datadata
datadata on Hacker News
You are basically saying that accredited investor rules are not successful in excluding people from making certain types of more desirable investments, because there are other barriers that are in place anyway. I think this is true, but beside the point. If you want to have an even playing field for investing, every barrier is an obstacle.
Accredited investor rules was an example of not having a even playing field. The market is not open to everyone which contributes to unfair outcomes. I'd welcome reforms to transparency as well there, as lack of transparency also contributes to unfair outcomes (the company can exploit investors).
> they can replace it with a system that they personally have an equity stake in.
Isn't this a fact about capitalism and not at all specific to the financial sector?
I think crypto fans want transparency and an equal playing field, and are more afraid of things like regulatory corruption and markets that are not open to them. It is not clear that "regulated finance" prevents comically unfair outcomes either. You still have insider trading that is legally protected, discriminatory rules like accredited investor qualifications, and abuse of the legal system by the rich to avoid regulations with loopholes or lobbying.
That's why I said "can". Obviously there is a lot of diversity of forests in the world. Cutting down half of them to make room for human stuff might have reduced the average amount of carbon stuck in wood on average?
> Crypto is "cult by design" in much the way all greater-fool scams are. Namely, since coins are incredibly deflationary
I think you have it backwards. Bitcoin is not deflationary by design, but rather it becomes deflationary when demand increases. This is a property of any scarce asset where there are constraints on supply. Conversely, as demand decreases it becomes quite violently inflationary!
For assets that are not scarce, such as fiat currency, deflation is avoided by creating more units as demand grows. There is also an allocation fairness problem in this case, at it is just as bad if adoption is growing as fast as it is for bitcoin. Who has the right to produce new supply, and how do you stop them from becoming incredibly rich when you give them this privilege? Ironically, those sorts of systems also tend to result in feudal like structures as well.
What I don't understand is most people think bitcoin must either go to zero or take over the entire world. It is entirely possible that some subset of people decide to adopt bitcoin, other people decide they want nothing to do with it, and that its value stays relatively steady once everyone has decided. This would still offer great utility as a protection against inflation of fiat (the expectation is not necessarily huge returns), in the same way that other scarce collectables are used. Most people don't view other markets with such extreme views.
With an inflationary fiat currency, people are always going to try to invent things like bitcoin to be able to do something with their money other than watch it dissolve from inflation or be forced to consume.
I don't think that means that bitcoin is going to be successful, but fiat currency is either going to become less important or more coercive as people become aware of what inflation does and try to escape it.
I appreciate the nuance-- I completely agree that there are tradeoffs and that no money technology is perfect in all regards. I don't think it is fair to call complete resistance against counterfeiting a small win though, it eliminates an entire category of crime. You can't only consider the total size of the problem counterfeiting currently causes (which is small), but also the expenditure and surveillance that is needed to achieve that outcome.
The US also can't completely prevent people from creating counterfeit cash, see
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superdollar. The transparency of bitcoin is a win here, as everyone can verify that this kind of fraud is not occurring at the base layer.
For someone in a another country, the current 8%+ inflation of US Dollar is far from negligible, especially when the dilution drivers such as stimulus packages are mostly only to the benefit of US Citizens. Physical bearer assets like cash or gold seem to be far worse than any digital solution in that they can be seized with physical force and are not possible to conceal. Bitcoin's advantage is further that it is digital and permissionless. So just like the US Government can't prevent drug cartels from using cash, it or any other government can't prevent anyone from using bitcoin.
I'm not sure how "non-cryprocurrency" applies to lightning in anyway. Lightning channels are denominated only in bitcoin. There is no non-cryptocurrency aspect of it. Lightning has many properties that a debit card does not. For example not having to trust a bank to grant you an account, and supporting peer to peer transactions without intermediaries. Debit card transactions are limited from below by fees, fees on lightning are fractions of a penny, thus allowing micropayments that are not feasible with a debit card.
