News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

datadata

Re:Bitcoin Falls Below $20k for the First Time Since 2020 on Saturday June 18, 2022 @01:41PM (#31792012)
You are conflating price volatility with inflation. Stocks are also down in price this year for the same reason. Stocks are not inflationary either.
Re:Three Arrows Capital reportedly facing insolvency on Saturday June 18, 2022 @10:26AM (#31790071)
If the network is under load you can prioritize by paying a higher fee. If mining slows down it can take more time for a block, but difficultly will adjust to get back to 10mim cadence.

I'm not sure what you mean by centrally registered clients. You can still use bitcoin peer to peer. Also the idea that banning peer to peer bitcoin would be what would make decentralization not worthwhile feels rather circular.

Re:Bitcoin Falls Below $20k for the First Time Since 2020 on Saturday June 18, 2022 @10:17AM (#31790011)
As a lower bound it would need to be high enough to support the largest supported transaction. If the market cap of bitcoin was only $100, you could not transact $200.
Re:Bitcoin Falls Below $20k for the First Time Since 2020 on Saturday June 18, 2022 @10:09AM (#31789978)
Visa has value (on top of it's utility) because it is able to take a 1-3% cut of all payments that use the visa network.

Suppose bitcoin gave the equivalent utility as visa but for negligible fees. In this world, you would have the same utility for a lower cost, and the equity value of Visa would conceivably go to zero. My point is that converting utility to value depends on the ability to monetize something. If there was somehow a screw monopoly, I'm guessing the "value" of screws would go way up even with fixed utility. This of course was also true when the cost of producing a screw was much higher in the past. Technology is deflationary.

I don't know what the value of bitcoin should be (nor do I think it has comparable utility to visa), but we are undoubtedly in world where too much value is extracted from financial services relative to the utility that they provide. I think that will be disrupted, but have no idea what, if anything, will be valuable after it is disrupted.

Re:Bitcoin Falls Below $20k for the First Time Since 2020 on Saturday June 18, 2022 @09:40AM (#31789715)
There is of course news that matters to bitcoin and impacts the price. When China banned bitcoin, one would expect price to go down. When Tesla bought bitcoin, price should go up. By your argument all commodities would also fall into the same camp.
Re:Three Arrows Capital reportedly facing insolvency on Saturday June 18, 2022 @09:33AM (#31789668)
Sure, I was merely commenting on the cost to physically secure the asset. Necessary (to prevent theft) but not sufficient.
Re:Bitcoin Falls Below $20k for the First Time Since 2020 on Saturday June 18, 2022 @09:30AM (#31789651)
That is irrelevant here. The argument that bitcoin is not inflationary is merely that it has a supply cap. USD has no supply cap but it obviously has lower price volatility. That said, it is the Fed's goal to purposefully reduce the purchasing power of USD by 2% every year, so the trajectory is clear.
Re:Three Arrows Capital reportedly facing insolvency on Saturday June 18, 2022 @09:16AM (#31789557)
Rolling over our current national debt at the current rates will make the debt servicing costs too high relative to tax income. So either rates cannot stay high indefinitely, or inflation will continue until debt is smaller compared to tax income. In both cases money becomes cheap. The average maturity on debt is 5 years which is where I got that time scale, but this is also in line with previous cycle lengths-- you can't find many times where the fed has waited longer to cut rates. Debt has also never been this high as a percent of GDP, so more pressure from that shouldead to faster policy changes.
Re:Bitcoin Falls Below $20k for the First Time Since 2020 on Saturday June 18, 2022 @09:11AM (#31789523)
> Bitcoin has no assets.

Cash just as well "has no assets". You can't just compare bitcoin to a corporation and get something that makes sense.

Re:Three Arrows Capital reportedly facing insolvency on Saturday June 18, 2022 @09:01AM (#31789459)
These work if you either have a master fed account or have credit with some bank that does. You can't settle instantly with an entity that is not already known in the system.
Re:Bitcoin Falls Below $20k for the First Time Since 2020 on Saturday June 18, 2022 @08:30AM (#31789250)
Normally by inflation it is meant "monetary inflation", price has no bearing on this.
Re:Three Arrows Capital reportedly facing insolvency on Friday June 17, 2022 @09:15PM (#31786469)
I think the settlement story for bitcoin is actually superior than with USD/EUR. Yes you have to wait 10min x a few blocks, but that is final, irreversible settlement.
Re:Three Arrows Capital reportedly facing insolvency on Friday June 17, 2022 @08:55PM (#31786359)
Cheap money will come back again also, at least within 3-5 years
Re:Three Arrows Capital reportedly facing insolvency on Friday June 17, 2022 @08:50PM (#31786329)
What would invalidate your belief that it is all just a greater fool scam?
Re:Three Arrows Capital reportedly facing insolvency on Friday June 17, 2022 @08:24PM (#31786179)
The cost to store crypto is quite negliable compared to the cost to store gold.

Easy to hide a billion dollars of bitcoin on a USB stick for 10 years. Good luck storing a billion dollars of gold, you couldn't even physically move it by yourself.

