News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

advocateone

Re:Tell HN: Podcast Looking for Startup Guests on Friday September 18, 2020 @07:10PM (#24522744)
My guest booked today was Morgan Housel, a VC and former journalist who's frequently on CNBC. We had to reschedule b/c of a conflict -- this would have been the perfect day to get your startup on. Remember, you really have to get yourself out there in front of the public, and don't take my word for it, just ask some startup founders! We're routing for all of you!

Tell HN: Podcast Looking for Startup Guests

If you've got a cool startup, and would like to get the word out - consider guesting on my podcast. Don't be shy, it's important to get in front of users & the market!Just Google 'Cameron Tousi Podcast' and apply. Especially love Y C taught & motivated folks.

( Read More... | 1 comment | 2 points | on HN )
I know this is obvious, but it's important to look at your online agreement or terms of service for customers to see what they've agreed to.

If you're not legally culpable, I don't see the reason for the refund. The fact is most people, especially in the US, will understand that delays caused by the government's servers are not at all unusual, and they might just side with you. Perhaps you're concerned about social dislikes before you've even gotten your startup off the ground. I find communication is really the most important thing; if there are few enough customers to contact, I'd call every one of them; it may see like a waste of time, but they're really key to your business, and having the founder contact them may bring tears to their eyes.

We are dealing with human beings, and so-called disasters could be turned around to super-power you. Remember that Intel's biggest growth was when there was a rare problem with their pentium chip, and they fixed and returned every one, and made a huge marketing campaign around it; if you have already refunded, you should make sure to let everyone know about it, and reach out to customers, perhaps via email directly. Testimonials are a really big deal in the social world, and every one of them could be your biggest advocate for lots of new customers.

Regarding what you're apparently most worried about, the bigshot late stage startup, that wouldn't be a concern to me. Some bigshot, who can't afford an EIN number; rmember what YC awards on here, it's called karma, and it goes around. If they try to injure you, they may have a lot more to worry about when you tell your side of the story, especially if they are bigger.

Let me tell you a true story that happened to me just today. I had an investor on my podcast some weeks ago. This person seems really nice, and has a huge social following, so I offered something that really goes against the way we operate, to do some free legal work for this person, so they could view our work, and if they were satisfied, to establish a regular working relationship together.

A few weeks later, this person reached out to take me on my suggestion (and was actually mad that I hadn't contacted the person earlier, but apparently the email had ended up in spam) and not only did we do the work namely fixing a really bad contract bringing a ray of sunshine to it (sorry for the braggadocio), and they kept all the changes, but I did a full video of explanation for this person and their partner.

Yesterday, they reached out to me again, this time stating that we could work together but that their partner is cheap, so watch the fees, then telling me how much we could charge, and when we mentioned our customary retainer for this sort of work, refused but did mention they needed the work done right away.

My response was to say sorry, we can't do it, and send them a polite email, and fortunately as founder like you I don't have to answer for it. I'm just letting you know about own experience, acquired over decades.

This is my hugely wordy way of saying to stay away from time wasters, big-shots or otherwise, and put your time into what counts. I've seen lots of folks like this, and all they do is waste your time, because you've got finite time, and let it be spent with the good customers, who love you and want to work with you. The 'big shot's' power is mostly a perception, and most people are fair minded. Don't give into it.

My only caveat is that I don't know the exact circumstances and I'm taking your word for it.

Respectfully, I have the opposite view and left my comment at the top.
In response to your question, about exactly where to come down on billionaires, I'm not sure but there are some great points on here, and for the folks questioning why so many techies question having billionaires and lean more toward socialism, here are my views. And I’d love to hear yours, pro or against.

If you’re in the US or Europe, you live in countries that are capitalist, but that have a huge helping of socialism so that we can take care of our citizens.

