News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

datadata

Re:Bitcoin Is Acting Like Just Another Tech Stock on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:46PM (#31349051)
The fact that there is forced demand does not matter because the supply is potentially infinite. Look towards any episode of hyperinflation to see this on full display. You need both limited supply and non-zero demand to guarantee scarcity and thus value.
Re:Bitcoin Is Acting Like Just Another Tech Stock on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:40PM (#31349022)
What is your definition of pollution which includes any heat? Is a hurricane pollution?
Re:Bitcoin Is Acting Like Just Another Tech Stock on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @11:22PM (#31348930)
Energy is most definitely not fungible. The availability of energy and demand for energy can vary by greatly location. For it to be fungible, energy would need to be free to transport, or demand for energy would need to be location insensitive.

Bitcoin actually does a lot of good things here because it is location insensitive. For stranded energy, say methane flare gas, there is not an economical way to use the energy of this gas because transport is too expensive and demand is too far away. In this way, the bitcoin mining is consuming energy that wouldn't actually otherwise be marketable. It is also greatly reducing greenhouse emissions without demand for the energy, the methane would be burned, which has much worse emissions than when consumed in a generator.

If you don't take your phone everyplace and leave it at home often, you'll probably also end up in some list of suspicion people at some point in the future. Absence of data together with an identity is also a footprint.
Re:The Case for Higher Rates on Sunday May 08, 2022 @04:21PM (#31307797)
> Fed approval rating is very high [0]

The fact that your source for this is April 2020 makes me conclude you are trolling

Re:The Case for Higher Rates on Saturday May 07, 2022 @04:15PM (#31298134)
> On the contrary, March 2020

I'm talking about credibility going forward. I said I agree with you for past events, and you again cite past events. The consequences of that intentional choice going forward are what matters.

> There is equity and also dividends, you just don't see it your portfolio because it's impossible to split the ownership of a bridge or an airport or a port.

Splitting the ownership of things like that to share in profits is literally how equity financing works. I'm not entitled to any profits that the government earns, should it ever actually have profits. Sure, I get to use the publicly owned land and airports, but to call that a dividend or equity is ridiculous. Your analogy would be like saying that since I am a google user, I therefore am a google shareholder. Similarly, a foreign citizen can also use our airports, it doesn't make them a shareholder of the nation.

> so again it's not just the Fed

You are reading past what I'm saying. I never said it was just the fed, what I meant is that the fed at that time was probably the largest market participant and the force that kept rates low, manipulating the entire market despite there being other participants. That's the point of QE-- to entice people to take debt in an environment when the free market can't provide sufficient lending. Note also as I said, many of the 60-40 portfolios are forced-- managers contractually must keep a 40% allocation of bonds.

> the average person understands it more than you realize and they see zero value in it. The two most frequent reasons for not using BTC/Chivo being price volatility and not wanting to be tracked by their government.

The article literally has a graph where 62% of the people surveyed here agree with using Chivo. Of the 38% who don't, 40% of them cite not understanding bitcoin as a reason. Volatility and trust are also reasons, but it is disingenuous to assert that the average person understands bitcoin and rejects when there is literally data contradicting this, and in fact that the majority of people don't even object to Chivo/BTC at all here. https://www.howtogeek.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/Agree-w...

I find it amusing to expect a resolution here in less than a year for something that has never been attempted before. This is a country where 70% of people had never used a bank account before. If as a counterfactual at this point it was a raging success in terms of replacing USD, critical articles would probably cast things as a mania/bubble poised to fall apart, or cast the adoption as being coerced.

Re:The Case for Higher Rates on Saturday May 07, 2022 @01:44PM (#31296775)
I generally agree with you in that historically treasuries and USD have been the lowest risk asset and thus the place to go in a panic. But markets are forward looking and people will always try to predict what will perform better, rather than just rely on past data. The current conditions in terms of the gap between inflation rate and interest rates, and in terms of total debt to GDP ratio have never been seen before. Bond and Treasury holders have never lost this much of their principal before.

