MrSartorial
MrSartorial on Hacker News
Posted by
MrSartorial on Wednesday February 03, 2010 @06:39PM
from the gizmodo.com dept.
I think the author makes a great point. I pursue this concept in what I call "elegant design". What this means to me is taking as much functionality as possible and putting it into a simple to understand package. There is a huge difference between "intuitive" and "Dumbed down". Want some exapmles? Think Apple products or, online, facebook. Both have a lot of features available, but you aren't overburdened by them. You take what you need and you leave the rest. On top of that, both offer an intuitive GUI that is easy to comprehend. A lot of times this comes down to interconnecting all of the aspects of your system to be accessible where your users need them to be.
I feel this is an area Microsoft has struggled with in the past and they are finally catching up with their more recent Office program. A good case study here? Compare Microsoft Outlook to Gmail. Gmail is an elegant solution, Outlook is incomprehensible to the point that there are companies whose business is making it easy to understand (ie. Xobni).
There are many other examples, but I'm interested in what everyone else thinks too...
I really think that Spotify is going to put Apple into a tough spot. iTunes is fairly useful, but there are a lot of difficulties I have with it. A trend is emerging where Apple is starting to be harped at for their closed policies by more than just hackers. This could lead to a tipping point against them if the issue builds traction. The more content they get their hands on, the more regular users are noticing that they exert a lot of control over their content. For some, this will never matter, but the number of people who it does matter to appears to be increasing.
Aside from this, Spotify appears to be on the right tech trend: cloud computing. With Google prepared to release a cloud computing operating system, getting more and more info off of our computers and into a centrally located space seems to be the way to go. Why not just run Spotify and have an app that manages and streams my music from my phone? It means I don't really need a huge hard drive anymore. It's convenient because rarely do we just listen to the same limited playlist over and over again; people tend to enjoy a lot of variety in their music.
I believe Spotify is on trend, and this will give them the advantage in the future. More and more of our life content will keep moving to the internet I think (I think this is a good thing as long as security is kept up).
I think that the hypothesis proposed in this article sounds like it's certainly a part of the effect we feel, but there is likely some support that the percentage of our live thus far that each moment adds up to plays a role in our sense of time passing as well.
Think though, to your novel experiences later in life and how time passed. I can certainly say that even though just recently I left Canada (my home country) for the first time, to go to Mexico, I can recall every second of it, and it did seem to take a long time.
So I would argue memories are encoded based on what is perceived, and I think we perceive what is most important to us at the time. This is often something we are learning; something novel. Routine is not encoded carefully because it is not important to us. We aren't learning anything new when we follow our routines. But when we experience new things, we are learning. The density of the memory at this time gives a prolonged time passage effect I imagine.
There is a similar psychological effect: Think in terms of your closest acquaintances or, better yet, a new love interest. Because you spend so much time with them, getting to know them, you encode a lot of memories that involve them, and so when you are apart for a short period of time, it seems like much longer. This is quite noticeable after a break up, when you're time with someone goes from very high to zero.
Those are some of my thoughts anyhow.
I think co-founders are most useful when you have a similar vision but bring different expertise to the issue. I agree with what you are saying though, that you should have similar values and vision, but then want to discuss the implementation from different perspectives. It's kind of like having a mini focus group or think tank. Those different understandings of the issue are important to come to the BEST implementation and to avoid groupthink.
I agree 100%, but there is precedent for lawyers to follow, so that is considered when pursuing each new case. Much like "I didn't mean to" is not an excuse, it is stated in law that ignorance of the law is not an excuse either.
It's the same that no one will prosecute a minor for sexting another minor even though it may be considered "child pornography", or at least they shouldn't.
What is needed is clear and concise law that does not bog down the process and micromanage what should be left open for interpretation. I stand by the fact that the aspects of law mentioned in the article are simply very poor jurisprudence.
I think this is a challenge that a lot of startups encounter. I've certainly encountered it so far. I think the breakthrough for me was when my dad (good 'ol parents) asked me to describe what I wanted to do in one sentence. Once I did, it became clear how to best focus on what I was trying to accomplish, who I wanted to reach, and how I wanted them to benefit. Sometimes giving yourself some solid guidelines will free you more than anything else. Above all I find that you have to maintain focus. As an entrepreneur I find that you will pick up on many problems that can be solved, and many ways to do so. You have to pick the most important problem to solve, and the way that will solve it the greatest amount is the first one to pursue. My thoughts, from someone that is still learning a lot...
This is just bad jurisprudence. It's the reason why legal language is supposed to be intentionally vague; so that there aren't potential legal issues with doing something that a completely rational person might do. Obviously there is no intention for the law to be interfering with any super bowl parties you might want to have at home and no prosecutor would relish pursuing someone who did. This whole thing is pretty much a moot point unless you own a sports bar. That's what happens when lobbyists get to the lawmakers though...