At the turn of the 20th century, we had more “real” capitalism with the social safety net. The result is that J.P. Morgan literally worked his starving employees to death, which was called “morganization.” Andrew Carnegie was able to get away with having union demonstrators shot to death by the Pinkerton police, and there certainly weren’t criminal charges filed against him. Rockefeller found his oil deposits had an explosive component called gasoline, and he had no idea what to do with it; so his company’s scientists created the internal combustion engine we still drive today.

From FDR’s reforms including 'social' security to the FDIC to protect our bank deposits, we enjoy the benefits of the socialist aspect, and it is not a dirty word here.

We used to not have the socialism of free public education for our children, and the addition vastly improved society including economic mobility. Today, one doesn't have to be a land owner enjoying hand-me-down wealth to have economic opportunities. Even law had to deal with this, with the passage of negligence laws, and preventing inter-generational wealth. (See the rule against perpetutities https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/rule_against_perpetuities, the question you're always told to skip on the Bar exam.)

Unbridled capitalism without the social component is not a place most people would want to dwell in. On the other hand, the socialist component, yang to the ying of capitalism, and I am a capitalist myself, has been an enormous feature of civil society.

In short, if you like the life that you have, and you live in the democracies, you live in and enjoy socialism as much as capitalism.

As someone older than I guess the average age of most hackers, the fact that these techy folks have these views, question whether we should even have billionaires, and 'socialism' is not a dirty word for them, makes me think makes we will have a brighter future.

Re:Ask HN: Why Are Software Patents So Awful? on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @04:34PM (#24286956)
Hi Everyone - I know there's a lot of prose in the responses below, but you may discover a lot about the entire patent system (especially business method and software patents) and the issues startups have to deal with, by checking it out.

My responses are not to take sides, but so that you get the challenges in light of the patent system as it really works. Already I've gained a lot of insight from your responses.

Please keep your responses coming. I'd love to hear some anecdotal info or studies showing the problems with software patents.

Re:Ask HN: Why Are Software Patents So Awful? on Wednesday August 26, 2020 @04:29PM (#24286910)
Thanks much for your clarification.

Regarding whether there are multiple patents issued on the MRI –

(1) Assuming that the algorithmic steps work properly (i.e., without typos and the like) . . . Please see my explanation about patent claims in other discussions. The claim of a patent puts a box around the uniqueness of an invention. Ideally, it’s supposed to be as broad as possible without being so broad that it’s anticipated or rendered obvious by what is already known (prior art). The patent claim and algorithmic steps are not synonymous. It’s possible that the first step of a claim incorporates hundreds of algorithmic steps, and the second step of the same claim incorporates hundreds of other algorithmic steps. (Those steps would be described in a broad or exact fashion in the specification.)

The way the patent system works, while it’s possible that many patents try to claim the same thing (different patents by different inventors), the patent is supposed to be awarded only to the first one that was filed.

Since today patent applications are published approximately 18 months from their filing publications (and could be prior art), in the U.S. and in most other systems, the system doesn’t really work for filings within that 18-month period. That’s because for the patent application being examined, there’s an 18-month gap of filed applications that can’t be used; and there’s even an exception to this if the prior art application is filed first and later publishes (secret prior art under 35 USC 102(e)).

Technically, the examiner should have access to secret prior art (non-published applications) if they’re published under 102(e), but you can see that there’s no way for the applicant to have known that before their filing.

Plus what happens if the secret prior art that hasn’t published (and isn’t really prior art) issues as a patent after the applicant’s patent issues as a patent? Now you may have two people patenting the same invention, and they may invoke what’s called an interference proceeding before the USPTO, to see who wins.

There’s lots more. But without writing a novel and giving everyone here a headache, let me add that what is prior art is legislated (which means lobbying has a lot to do with it) and not based on logic, and that the America Invents Act (AIA) that was supposed to tame abuses and clean up the system was more of a monkey wrench thrown at the patent machine.

Because of the complexities of a legislated system, there are many instances where the problems you’ve outlined could apply. But I haven’t seen anything other than anecdotal evidence to support there’s a high rate of patents that shouldn’t have been issued. The elephant in the room however is there isn’t an easy way for an examiner to search prior art that’s doesn’t constitute patents.