I don't see a path for the dollar to regain the credibility that it had before. It might take a long time to transition because much of the market is forced buyers (either the fed itself, or funds that are mandated to hold a percentage of bonds, for example) but the trajectory is clear. As monetary inflation looks more and more unavoidable, fiat as a safe asset will look less enticing. Instead, assets like commodities, real estate, gold, or even bitcoin will look more desirable. Everyone now knows that in the next crisis, the fed will go hard into money printing and monetary inflation will follow. The market will front run that by buying the assets and driving up the price ahead of inflation, which takes a while to slosh around the entire economy.

> you as an American are a shareholder of the Federal Govt. and as a shareholder you also benefit

I'm not sure how I'm a "shareholder". I'm a citizen yes, but there is no equity. There is however an incredible amount of debt relative to GDP (about 130%). If we were a public company, the equity would be worthless and we would be insolvent, as such a high amount of debt relative to a slowly growing revenue (GDP) is impossible to overcome. But as a fiat based country, we can avoid bankruptcy with money printing and monetary inflation.

> Powell said that inflation wasn't transitory but people decided to lend to those solid entities

It isn't PEOPLE who are doing the lending, for the most part these days. The Fed itself was buying $120 billion a month on the open market of treasuries and mortgage bonds plus 4 trillion or so to kick things off. This action is to create new credit and liquidity for the people. The general trend is the the percentage of debt held by the central bank goes higher as the currency gets weaker and debt becomes more of a problem. In the past, when rates were more attractive and debt was lower, then yes, people made up a larger portion of government debt holders.

Re:The Case for Higher Rates on Friday May 06, 2022 @08:42PM (#31291129)
> The Fed mandate says "stable prices AND maximum employment". It says nothing about setting the fed fund rate in a way that enables investors to earn money from lending to an entity which has a zero default risk.

I was not saying that the Fed mandate says that the fed must do this. I was challenging YOU who said that investors should consider treasuries capital preserving and default risk free. Neither is true-- inflation rate is meant to characterize the buying power of dollars. Whenever inflation rate exceeds the overnight interest rate, then the purchasing power of anyone holding cash or short term treasuries is by definition losing principal in a guaranteed way. Defaulting on a pure fiat system is also basically pointless, dollar denominated debts can always be met with money printing, so inflation is really the only way a default happens. And we did actually default in 1971 when Nixon ended convertibility of dollar to gold.

> When investors are very scared it happens that they get very defensive and pay the Fed govt. for the privilege of parking their money in US Treasuries.

I think you have something inverted here in your understanding (unless you are talking about negative interest rates?). You pay to borrow, you get to collect interest if you park capital. If you want to park money in US treasuries, that's a long treasury position and the government is paying you for the privilege of being able to use your dollars for a while. How it would work is you start with your asset (say a stock) sell that for dollars, then sell the dollars for a treasury, which pays a coupon upon maturation (gives you back more dollars than it started). So investors with a parked cash position are not paying the government, the government is paying them. When there is a panic, I agree the demand for treasuries goes up, and that is why you see the long term rates go down-- as demand for treasuries goes up, they start to be auctioned at a lower premium. The only people paying the government interest on the treasuries are those who are borrowing money, for example banks.

Re:The Case for Higher Rates on Friday May 06, 2022 @06:14PM (#31290116)
It seems like we have high employment but unemployment rate is being ravaged by Goodhart's Law after being such an important needle for politicians and the Fed itself. It doesn't seem like many of the employment options are good, but in order to keep unemployment down we have coerced our institutions to create low quality high quantity jobs.
Re:The Case for Higher Rates on Friday May 06, 2022 @06:10PM (#31290082)
Your principal is safe only if you demarcate principal in dollars. This is only a reasonable way to measure principal when inflation is negligible. With inflation widely exceeding interest rates, it is unreasonable to consider the only risk of US debt to be default and you have to consider the inflation loss.

Another angle is that all of the military defense backing the USD is coming from dilution of the USD (monetary inflation), or at least that is true as long as we continue to run a deficit.

