against-patents
against-patents on Hacker News
It's a tad pessimistic, given that, say, slavery was abolished by most nations after being widespread and acceptable, in all cultures and on all continents, for thousands of years. Things end, especially if people actively try to end them.
Isn't it rather possible that the right answer for software is not like the right answer for drugs, and that it takes an expert in a particular field to propose a sensible reform (assuming one is needed in that field)?
A lot of the questions about what patents tend to do seem to have different answers in different fields: http://inventors-against-patents.org/faq.html#is_abolition_o...
Patents have a lot of "advantages" over normal publishing: investors like them, companies encourage them (as in, "if it's patented then it's a great thing for the company, if there are no patents it's not really "ours" so we're going to be more secretive about it, making it unusable in business situations where disclosure to other parties is unavoidable), you can publish something really obfuscated without really driving attention to the details or giving away much useful information, you want a larger portfolio to appear "dangerous enough" to a competitor who might otherwise want to sue you, etc. Combined with the fact that neither decision-makers nor patent examiners really understand patents, you get a lot of pressure to just go ahead and file patents and you are not unlikely to choose to do this as a part of advancing your ideas within the company.
Thanks! That really is a good idea.
As pointed out by Richard Stallman at the topmost comment about EFF's proposal to shorten the patent term for software patents to 5 years, it might actually be easier to entirely abolish software patents because of a requirement by WTO to have all patents granted for a 20-year period:
https://defendinnovation.org/proposal/shorten-patent-term#co...If you're a designated inventor of a patent or a patent application who opposes patents, you could publicly state your support for patent abolition at the Inventors Against Patents site: http://inventors-against-patents.org
If you're a designated inventor of a patent or a patent application who opposes patents, you could publicly state your support for patent abolition at the Inventors Against Patents site:
http://inventors-against-patents.org(A site operator here; the site was launched a few days ago. The idea is that anyone campaigning for a patent reform can use support by designated inventors as a presumably convincing argument in the eyes of the general public.)
Edit: As Richard Stallman points out in a comment at EFF's site, abolishing software patents can be easier than shortening the period during which a monopoly is granted to 5 years as EFF proposes; he cites a requirement by WTO that all patents are granted for a period of 20 years.
The nice thing about publicly supporting abolition is that you automatically support "less radical" proposal's like EFF's 5-year reform, and you support all of them at the same time just once and all campaigners can use your support. DRY :)
Posted by
against-patents on Friday December 14, 2012 @02:48PM
from the show-hn dept.