(2) If Assuming that the algorithmic steps do not work properly (i.e., without typos and the like) . . . Here we have the additional issue that they written description may not support the invention and/or they may not enable the POSITA to make and use the invention. That’s under 35 USC Sec. 112 (a), which pre-AIA was 112, first paragraph.

I’m mindful of Church’s lambda calculus and Turing’s solutions and halting theorem, but it’s not really applicable generally except under Sec. 112 here, and likely not really applicable. We don’t require a complete axiomatic set or proof that every single series of algorithmic steps results in a defined solution of a computer. Applications that broad would likely invalidate the entire patent system – and I’m sure many would love that :)

Also, about the good versus bad issue for the MRI you mention, I defer you to my long response to orangecat2, specifically about novelty under Sec. 102, nonobviousness under 103 and POSITA.

Let me add that we are supposed to handle these matters objectively, and the USPTO was applying a motivation test for combining references; this is a test developed over 50 years by the Federal Circuit and applied by the USPTO, and it was injured by the Supreme Court’s KSR International case. The USPTO is still walking it back as much as they can, so as not to make the examination system so arbitrary.

If you think about it, along comes technology and the Internet age, and now we’re dealing with application of a generic computer program to things that were done manually earlier. (Business method patents are in this lot.)

Many a patent troll has used these kinds of patents against smaller businesses and startups who feel wronged. And there are many on both sides of the issue, but you already know where most technologists stand, and some of the abuses out there are simply not acceptable.

The Supreme Court’s Alice decision tried to resolve at least part of this issue by saying that if something that’s well known, and has been performed manually is now done by a generic computer (i.e., for example a pc using a Windows operating system) running a program, the simple act of using the computer does not make it patentable subject matter.

There’s a lot of truth to this simple statement; the issues is that the Sup Ct is now using subject matter eligibility (under Sec. 101) versus patentability (under Secs. 102, 103) which has lots of bad repercussions for the patent system; not to mention that there’s a lot of dicta (legal prose) that litigators can use as they deem fit, to convince a federal judge who may not have any background in tech, like our dear Sup Ct.

Re:Ask HN: Why Are Software Patents So Awful? on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @01:03AM (#24268256)
Thanks much for your insight, pedalpete. I found your comments helpful and insightful on a number of different levels.

Regarding reverse engineering, while I don’t know the particulars from the legal perspective it’s fine and done quite often. In truth, the fact that reverse engineering is completely acceptable is one of the reasons to consider patenting. You may also consider getting an FTO (freedom to operate) to provide at least a reasonable likelihood the end product won’t be infringing.

I provided some thoughts to taf2 below you may consider taking a look at as well.

Re:Ask HN: Why Are Software Patents So Awful? on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @12:53AM (#24268210)
Very well said, and insightful, truly.
Re:Ask HN: Why Are Software Patents So Awful? on Tuesday August 25, 2020 @12:52AM (#24268205)
Thanks so much for bringing this to my attention. I took a quick look at the litigation docket for this case, which was consolidated with actions against a number of other defendants too. This was in the Eastern District of Texas, considered to be plaintiff friendly, which I’m quite familiar with.

The defendants used the USPTO’s relatively new (at that time) Inter Partes Review (IPR) procedure in order to try to invalidate the claims (alleged to be infringed) before the USPTO’s Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB). When the IPR was filed, as is customary, they requested a stay (temporary stop) of the court proceedings, in order to try the IPR before the PTAB. The strategy worked, because the claims alleged to be infringed were invalidated by the USPTO’s PTAB, but 2 claims (claims 21, 22) apparently survived the IPR. After the IPR, the case was continued in Texas, again as is customary.

