SuitAndThai
Gruber says 'Yes': whoop de doo
Gruber says 'No': Well, the person at fault looks like Gruber for being prohibitive of others trying to improve his work.
If his opinion was really to be respected, Jeff should've messaged John behind closed doors to see if he could expect his support or not on this committee, like John had any real say in the matter.
I would hardly expect Jeff to keep track and know of every topic in StackOverflow, let alone one with only 11 questions. Give the man some room to err.
1. Online education is not mass produced as he claims; the costs for every video that is downloaded to watch video lecture is incredibly small. Popping up tutorials on YouTube with ads is profitable and sustainable, and that's really all you need for someone who can dedicate themselves to learning more about a topic.
2. I have no idea where he pulls his "winners win" suspicion.
> why wouldn’t every student choose a Stanford or MIT education over, say, UNM?
If we have an open model of education, people would have the freedom of spending a minimal amount of time to look through a plethora of lectures and figure out what they like the best. In the end, you'll hear the best lecturers echoed from students who watched them. I'm making many assumptions here, and I don't want you to forgive me for making them. But we can't overlook the assumptions that the author is making either, and there are a lot of them.3. Supposedly, online education kills a personal connection: an argument that has been made many times. Maybe I should point to a popular counter-example: Khan Academy. A very small group of people who manage to supplement the education of an incredible amount of people who want the extra help. They do it for free. They are happy with the results. And the people they do it for are very happy with the results. The argument he's making sounds like there's something to be yearned, but I don't buy it.
Were it not for this section and his rant on the "Funding Climate" (I really don't want to argue about politics here), I would not have thought this to be the rambling of an angry, old man. He may have some valid points, but it's hard not to see this as a giant middle finger to his previous employer as well as venting now that he's at his new job.