News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

bschmidt44

Damn downvoted just for asking hahahah

Don't bother answering, there's no point in trying to have rational discourse here.

Re:Underwhelming MCP vs Hype on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:38AM (#43389670)
You're talking about using a Chat AI as an end user.

I wonder why there is a protocol at all for end users since you are using natural language as the ACTUAL protocol.

Is MCP not for developers?

I thought of it as like a GraphQL in that it takes over the network comms layer but for LLM queries instead of payloads.

Idk

Should be straightforward. I get mixed opinions on YC from both extremes.

I've heard YC's "exclusivity" used as the reason it's the best, and the reason it's the worst.

Just curious what the community thinks.

Re:Underwhelming MCP vs Hype on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:20AM (#43389511)
Does fetching data straight to LLM context cause new problems for you?

I imagine a simple Bad Request could derail the convo since it's added to the context?

Fundamental things are keeping me away

Ask HN: Why MCP instead of just HTTP?

Why create a new protocol for fetching data instead of using existing protocols like HTTP?There's far more training data already for just using fetch. I bet LLMs are better at fetch than MCP.Why not extend LLMs with basic browser technology instead?I also wonder about storing the fetches data in context (polluting it) vs elsewhere.Is there a better way?

( Read More... | 3 comments | 2 points | on HN )
Re:That Time I Recreated Photoshop in C++ on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:48AM (#43379472)
Check out https://photopea.com/

I use it daily.

bro who made it is a beast