Unfortunately for Uniloc and fortunately for the defendants, Uniloc hadn’t alleged infringement of these claims, so it tried to do so after the IPR. The court found this was too late, and dismissed with prejudice. It does not look like Uniloc got any money from Laminar Research or a number of these other defendants. However, I agree that it was apparently a waste of time for the parties involved, and likely cost Laminar some real legal fees.

The whole thing seems irrational to me because patent troll cases like this should settle early.

I will have to provide some guidelines here for startups dealing with patent trolls. That’s if you and others on HN are okay with it, i.e., to educate versus being promotional.

Re:Ask HN: Why Are Software Patents So Awful? on Monday August 24, 2020 @02:07PM (#24263489)
Thanks much for your reply. Turing’s application of Godel merely says that there are some calculations a computer can’t do. There are still a finite number of instructions that are unique and would reasonably pass muster under our patent laws. If you’d like to further clarify, I’d love to hear it.

I laid out the issues for the patent system in my other responses, and perhaps you’re right that it’s hard to search and find a series of instructions, aka software, but you should know that software patents are examined entirely the same as other patents.

I haven’t seen an analysis that 90% or some other high percentage of software patents shouldn’t have been allowed. Remember that you can include any description in the specification and abstract, including the whole encyclopedia if you want, but that doesn’t define the invention. The invention is defined by the legal description in the claim language – it’s a boundary for what is actually new, and every single word of it must be found in a product for it to infringe.

The claim is synonymous with the invention in the case law, which is why it’s not recommended to use the word “invention” in the specification, so it’s not used to narrow the claim interpretation in the court’s Markman (claim construction) proceedings during the suit.

Believe me, if someone could do an actual assessment of allowed patents (notably the claims) and show that they never should have been issued, I’d love to see it. As an FYI, from time to time in representing defendants we’re approached by professors etc. who’d like to share prior art and be retained as experts. But aside some from studies here and there which are generally marketing hype ramping off the thought that all software patents are bad, I haven’t seen it.

Re:Ask HN: Why Are Software Patents So Awful? on Sunday August 23, 2020 @11:36PM (#24257346)
That’s kind of a sweeping generalization for the few examples here and not exactly applying the scientific method, don’t you think?

I hope you notice that I’m purposefully not using legal jargon because I genuinely want an honest communication where we understand each other. Jargon is not a sign of intelligence but rather of hiding.

And I hope we get lots more, because I’d really like to see the nature of the problem. Not to dismiss anyone here, but remember we haven’t looked at any of the patent claims and actual references, and unless I’m missing something, no one’s stated having expertise in the patent field.

When large company A licenses its 2000 patents to large company B for $470 million, and thrown in the mix are other rights, license and non-competes, that doesn’t make the news because the deal is confidential. I’ve done a lot of these, and I’m not bragging here because a lot of others on here have too, but it’s a plain fact that you wouldn’t know about these unless if you were a cxo at one of those companies or their lawyers. But you definitely would see reports about a no-name patent troll suing a startup. The bogeyman is spotted by your local tech reporter/blogger, emboldened by the fact that everyone thinks like her/him and won’t question the various biases and misinformation.

Also consider that today the distinction between hardware and software is really arbitrary. It’s more about the type of instructions being implemented. Anything implemented on software can be embedded into firmware and the like. Can you imagine how arbitrary and nonsensical would be a patent system that says you can’t protect software, but if you burn it into a chip you can protect it? That's the definition of a bad law.

But that’s different than say software for implementing a business process. In my view, and I may be wrong, that’s why you’ll see the CY folks make a distinction between patents for rockets versus for an online store.

Re:Ask HN: Why Are Software Patents So Awful? on Sunday August 23, 2020 @10:35PM (#24257109)
Sounds like you've had some bad experiences. I really appreciate your sharing this. Regarding the balloon, you'll have to check out some of my other responses about the obviousness legal standard for obtaining a patent. Unfortunately, when problem patents are allowed it makes the whole system look bad.

