News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

datadata

Re:Tether Withdrawals Top $10B on Tuesday May 24, 2022 @03:32PM (#31496560)
Here is an example: https://www.capitalone.com/bank/disclosures/savings-accounts...

> Advance Notice of Withdrawal: Under federal law, we must reserve the right to require you to give us at least 7 days written notice before you take money out of your 360 Savings. (This hardly ever happens but legally we have to say it!)

Re:The Bitcoin Investment Thesis Is Broken on Tuesday May 24, 2022 @03:31PM (#31496541)
It is notable that Bitcoin took fewer years than both Google and FB to reach a 1 trillion market cap. Now market cap is a pretty horrible metric (and 1 trillion is arbitrary), but one way to compare totally different things. Note that bitcoin has always been the dominant cryptocurrency, and google/FB were dominant search engine/social networks much earlier than they reached 1 trillion market cap. What took a long time for them was for the market to value those innovations more highly. In crypto's case, the market valuation actually came quite quickly.

> The volatility of BTC/USD has only increased

Do you have a source for this? The data I have seen is that it is just slightly decreasing if anything, but there are many ways to measure volatility.

Re:Tether Withdrawals Top $10B on Tuesday May 24, 2022 @02:31PM (#31495832)
> In theory, every single USDT in circulation could be redeemed at a moment's notice

The easy way to protect against this is to not contractually promise instant redemption. I think this is what tether actually does, but I could not find a source. Regular savings account banks do typically do this, for example the bank has the right to ask for 7 days to honor a withdrawal.

If you are tether and your asserts are in bonds that mature in under N days, then you could just promise redemption within N days to eliminate bank run risk. You would still of course have counter party risk that when the bond matures it is not paid back.

Re:Index funds officially overtake active managers on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:24PM (#31471760)
Debt based monetary policy is the root ponzi here. Our rate of assuming new debt depends on the assumption of endless economic growth.
Re:.01% of Bitcoin holders hold 27% of all Bitcoin on Saturday May 21, 2022 @07:07PM (#31463006)
If you had a lot of capital, you could also deploy that capital completely outside of crypto, multiply it, then come back into crypto to have a larger stake in the crypto assset than you started. So your comment is true, but really applies to every freely traded economic asset.

Anyway, the mining/staking in crypto isn't primarily about increasing wealth, it is about defending the blockchain. In this aspect, there is a huge difference between the PoW and PoS. If someone has >50% of a PoS token, there is no way to usurp their control of the blockchain unless they willingly sell their tokens. With PoW, because the mining uses a different resource (energy), it is always possible to invest more capital to usurp the control of the blockchain by creating a larger hashrate. The ownership structure of the actual PoW token doesn't really matter, because outside capital can be introduced into the system.

Re:The Great Crypto Grift May Be Unwinding on Thursday May 19, 2022 @12:54AM (#31430939)
> Especially when you have to assume that we live in some fantasy world where nobody can be trusted

I think the value of crypto is that trust is not required to participate in the system and transact. You don't need to be second guessing every single person to benefit from this. It doesn't hurt to have a system that minimizes the consequences when trust is abused. It is a bit like the adage of wanting privacy even if you have nothing to hide. I might not want someone to have the option of stealing my money in a transaction, even if I don't think that they actually will.

Re:The Great Crypto Grift May Be Unwinding on Thursday May 19, 2022 @12:33AM (#31430800)
That's the difference between an investment and money. I've never said that bitcoin is an investment, but it is a form of money.
Re:The Great Crypto Grift May Be Unwinding on Thursday May 19, 2022 @12:30AM (#31430786)
It is not misinterpretation, and the precision matters. For example, discourse on abortion that is favorable to abortion rights would not talk about the opposition "regulating" abortion, but only in terms of banning it. With crypto, it is clearly not politically favorable to have a complete ban, so to get an effective ban under the guise of regulation is basically hoping for authority to act in bad faith.
Re:The Great Crypto Grift May Be Unwinding on Thursday May 19, 2022 @12:13AM (#31430680)
> Neither. Guns are a tool usable by a variety of actors for a variety of purposes.

Agree. Now replace guns with crypto and this is basically my position. There is obviously nuance for this kind of classification for any technology.

Re:The Great Crypto Grift May Be Unwinding on Thursday May 19, 2022 @12:12AM (#31430667)
> A good investment does need intrinsic value, which BTC does not have.

Agree, USD is also not a good investment but it is still widespread to have some USD.

> It's also not a feasible payment system.

Disagree, it is used (not widely) but without issue for payments all the time. It isn't a feasible payment system for every single transaction, but that is a ridiculous goal. There is no payment system that is feasible for every payment.

> The fact that cryptos are only referenced in USD terms proves that the only real use people have for them is a vehicle of speculation

No, it just proves that they haven't succeeded in taking over the incumbent fiat currencies. Stocks are also most commonly referenced in USD prices, and they are not merely vehicles of speculation.