Citations seem to indicate this is actually enough! This surprised me also:
https://www.fs.usda.gov/ccrc/topics/global-carbon. Indicates 400GT are in from forests, vs 800GT in the atmosphere. Some various sources seem to indicate that around 50% of forests have been destroyed by humans already (by area, not necessarily by carbon?). So if we could instantly recover all forests, and nothing else changed, that alone would reduce the atmosphere CO2 to preindustrial levels (it has almost doubled). I think the misleading part about "millions of years worth of trees" is that a very small percentage of tree biomass probably becomes useful fossil fuel, and the majority is recycled many times.
I feel this will happen at the end of the adoption curve, should we reach it. Media will begin to shame legacy drivers and accidents will become newsworthy curiosities. Sort of like the last known cases of a pathogen that becomes eradicated.
One thing I'm curious about to see quantified (I'm sure this has been done, but don't know where to look): If you burn a gallon of gas, it immediately releases some quantity of heat into the environment, this becomes heat pollution regardless of how the energy is used. The CO2 then joins the atmosphere and contributes some marginal change in the balance of energy of the atmosphere by inhibiting radiation of energy into space, this can be expressed as an amount of power (greenhouse effect power). There is some amount of time (greenhouse breakeven time) where these effect balance each other out, and the amount of greenhouse effect power * time is equal to the initial energy released. After that point, the greenhouse impact becomes larger than the impact of initial energy released and the greenhouse term matters. I did some really rough calculation of this time period and got ~ 1 year.
If total CO2 in the atmosphere were at equilibrium (it is not currently), there would also be a mean amount of time for CO2 to be sequestered. The ratio of (mean CO2 time / greenhouse breakeven time) would exactly characterize how much worse for the climate energy sources with carbon emissions are relative to zero carbon sources in terms of the total contribution of heat into the environment. With CO2 not at equilibrium, there is probably some fancier model to get a similar characterization.
Finally, it would be interesting to see quantification of different sources of renewable power in terms of thermodynamic impacts. For example, I would expect that solar would lead to energy that would otherwise likely be reflected back to space instead be dissipated into heat. It would probably for example be worse to have a planet that is entirely covered with black solar panels from a radiation perspective. On the other hand, for something like hydroelectric or geothermal, it would seem like we are simply channeling a energy source that is already just about to be dissipated into heat on its own.
A single tree is likely to release its carbon at the end of its life. A forest however can permanently endure and keep retain carbon in aggregate, at least compared to the alternative barren ground. To your point though, I would be surprised if this effect is big enough relative to removing fossil fuels from the energy mix.
> I’d also paid $40 in Bitcoin fees, such as levies for transferring the currency between Coinbase and my digital wallet. My Visa, by contrast, is paying me—$20 in cash-back rewards.
This doesn't mention that Visa rewards are subsidized by a ~1-3% fee that is payed by the vendor, and paints the picture that somehow Visa is away something for nothing. [1]
[1] https://www.vox.com/the-goods/22454885/who-pays-for-credit-c...
There are stocks which are fraudulent, e.g Theranos, Enron, or ZZZZ Best. The fact that a company might have expected cash flows does not make them impervious to defrauding investors. Similarly, something issued without any claims of future cash flows does not imply that it must be a fraud.
To offer rewards you would need users and a vibrant market, otherwise the price would collapse and mining would not be profitable, or you are going to have to personally subsidize the rewards yourself, which would not qualify as cloning bitcoing for free. Bitcoin has these things which is why bitcoin mining is profitable, and why the majority of PoW mining is for bitcoin.
That would be true if you could time travel to 2008. In 2022 you have to compete with what already exists, not with how what already exists was created. There are no other options for cloning a PoW blockchain. You would not easily get "others to do this for you" to the same degree that bitcoin already has.
I generally agree with you though that cloning a PoS blockchain is easy in this regard, those ones also are protected by network effects.
You'd have to exert the same amount of energy to clone Bitcoin as is being used in it's mining. Because the input energy is scarce, it is not trivial to clone as you are saying.
You are also ignoring network effects entirely. Number of users of Bitcoin have increased year after year.
