it would not work to prevent actual people from publishing AI written articles using their own identity. It would also not (directly) do anything to establish if the facts in an article are correct or not.
Re:Three Arrows Capital reportedly facing insolvency on Monday June 20, 2022 @07:13PM (#31817457)
Proposing opening an LLC is a pretty involved workaround that again requires more supervision and gatekeeping (e.g, for many people and many countries this is not even possible). Cash like settlement with any person on the planet without any intermediary is a pretty big technical achievement that absolutely was not possible before blockchain.
The notion of a fee amount of a new car is wildly implausible. The current block subsidy is 6.25 BTC, about 200k at recent prices where mining was clearly functional. A block can fit around 2000 transactions. Your scenario of a run where blocks are full and fees are the value of a new car (call that $10000) would imply a total miner reward of 20 million, about 100x the block reward that is currently enough to attract minors. In such a scenario if 100x the reward for minors, mining would be wildly profitable.
If governments are successful in manipulating money to avoid volatility, why are these still scores of hyperinflation failed currencies, financial crises due to too much debt, and so on? Why is these not a clear law of economics that can lead to stability and no recessions?
Re:Three Arrows Capital reportedly facing insolvency on Sunday June 19, 2022 @02:21PM (#31801895)
Do you think a bearer asset like cash has zero use cases? Bitcoin allows settlement much like this with a party that doesn't need to be identified and already trusted by a central clearing house. Of course this can be dangerous and might not be desirable for every transaction, but there clearly a technological achievement to make it possible.
Re:Bitcoin Falls Below $20k for the First Time Since 2020 on Saturday June 18, 2022 @02:10PM (#31792291)
No one said that USD is going anywhere. As you pointed out for bitcoin, the people who work on or invest in bitcoin are not part of the asset. This is the same for USD also. Visa equity is the most different amongst the three.
Re:Three Arrows Capital reportedly facing insolvency on Saturday June 18, 2022 @01:46PM (#31792062)
I'm not sure why you are talking about stock trading. Settlement is a general, non stock specific thing. I'm talking about settlement in regular transactions, e.g. paying rent or buying groceries.

Older »