Re:The Great Crypto Grift May Be Unwinding on Thursday May 19, 2022 @12:06AM (#31430614)
Normally if the policy outcome you wish for is for X to be non-existent, then it would be more precise and explicit to say "we should ban X". The word regulate implies to some degree that we want X to exist, just in a way that is more constrained for better outcomes. Think about the mechanical meaning of the word regulate. To try to ban something under the guise of regulation makes it seem like you are wishing for a bad-faith effort to use regulation to make something fail rather than function.
Re:The Great Crypto Grift May Be Unwinding on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @11:58PM (#31430552)
This is not naivety, it is just stating what the ideal is.
Re:The Great Crypto Grift May Be Unwinding on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @11:57PM (#31430544)
If you believe those things, you should be asking for crypto to be outlawed, not disingenuously regulated for the underhanded purpos of outlawing it.
Re:The Great Crypto Grift May Be Unwinding on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @11:56PM (#31430537)
I think it would be more standard to replace "regulate" with "outlaw" as well, does that make sense?
Re:The Great Crypto Grift May Be Unwinding on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @11:51PM (#31430498)
The answer to this question does not demonstrate that USD has any intrinsic value, it merely demonstrates that USD is the most valuable and well circulated of the currencies. These currencies still have zero intrinsic value.
Re:The Great Crypto Grift May Be Unwinding on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @11:43PM (#31430445)
It seems rash to wish for regulation to be weaponized to the effect of banning something, rather the actual meaning of regulation to define and enforce orderly, fair, predictable functioning of something.
Re:The Great Crypto Grift May Be Unwinding on Wednesday May 18, 2022 @11:38PM (#31430411)
> Governments will likely fight this tooth and nail however, because crypto is currently an anti-government technology.

Democratic governments represent the will of the people, and I don't think a technology can be pro-government or anti-government, it ultimately depends on what the people what. I think you are correct though for autocratic governments. Would you for example say that guns are clearly anti-government or pro-government?

Accepting some form of unbacked currency does not give the currency intrinsic value and therefore make it backed. El Salvador made bitcoin legal tender, which means that USD or Bitcoin could be used to pay property taxes there, that doesn't mean that suddenly Bitcoin is backed by El Salvador property.
Re:The problem with Bitcoin miners on Sunday May 15, 2022 @10:43PM (#31393251)
Yeah, that kind of contract is not really good. There are much better arrangements out there that leverage the fact that bitcoin mining is an interruptible load.
Re:The problem with Bitcoin miners on Sunday May 15, 2022 @07:11PM (#31392081)
> if the value dropped really hard all of a sudden, for example, it might suddenly be more viable to attack the network

In practice, users of bitcoin would simply wait a longer time for more block confirmations, namely if you estimated the cost of a double spend attack was $X you would just wait for block confirmations with a total of more than $X of fees + block rewards such that the transaction you are confirming is deep enough in the blockchain to not be economical to include in the double spend attack. Note that the slowness of difficulty adjustments is also a defense here against the further problem of $X decreasing very quickly such that a transaction you had already confirmed becomes viable to attack. Because difficulty changes only every 2016 blocks, if all mining stopped and $X theoretically became 0, in practice you won't get to the next difficulty as no new blocks would be found, so $X in practice wouldn't move.

Re:The problem with Bitcoin miners on Sunday May 15, 2022 @06:46PM (#31391910)
> Um, no. That presumes there is somewhere cheaper to move, for one.

If you assume this isn't the case, then the original comment I was responding to would imply that bitcoin mining is raising the price of energy for the entire world. At 0.5% of global energy consumption, this seems pretty unrealistic. The overhead of moving is obviously not zero, but my point is mostly that bitcoin miners will in general tend to flow to where there is cheaper and less demand for electricity. This in general should cause less tension between where energy is needed. More modern regulated bitcoin miners will generally only exist where there are periods of excess power, eg from wind or solar. They will often sell to the grid operator the ability to interrupt their power when electricity becomes scarce. I completely agree that miners shouldn't be sucking up subsidized hydro power, but also that hydro power shouldn't be subsidized in the first place.

Re:The problem with Bitcoin miners on Sunday May 15, 2022 @06:38PM (#31391841)
Are you sure that energy is a fungible good? Energy is neither free to transport, nor is demand for energy insensitive to location. If energy were fungible, you wouldn't see energy pricing that varies by an order of magnitude or more. Something like oil on the other hand is quite fungible, but kwh of electricity is not. Note that fungibility depends on the user: Bitcoin miners are fungible consumers, a house in Hudson Valley is not.

> Won't the amount of mining grow until all the electricity cheaper than that is being wasted calculating hashes?