Agree with this all, but I don't think the simple answer is sufficient. Cash as an option must be preserved, but the abuse of this power over cashless transactions will still happen. Cash itself will become even more of a probable cause and associated with crime if the abuse is allowed to preside only over the cashless transactions.
I think it is not very important whether blockchain is actually the savior or not. Rather, it presents an alternative option that changes the landscape of the debate.
In terms of the Overton window (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window), it moves the idea of decentralized, censure resistant money from "unthinkable" to merely being "radical", or even "sensible". This should cause a similar shift on the other side of the window-- rather than having fully censurable state controlled money as being obvious future policy, we are having a debate about the explicit tradeoffs of that choice. The system we get will probably be somewhere in the middle of this, so the shifting of the window matters a lot.
So the existence of a technology can change the outcome merely by its existence, not by it's explicit adoption.
My point is that the number of cryptos/websites/stocks doesn't matter at all. A saturated market does not lead to a failed market, a saturated market just means there is demand for something. Sure, most cryptos are probably going to become worthless, but all it takes is one to work, and one that isn't easy to copy. In the stock example, maybe 9999 companies go bankrupt, but there is still a market, and whoever survives is going to make money.
You are basically saying that there can't ever be consensus because there isn't yet a consensus. That's a possible and maybe even likely outcome, but it doesn't obviously follow.
I'm making analogies so that you have to substantiate your argument. It isn't clear that just because there is a large number of something, the entire ecosystem must be worthless, which is what you originally said.
You can't clone bitcoin at no cost. To clone bitcoin you would have to invest the same amount of energy that has been expended thus far to proof of work.
Scarcity by itself is not sufficient to make something have value, completely agree. But scarcity is necessary for value, so it is still important!
There are two notions of scarcity: Scarcity of bitcoin themselves (21 million), and scarcity around being able to create different cryptocurrency. Clearly the only weakness is in the later. Two points on this: Bitcoin commands a majority of proof of work energy. This does tie the digital scarcity of bitcoin to something in the physical world. You can't create another bitcoin without spending a similar amount on PoW. It's not that the scarcity of energy consumed translates to value in bitcoin directly, but rather it gives a high cost for creating an alternative to bitcoin. This is not unlike state issue fiats-- the Yen has value because Japan is a large state. I wouldn't trust a fiat from a state that was just created and had no citizens. So the scarcity of powerful states translates into a scarcity of fiat. Second, Bitcoin was the original invention of true digital scarcity. This makes it a natural place for a focal point. This by itself does not mean bitcoin has value, but it should be better at becoming valuable than other cryptocurrencies.
But bitcoin is also used for transactions and payments. It has growing links to the real economy just like other fiat currencies. The trend here is growing. If the trend continues-- meaning more and more businesses and workers take bitcoin as payment, surely you must conclude at some point bitcoin would then have real value, just like the Yen example?
> Bitcoin is not a real currency, is just a very complicated bank with extra steps, based on an asset whose value basically depends by the biggest Ponzi scheme ever known to man.
I think this is disingenuous-- A ponzi means that through intentional and planned deception invested funds are stolen. Sure, bitcoin is volatile and might crash again. But there is no structured fraud here, it is a free market, nothing like a Ponzi.
You still didn't define a falsifiable goal-- What would have to happen for you to consider cryptocurrencies to be successful, what is the end of the tunnel? It feels to me like you are assuming it will fail (it is a ponzi!), and then working backwards from that assumption to find how to justify it.
And stocks also? There are more than 10,000 stocks, therefore the value of stocks much also must go to zero as the market is saturated.
> If anyone can make it, the market quickly becomes saturated and the value tends toward zero and people losing interest in it.
You just restated your previous claim, you still didn't give any reason why the value must go to zero-- By the same logic, the market for websites is also saturated, therefore the value of the internet is going to zero.
Coinbase isn't just claiming to have come up with the concept, they are claiming no ad agency could have come up with the concept. I could see how this could ruffle the feathers of an ad agency.