Re:Federal Reserve raises rates by 0.75% on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @04:59PM (#31759405)
A good chunk of the debt (~9 trillion) is owned by the Fed itself. When the bank finances a mortgage for example, because it is a fractional reserve system the bank is lending only a small fraction of its own capital. The bank simply borrows from the fed either directly or indirectly by selling. The bank's profit is that the mortgage interest rate on the mortgage (and risk) is higher than that of the risk free borrow rate.
Re:Federal Reserve raises rates by 0.75% on Wednesday June 15, 2022 @04:51PM (#31759321)
What's worse is that some of the inflation becomes masked because of shortages. So in a simple picture if the government gives money out to buy baby food, but there is no baby food, the price people are willing to pay for baby food would go up since they have money, but not recorded as inflation since they are not making purchases.
Thanks for elaborating, I think this distinction does actually make sense. I do however still think that the this definition of intrinsic value does not really matter for justifying a "real" price. The intrinsic value ultimately is still backed by transactions that are at some point themselves market set prices without intrinsic value. There isn't any natural law that would say fix the price of 2 oranges to 1 apple that could support any particular trade. You could also for example use this definition to talk about the intrinsic value of equity in a bitcoin only exchange (from trading fees), which would obviously become zero if bitcoin went to zero.
So a cultural convention for consensus on using a particular TLD is part of your definition of intrinsic value for a domain name. But for gold, the monetary premium for a similar social consensus is entirely distinct from the intrinsic value:

> But a portion of gold's market value is driven by a speculative spread over the intrinsic value, similar to BTC.

What is the definition of intrinsic value that allows both of these interpretations to be true?

In your belief system, what perpetuates for example the price difference between a .com domain and a .net domain? Is there an intrinsic value of .com over .net? Or do you believe that they should be equally priced.
What is the point of raising this distinction? Air has infinite value/worth to every human, but its price is zero. It would make as little sense to start accumulating air on the converse assumption that something that has value will eventually have a non-zero price as it would to short bitcoin on the hypothesis that it will eventually be priced at zero because it is worth zero. The goal of investing/speculating is increase the price fetched for assets you control. You can only do that with prices, value is irrelevant.
I agree with all of this, when I said "nothing" I meant just that "intrinsic value" is not what determines the price of something, in response to the parent's assertion about intrinsic value setting a price floor on oil
I think that's just an extra step in your argument about intrinsic value. Now you have to analyze why the price of energy is $10/hour. That transaction is just another thing determined by a market where there isn't actually intrinsic value that sets the price, but another buyer. You can analyze this series of transactions forever, but you won't ever arrive at a point where the intrinsic value of something is what sets a price directly.

Note: I completely agree with you on the concept of an equilibrium price being a real thing, I just don't think equilibrium is determined by intrinsic value.

Air has a extremely high intrinsic value for its use in keeping humans alive. Yet the price of air is zero. Intrinsic value does not determine the price of something, the only determination of price is by a market.
How can you measure the intrinsic value of oil other than with a market? I agree it should have a non zero value in theory, but my point is that the price of anything is determined only by what someone else is willing to pay for it. The fundamental value could be $1000 a barrel or $0.01 a barrel, the only way to find out is to have a market. Also, just because the fundamental value is > 0, it does not mean that the price must be > 0. If there is no buyer or no functional market, the price can be exactly 0.
But it is entirely made up, it entirely depends on someone buying the oil and the price they are willing to pay. The fact that there is in principle a use for oil does not mean that there is a buyer, especially since oil is not truly fungible in that it has storage and transit costs. As an example, oil famously via future contracts traded at negative $37 during the covid crisis, meaning that you would have to pay someone to take oil off your hands.

The fact that it is used in daily productive activity might be an argument that oil should in theory have a > 0 price, however the actual price is still made up by a market! There is still not a way to say that the intrinsic value of oil must be X dollars.

There is actually no upside limit, but there is a fundamental downside limit of zero.

What justifies oil being $130 dollars a barrel vs $100? The answer is also nothing.

Re:Please, don't build another Large Hadron Collider on Tuesday June 07, 2022 @04:49AM (#31651505)
This article brings to mind the plot point [SPOILER ALERT] in "The Three-Body Problem" where the antagonistic and technologically superior aliens halt the progress of our entire civilization merely with nanotechnology that impedes science at our particle accelerators, thus preventing breakthroughs in physics.
Re:Tether Withdrawals Top $10B on Tuesday May 24, 2022 @08:08PM (#31499070)
I think there is just no way you could have a traditional bank provide the capabilities that tether provides. It acts like a bank, but it certainly does things that banking regulations to not actually regulate, and there is no way tether would have been granted a bank charter. Like it or not, waiting for regulation is not a way to build something that is new. As for forgiveness, not for permission.
Re:Tether Withdrawals Top $10B on Tuesday May 24, 2022 @07:58PM (#31498988)
Agreed, I think N would have to be too high to depend on this entirely, and high N looks a lot like insolvency. But it could still buffer against a partial bank run.

Older »