No, there is an upper bound (negating transaction fees, which are negligable) in that the cost of the energy used will never be larger than the block reward times the bitcoin price. There are estimates that this actually isn't a large enough market for the situations where bitcoin mining is actually a very beneficial consumer in terms of environmental concerns-- e.g to consume all of the methane flare gas (that would otherwise be burned off).

Re:The problem with Bitcoin miners on Sunday May 15, 2022 @06:29PM (#31391781)
Sure, but there are areas where it is not economical to actually make use of that power. For example, you could place a bitcoin mining solar powered installation in the middle of a desert where there would be no need for desalinized water and where there is no rail or road access needed for something like aluminum smelting. I think the evidence of bitcoin mining being powered by methane flare gas is irrefutable evidence of that: The methane flare gas just been being burned off for decades, it wasn't until bitcoin mining that there was a marketable use for this energy.
Re:The problem with Bitcoin miners on Sunday May 15, 2022 @06:01PM (#31391588)
The inflation due to bitcoin mining is already smaller than other systems that are widely considered stable. Note that I don't think bitcoin will actually be stable, but I think inflationary pressures are almost insignificant as a factor that would drive it to collapsing.

For bitcoin, 90% of all bitcoin has already been mined. So the remaining dilution for all time is in total just about 11%, and the current annual rate is 1.8% inflation. Compare this to gold, which has 2% inflation and no max supply. There are also technological innovations that could inflate gold much faster, e.g. asteroid mining. Compared to USD as measured by CPI is 8%, and the Fed's own target for CPI inflation is 2% annually, so this is much higher than bitcoin and also unbounded total dilution.

Re:The problem with Bitcoin miners on Sunday May 15, 2022 @05:45PM (#31391454)
> That's intellectually dishonest because Bitcoin is simply chasing cheap power and hydro power is among the cheapest. Bitcoin miners will happily use coal if it's sufficiently cheap. Also, use of certain renewables comes at the expense of other people. In the Hudson Valley, miners have raised the electricty prices for other residents in those towns.

If bitcoin miners are chasing cheap power (which I believe they are), then it shouldn't be possible for miners to increase the price of power in a fixed area, as they would immediately migrate elsewhere where power is cheaper. You can't have it both ways. Interestingly, the cheapest power is where supply completely dwarfs demand. Bitcoin miners should ultimately migrate to those areas of stranded power, and thus under optimal conditions bitcoin miners shouldn't compete with any other buyer of energy-- it would only be efficient to preform bitcoin mining for the lowest possible cost of energy where there is no other customer. It is largely looking like renewables would fit that bill, as the era of low hanging fossil fuels is long gone (aside from government subsidies).

Re:The problem with Bitcoin miners on Sunday May 15, 2022 @05:21PM (#31391267)
I think you are talking past each other. Leaving out transaction fees for a second (which are currently a very small percentage of the miner reward). The block reward is programmed to half every 4 years, taken alone this together with a fixed market cap would mean that the mining electricity spend would also half every 4 years. So the energy consumption of bitcoin will grow only so long as its market cap also doubles every 4 years. That's a tall order.

Bringing back in transaction fees-- I don't think anyone really knows what they will be, but it will be a long time until the dynamics of that are more important than the dynamics of the block reward halving and the market cap.

Re:The problem with Bitcoin miners on Sunday May 15, 2022 @05:06PM (#31391126)
> mathematically guaranteed to be a crypto dead-end

Your argument is not mathematical at all. It assumes first that bitcoin needs to appreciate 10-100 times current value. And second, that political willpower exists to then shut it down purely because of energy usage. Neither of those conditions are mathematically guaranteed, nor are they even in the realm of mathematics. I won't even address the underlying assumption that energy usage is unilaterally bad.

One possible outcome, for example, is that bitcoin just hovers around its current price for a long time. If feels like every discussion on bitcoin is made of people who either think that it must either take over the world or must go to zero.

Re:Spreading rock dust on farms as a climate solution on Sunday May 15, 2022 @12:12AM (#31385198)
Adding iron to the ocean to fertilize carbon sequester ING plankton is a interesting related approach: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_fertilization
Re:Bitcoin Is Acting Like Just Another Tech Stock on Thursday May 12, 2022 @12:50PM (#31356646)
How can you just ignore dozens of hyperinflation episodes? Clearly there are situations where supply becomes infinite.
Re:Bitcoin Is Acting Like Just Another Tech Stock on Thursday May 12, 2022 @12:21AM (#31349247)
The concrete financials are still dependent on an assumption that someone else will buy a product that the company makes. It seems inescapable that the bedrock of any definition of value is what someone else is willing to pay for something. As an example, you could assume that bitcoin should have zero value, but apply concrete financials to derive a non-zero value of a bitcoin mining company. To get the valuation of anything, you ultimately have to make an assumption about what people will value in the future.

Older »