I rather agree with you in the sense that we've got a winner-take-all system, that has a lot of arbitrariness built into it, with huge ability by big players to game the system, where there's huge misinformation and everyone (whichever side they're on) thinks they're right and won't really listen to the other side. I can tell you that if you talk to a room full of patent lawyers, when they're being honest and not brown nosing their clients, are pro-software patents just as much as people on here will be anti. These are reasons why I'm looking to disrupt, it's like Ma Bell before everyone woke up and AT&T was broken up.

Re:Ask HN: Why Are Software Patents So Awful? on Sunday August 23, 2020 @10:17PM (#24257030)
You make a couple of great points.

Let me analogize the problem. Imagine that one day you’re reading books and working on computers and floppy disks.

So your information is limited. To be more fair, you’re searching paper copies of patents in “shoes” and using the Dialog database and now-arcane machines to actually look at images of patents (wow).

This is what I was doing in the early 90’s as a patent examiner, following working in industry as a software engineer.

Then along comes all the information in the entire world from the dawn of civilization to the present: the Internet. (Or think of it this way: Bill Cosby meets Twitter.) So now, you’ve got the USPTO, with access to all of human information.

Now, in reality, patents like most other creative work are typically incremental changes. If enough time is spent, it is possible to find reference that are very close to the “invention” being examined, especially if all information is available.

The next challenge is how close do the references have to be? When are the references close enough that when combined together, it would have been obvious to come up with your invention. Is your invention obvious, or not, over references. If it wouldn’t have been obvious to combine them, you get a patent, but not otherwise.

Well, who gets to decide this? It’s not really the patent examiner, though it really is – let me explain.

The patent examiner can’t say it would have been obvious to me, Mr. Patent Examiner, and so you don’t get a patent. That subjective nonsense.

We don’t really want this objective person to be a real person at all. Imagine if we let the president decide – this president – I can’t imagine anything worse.

If you’re familiar with contracts, we create the legal fiction of the “reasonable person” to decide how the contract should be interpreted, and the parties, judges, juries and everyone else must put themselves in the shoes of this fictitious person to decide how to interpret contract language.

In patent law, we’ve had to create the legal fiction of the “person of ordinary skill in the art (POSITA)” If you think about it, it’s logical, because the person has to be someone who works in the field of the patent subject matter, and this person’s doesn’t have a low level of knowledge or a genius level of knowledge, but instead an “ordinary” level of knowledge. And that’s when the patent application is filed, not later.

It’s the POSITA that the examiner pretends to be when issuing the patent, and whose shoes judges, juries and even Supreme Court justices must step in to make the determination.

So if you put 1000 people in a room, and gave them some good (perhaps not even great references) and asked them whether it would have been obvious to come up with an invention, how hard do you think it would be to get consensus? I think it’s a lot more likely that you couldn’t get half of them to agree one way or the other. When I did EE and math all those years ago, I remember a couple of grad students who though everything was rudimentary. I guess there's always some bonus points awarded with this kind of chest pounding.

Now, throw on top on top of that a few more facts. 1 - the examiner has perhaps a few hours or a day or two to find all of the best references, and make a rejection; 2 – the attorney responding for the applicant is limited really by the client’s dollars, so unlike a big corp a small company doesn’t have a budget to keep arguing over and over to get some decent claims allowed; 3 – the budget once we’re in licensing or litigation is much higher, so you can bet that a big company being sued will comb the earth to find the best references to invalidate the patent; 4 – that same big company has enormous marketing dollars to paint anyone who ever brings a suit as underhanded, bad, gaming the system, basically the same as the old lady who sued McDonald’s for giving her coffee that burned her; 5 – for these reasons, and that so many software engineers feel as you do, the USPTO and this particular examiner are extremely nervous to allow a software patents that’s got any teeth. Who does that hurt?

Well, I can assure you it's a much bigger problem for smaller companies and startups than for the big companies pushing out the marketing. That's one of the reasons I'm always fascinated by the vehement antipathy toward patents by startups in SiVy, in a Spock sort of way.

