datadata
> Advance Notice of Withdrawal: Under federal law, we must reserve the right to require you to give us at least 7 days written notice before you take money out of your 360 Savings. (This hardly ever happens but legally we have to say it!)
> The volatility of BTC/USD has only increased
Do you have a source for this? The data I have seen is that it is just slightly decreasing if anything, but there are many ways to measure volatility.
The easy way to protect against this is to not contractually promise instant redemption. I think this is what tether actually does, but I could not find a source. Regular savings account banks do typically do this, for example the bank has the right to ask for 7 days to honor a withdrawal.
If you are tether and your asserts are in bonds that mature in under N days, then you could just promise redemption within N days to eliminate bank run risk. You would still of course have counter party risk that when the bond matures it is not paid back.
Anyway, the mining/staking in crypto isn't primarily about increasing wealth, it is about defending the blockchain. In this aspect, there is a huge difference between the PoW and PoS. If someone has >50% of a PoS token, there is no way to usurp their control of the blockchain unless they willingly sell their tokens. With PoW, because the mining uses a different resource (energy), it is always possible to invest more capital to usurp the control of the blockchain by creating a larger hashrate. The ownership structure of the actual PoW token doesn't really matter, because outside capital can be introduced into the system.
I think the value of crypto is that trust is not required to participate in the system and transact. You don't need to be second guessing every single person to benefit from this. It doesn't hurt to have a system that minimizes the consequences when trust is abused. It is a bit like the adage of wanting privacy even if you have nothing to hide. I might not want someone to have the option of stealing my money in a transaction, even if I don't think that they actually will.
Agree. Now replace guns with crypto and this is basically my position. There is obviously nuance for this kind of classification for any technology.
Agree, USD is also not a good investment but it is still widespread to have some USD.
> It's also not a feasible payment system.
Disagree, it is used (not widely) but without issue for payments all the time. It isn't a feasible payment system for every single transaction, but that is a ridiculous goal. There is no payment system that is feasible for every payment.
> The fact that cryptos are only referenced in USD terms proves that the only real use people have for them is a vehicle of speculation
No, it just proves that they haven't succeeded in taking over the incumbent fiat currencies. Stocks are also most commonly referenced in USD prices, and they are not merely vehicles of speculation.
Democratic governments represent the will of the people, and I don't think a technology can be pro-government or anti-government, it ultimately depends on what the people what. I think you are correct though for autocratic governments. Would you for example say that guns are clearly anti-government or pro-government?
In practice, users of bitcoin would simply wait a longer time for more block confirmations, namely if you estimated the cost of a double spend attack was $X you would just wait for block confirmations with a total of more than $X of fees + block rewards such that the transaction you are confirming is deep enough in the blockchain to not be economical to include in the double spend attack. Note that the slowness of difficulty adjustments is also a defense here against the further problem of $X decreasing very quickly such that a transaction you had already confirmed becomes viable to attack. Because difficulty changes only every 2016 blocks, if all mining stopped and $X theoretically became 0, in practice you won't get to the next difficulty as no new blocks would be found, so $X in practice wouldn't move.
If you assume this isn't the case, then the original comment I was responding to would imply that bitcoin mining is raising the price of energy for the entire world. At 0.5% of global energy consumption, this seems pretty unrealistic. The overhead of moving is obviously not zero, but my point is mostly that bitcoin miners will in general tend to flow to where there is cheaper and less demand for electricity. This in general should cause less tension between where energy is needed. More modern regulated bitcoin miners will generally only exist where there are periods of excess power, eg from wind or solar. They will often sell to the grid operator the ability to interrupt their power when electricity becomes scarce. I completely agree that miners shouldn't be sucking up subsidized hydro power, but also that hydro power shouldn't be subsidized in the first place.
> Won't the amount of mining grow until all the electricity cheaper than that is being wasted calculating hashes?
No, there is an upper bound (negating transaction fees, which are negligable) in that the cost of the energy used will never be larger than the block reward times the bitcoin price. There are estimates that this actually isn't a large enough market for the situations where bitcoin mining is actually a very beneficial consumer in terms of environmental concerns-- e.g to consume all of the methane flare gas (that would otherwise be burned off).
For bitcoin, 90% of all bitcoin has already been mined. So the remaining dilution for all time is in total just about 11%, and the current annual rate is 1.8% inflation. Compare this to gold, which has 2% inflation and no max supply. There are also technological innovations that could inflate gold much faster, e.g. asteroid mining. Compared to USD as measured by CPI is 8%, and the Fed's own target for CPI inflation is 2% annually, so this is much higher than bitcoin and also unbounded total dilution.
If bitcoin miners are chasing cheap power (which I believe they are), then it shouldn't be possible for miners to increase the price of power in a fixed area, as they would immediately migrate elsewhere where power is cheaper. You can't have it both ways. Interestingly, the cheapest power is where supply completely dwarfs demand. Bitcoin miners should ultimately migrate to those areas of stranded power, and thus under optimal conditions bitcoin miners shouldn't compete with any other buyer of energy-- it would only be efficient to preform bitcoin mining for the lowest possible cost of energy where there is no other customer. It is largely looking like renewables would fit that bill, as the era of low hanging fossil fuels is long gone (aside from government subsidies).
Bringing back in transaction fees-- I don't think anyone really knows what they will be, but it will be a long time until the dynamics of that are more important than the dynamics of the block reward halving and the market cap.
Your argument is not mathematical at all. It assumes first that bitcoin needs to appreciate 10-100 times current value. And second, that political willpower exists to then shut it down purely because of energy usage. Neither of those conditions are mathematically guaranteed, nor are they even in the realm of mathematics. I won't even address the underlying assumption that energy usage is unilaterally bad.
One possible outcome, for example, is that bitcoin just hovers around its current price for a long time. If feels like every discussion on bitcoin is made of people who either think that it must either take over the world or must go to zero.