admstockdale
admstockdale on Hacker News
Posted by
admstockdale on Tuesday January 10, 2017 @04:08PM
from the blogs.wsj.com dept.
Can we now mock all those who prognosticated poorly in regards to Instagram's success?
I see a lot of smug in the previous thread that needs to be called out.
What do you mean by forced intersectionality and unforced intersectionality? Can you expand on this?
Some of this article is spot on.
There is a need in the internet age to educate people on how to consume information. When we had fewer news organizations, information was more controlled. It was done by professionals with years of training.
While there's a lot of benefit in providing more voices and more outlets, there's a real danger of spreading misinformation propped up by false equivalences as to what qualifies as a professional news organization. I'm not sure the answer other than education.
Posted by
admstockdale on Thursday November 03, 2016 @12:19PM
from the atlasobscura.com dept.
Keep it simple. There's no reason to overanalyze the failure. Ask someone why they're not on Google+. There response: "What's Google+?" If they know what it is: "Why would I use Google+? No one is on there. All my friends use x y or z." Google+ has a huge public perception and identity problem -- who is it for exactly? Why use it when there's other social media?
This was actually a well thought out idea. He took the time and tried to do some research and analysis. While some of his conclusions were off, this is a great way to learn and think. But publicly humiliating him (which I think is the result of the media response), we're telling kids that if you make an attempt, you're going to be ridiculed. I don't know if you've ever been in a classroom, but one of the biggest problems is that kids feel like they can't fail because they'll be labeled as an idiot. Calling the ideas of a 14 year old trying to solve a problem "shallow" is pretty sad. I understand why kids don't want to tackle topics in mathematics and computer science with attitudes like this.
I shared this with my students. We're learning about typefaces and graphic design right now. Some of these comments picking about a 6th grader are pitiful. We want to encourage these ways of thinking -- not nitpick
To all of you saying this doesn't matter and who gives a shit -- get real. There's this deep-seated elitism to programming that is really damaging to all types of backgrounds. The barrier for entry is high enough -- it's great there's a story about someone most wouldn't think of when thinking of a programmer. It benefits those interested in seeing computer science grow as a discipline to have more people in the fold.
I'm surprised by the reaction -- I thought more people would be in support of this.
Since I'm from the U.S., I'm curious what the attitude is around the world. Does the layman have a lot of resentment towards the "expert" in other countries?
The best teachers are able to adapt -- they have command in the classroom & students respect them. Each student CAN be treated differently depending on what they respond to. Some students might react best to a bit of tough-love, other will respond better to positive encouragement. The key is knowing your students well enough to know what makes them tick.
I have not consumed 10+ hours of information about the NSA revelations and I feel I have a solid understanding of the situation.
When we read something like the NSA reports, we don't just think of what we can do right now to protect ourselves, but about how we change policies for the future. We look into what we need to develop. We look at how to protect ourselves without sacrificing privacy.
News is education. If you consume news about Kim & Kanye I would agree with you and call it information pollution. Good journalism is educating us. There's plenty of good journalism out there. Whether we want to read it and support it is another thing.
No you don't need to read 10+ hours of news about the same story unless there's new information and it has an effect on you. I didn't make that point so I'm not sure what you're getting at.
There's plenty people can do: develop a means to protect ourselves from the governments spying, activism, find out who was responsible at the top and try and get them removed.
I used to work in television news. I agree with you that some of it is just entertainment. The problem is that's what people want. Not everyone. But a good portion who never speak out about the news don't mind the entertainment part.
There's also reason to educate yourself about the world and culture without having to directly apply it. But that's another philosophical argument.
I agree we need to consume better news. Instead of clicking on the link-bait headlines, take some time and read that long-form article that took months or years to research. If we tell the media that's what we want, that's what we will get. They need/want to make a profit.
Cable news is only a sliver of the news picture.
We have yet to come up with a better alternative because we consume & we want it all for free. We cry about journalism yet we don't want to fund any. When good journalism is done, no one or very few people read it.
The key to changing news will be finding a way to monetize online content. Without this, all we will get is link-baiting and stories that are sensational to get people to come to a website.
This is a rather ignorant stance to take.
I know a lot of people don't like the doom & gloom of news. But it's needed. I recently discussed with someone who doesn't consume news about the NSA revelations. They were shocked. They said "why didn't anyone tell me?"
Instead of blocking things out and being happy with our ignorance, we need to change how news is done. If you whine about something, change it. The Guardian can certainly make an attempt to change the dynamic.