I think you get the scope of the problem. We have huge systemic issues that are exacerbated by big dollar interests. And it's not the best formula when everyone's completely convinced they're right about everything, if you know what I mean.

Re:Ask HN: Why Are Software Patents So Awful? on Sunday August 23, 2020 @09:29PM (#24256807)
Sorry for the long reply here, but I think a lot of people have the same thoughts, so I’ll elaborate.

It’s not in the individual instructions that there is uniqueness, but instead in the combination of them, that makes the code. By your same argument, every possible thing you could do with the English language has already been done because we’re limited by a finite number of 26 letters or a finite number of about 170,000 words, give or take, and so there’s nothing novel or unique in a new novel -- it’s already in the sandbox.

There are 2 big things going on to get you a patent. 1 – it has to be subject matter than we, as a society, by our laws, deem “patentable subject matter” and 2 – your particular thing, that you say you’ve invented, is both novel and nonobvious (the latter means it wouldn’t have been obvious to combine more than one novelty reference together to come up with your invention).

Think of 1 as the ticket getting you into the show, and 2 as your seat at the show.

The math thing you’re talking about comes from the Supreme Court. For over a hundred years, the Supreme Court has narrowed the meaning of article 1, sec. 8, clause 8 of the constitution (about patents) to exclude mathematics and algorithms as patentable subject matter (item 1), because it’s too important, not because it’s trivial (item 2). They call it “preemption,” meaning giving someone a limited monopoly say over E=MC^2 can preempt an entire field from developing.

That’s very different from it being obvious (item 2), in fact you could say it’s the opposite, which is the argument you’re making in your first paragraph.

But, it turns out that you’re in good company. This particular Supreme Court, the Roberts Court, made the same mistake, namely of mixing patentable subject matter and obviousness in it’s Alice decision, that runs contrary to it’s own case law. It's been harshly criticized in the patent field, though it's unlikely anyone outside our "sandbox" has heard it.

The Alice decision doesn’t really kill business method or software patents, as many have said, but it did weaken them. Much of this is because if you're defending an alleged infringer (and I've represented both plaintiffs and defendants), you will make much hay out of the court's language ("dicta") to win your case.

The other issue we have is with the courts. You see, for several decades, the Supreme Court has punted on patent law, and let its lower appellate court, the Federal Circuit make the calls. The Fed Cir is the appellate court with exclusive jurisdiction over patents, and it’s decisions are way more important than what the USPTO says (in fact the USPTO must follow it).

This particular Supreme Court has woken up and decided to kick the Fed Cir’s butt (reverse it’s decisions). Think of it like parents who’ve placed all of their child raising duties on the oldest sibling. Then one day, after shirking their own duties for years and when the kids are nearly grown, they beat the tar out of the oldest sibling. For years, the Supreme Court has even admitted it doesn't really understand technology or patent law.

And don’t get me wrong. I’m not advocating for software patents, but I do want (1) that our laws be logical and consistent in creation and application, and (2) preferably for a law to be passed by the people versus de facto by the Supreme Court in its application (which is really a construction).

Ask HN: Why Are Software Patents So Awful?

Ask HN: As a software developer from the stone ages who’s spent many years in the field of intellectual property (IP), I’m truly curious why Silicon Valley is so down on patents. This is especially true for software patents, and the sentiment is at least tenfold greater here than anywhere else I’ve seen. Forget for a moment which side is right or wrong.The startup community especially in...

( Read More... | 19 comments | 9 points | on HN )

A lot of you otherwise smart folks are misinformed about patents

There's a lot of misinformation on the site about patents. Folks - yes, novely is still required for patents under 35 USC Sec. 102, and nonobviousness is also required under 35 USC Sec. 103. Nonobviousness means taking multiply novely destroying references and combining them together in an obvious way. That's true for all utility patents, be they for software, hardware, life sciences, biotech etc.

( Read More... | no comments | on HN )