I don't disagree. As we've discussed in previous threads on the iPad, many are opposed to it's closed-system. Everyone is touting open-system as the better approach, and I definitely support that as the way to go, but few are discussing the best way to meld an open-system with turn-key simplicity. Microsoft products lack the industrial design that Apple is famous for as well. So I agree with you when you say that a well-designed, open-system product with turn-key activation and networking with other devices will certainly subvert Apple's domination of this market.
Some excellent points. I must admit I hadn't thought of abandoned cart reporting; that's an excellent suggestion. I think that so many sites are lagging in their ability to categorize products and then to suggestive sell at the checkout. These are related concepts and both are not very effective. Development is needed in identifying customer habits to increase up-selling and cross-selling on many sites. I believe that a new method of grouping items for quick access is needed as well. With the amount of product that is available on the internet, even looking for the simplest of things can be an overly arduous task. By carefully grouping products to appeal to each unique customer as fast as possible, sales would increase and so would site loyalty.
I think that the author is completely right about the iPad (the names still makes me grimace) being an appliance. As are all of Apple's products, more or less. Microsoft is a little off the mark on this one, but it IS their job to criticize their competitors. I look forward to seeing their technological rebuttal since they sound so cock-sure. They better act fast.
Wow, that's really interesting. I think that Britain is firmly in the wrong on this one. That places a lot of trust in a lot of individuals hands, which I don't necessarily have a problem with because of a number of psychological factors related to their employment in the army, but that doesn't discount someone infiltrating the systems and activating the missiles.
I actually agree with you 100% that people love something that's easy to play with. That's what I meant when I said that Apple's simplicity is their strength. What I'm talking about is a difference between "open" turnkey and "closed" turnkey.
I love turnkey, and so do a lot of people. Who wants to fuss with installing new software, etc.? That's my perspective.
Closed-systems are much easier to make turnkey, but they aren't the only alternative.
Just because something is open, doesn't mean that it can't be simple. It CAN be tinkered with, but it doesn't have to be to make it work.
That response is shorter than I'd like, but I have to run unfortunately.
That Apple is creating a closed system is of little surprise. Steve Jobs is all about control. It works in the short term, but I believe it will bite them in the ass over the long-term.
Making use of a closed-system and trying to be the best in a category assumes that you have access to the most brilliant minds in that field, and the most brilliant marketing campaign. What makes Apple great? Well, they can control every aspect of their production because they own all their own tools and can keep out the crap. Also, they have slick industrial design. For now they also have some of the most brilliant minds in the industry, but not all of them. This is why they will never achieve world domination with their products. I suppose I could make use of their own advertising to make an example : "I'm a mac, I'm a PC". You are either an apple person or you're not. Their closed-system allows little flexibility. They would be doomed to what they used to be were it not for them opening their file formats to standards.
Why is this not the best approach? Because of human innovation. People hate being held down, forced into one category, etc. This is what apple is doing, but because their products are so innovative, consumers will go for it.
Google is much smarter; they know what to hold onto and what to open up for the masses. Even though they employ many geniuses, they are always on the search for new innovative ideas. That's why they purchase so many startups, or so I've been told.
That's why I believe in a race between Google and Apple, Apple WILL lose eventually.
Closed-systems should actually drive innovation because they must be circumvented. That's why Apple products are cracked all the time. So I guess the challenge then is, that if you aren't happy with Apple, build a better product and market it as well as they do. All things being equal, the open-system product will win every time. You can't employ all of the brightest people yourself, all of the time. I think Apple will learn this in due time, and then things will change.
A sidenote is that a large part of Apple's appeal is simplicity because of their closed-system. If anyone could create an opem-system as turnkey as theirs, they'd come ahead by far. I think one of the closest systems to being fully open and turnkey I've seen so far is Facebook Connect, but I'm starting to become too long-winded, so I'll leave it at that.
Interesting points. I suspect that Facebook doesn't allow you to change the name of your business page because of the way they anchor them in their database... but at the same time, I believe you can change your personal page in a way that requires redirecting to a new permanent link. This is the same on twitter or tumblr. On both you can change your name and it will automatically change your personal URL to match. As someone who has had a business page, both of these are complaints that I agree with completely though.
Presentation just finished. I have to say I'm disappointed. First point is trivial; they should have gone with a new name like iSlate. Playing off of your own products name (IPod) is weak marketing. It sounds like something somebody would try to knock off an iPod with.
Actual problems with the iPad:
1)It should have 128GB of storage available. I understand this would lead to a big price leap, but availablility would be nice
2) They should've gone 16:9 Aspect Ratio. EVERYTHING is that ratio now. Notice all the vids didn't fit the screen? Furthermore, the keyboard built in would be much more effective with the increase in dimensions.
3)Thank the lord they have 3G. If they didn't I would've lost it. But why can't they just put this on the same bill as my phone? THAT would've been a good contract negotiation. That way Phone providers get even more of our data usage and it's built in. This would help me use up my 6GB monthly dataplan. I want simplicity Apple, not another plan to activate.
The battery life is brilliant though.