You do not need to understand the entire operating system to benefit from open source. Open source can enable an end user to fix or at least report a narrow issue.
Re:The rise and fall of crypto culture on Monday April 18, 2022 @11:51AM (#31072364)
Can you provide an example of a centralized authority providing a service with these features that is widely adopted? Because there are blockchains that provide these features currently, and central authority finance has had a lot more time to figure things out.
Framing this as emergent rather than strategic makes a lot of sense.
Are these frictions good for either businesses or consumers? What is wrong with the desire that a good consumer protection protection be rolled out nationally rather that state by state?
Do you think that the growing size and complexity of software might be part of the strategy of those profiting from the suppression of free software, rather than a necessity for increased software quality?
The fact that you only get this if you are a resident of a single state is part of my point. The law is good, but having each state exert its own rules is a lot of regulatory friction.
I think ignoring it is more likely. Imagine instead every jurisdiction enacting similar unique laws. You'd have ~25 things to comply with.
Pennsylvania is less than 4% of the US population. That's a really small piece and it wouldn't be sustainable if every jurisdiction that small enacted different rules
The effect of this bill is probably that it will either never be enforced or companies will terminate business in Pennsylvania, at least until more jurisdictions adopt compatible rules. At best companies would only offer these rights for Pennsylvania residents. Local legislation seems incompatible with the economies of scale of internet commerce. I wish that rather than creating laws like this that only govern a tiny percentage of people, local jurisdictions would enter a pact to do so in unison before making an actual law. In the mean time, global companies are getting more brazen about ignoring compliance when there are literally hundreds of authorities they must in theory obey.
Fair to say bitcoin fixes this particular large and important class of currency failure, by taking away the power to print it to death?
Re:The Colorado Safety Stop is the law of the land on Friday April 15, 2022 @12:35PM (#31042247)
In west coast cities, stop signs seem to serve the purpose of letting pedestrians exert their legal right of way where it would otherwise be taken by cars. Without stop signs, cars are not really likely to stop and pedestrians will wait until the road is simply clear rather than playing a one sided mortal game of chicken. The result is that cars can pretend that the pedestrian doesn't actually want to cross. With a stop sign, pedestrians can reason that a car has to stop for the stop sign, and so they will also be able to walk.

That said I think stop signs is a terrible solution to this issue.

Re:Ask HN: Why do negative crypto articles dominate on HN? on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @11:10PM (#31023044)
I'm not sure this explains it. Look at the comments on any mainstream media article about crypto. The polarization is still there, and the more negative the article more attention there is.
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @10:58PM (#31022979)
Thank you for pointing this out, I had no idea!
2) Seems like a waste of bandwidth, did you consider the use case that turning off the video stream might be done to try to reduce bandwidth usage either due to cost of bandwidth or bandwidth being limited enough to break other simultaneous needs? And since 3) while creepy, is at least done on the client so does not seem to require the stream to always be sent to the other clients.
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @12:51PM (#31017006)
I think if the investment story of companies was better, maybe there would be less demand for crypto in the first place? Another big appeal is that in crypto the rules (governing the crypto itself) are not changeable by humans. This eliminates a large category of manipulation by insiders (while opening the door to other problems).
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @11:44AM (#31016069)
Could you share a citation for your claim of "laughably tiny adoption"? What data are you looking at to reach this perspective?
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @11:12AM (#31015631)
I think trading on the basis of private information at the expense of other shareholders without the same information is the problem. I'm less concerned about the specifics of filing requirements, and more concerned about information asymmetry regardless of auditing/reporting obligations. I'm not sure I know enough to recommend a specific policy here, my original comment was just what I believe to be some of the flaws that 'crypto fans' see in traditional systems.
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @11:04AM (#31015524)
I agree that markets are not natural and don't happen magically without human oversight and rules. But generally we want those systems to increase participation in the market. The criteria of net worth as a obstacle to market participation seems pretty indefensible here. It is hard for someone to commit to changing their net worth in the same way that a company can decide to become public, or that a wealthy person can sign a contract saying they are aware of investment risk. I would support some rule like "you must have either this net worth or prove that you are knowledgeable about investment in some way". The criteria has to be something that people are able to overcome.
Re:Insider Trading at Coinbase on Wednesday April 13, 2022 @10:52AM (#31015368)
I believe that every financial transaction has the potential to be adversarial, there are many ways outside of investing that the poor are disproportionately exploited (lotteries, debt interest). I think the libertarian perspective is that we shouldn't have protections that prevent people from making personal choices that result in harm to themselves, but only from harming others. I think that transparency for the companies seeking investment, or education of the investors themselves are better ways to restrict investment. Net worth/Income is not a fair criteria.

Older »