News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

MichaelEllsberg

Re:The Coming Disruption on Thursday May 26, 2011 @05:33AM (#2587130)
I agree with you that many journalists are perhaps a bit quick on the draw to label any little murmur a "movement" or "trend." However, I do believe that the phenomenon of young people questioning formal higher education and striking out on their own---while certainly not at critical mass yet---will truly quality as a true trend/movement to watch in the coming years.

There are just too many structural factors coming together at once: skyrocketing tuition costs; combined with a lackluster economy; combined with unsustainable levels of indebtedness compared to starting salaries; combined with cheap and easy ways to educate yourself on the Net; combined with a cultural trend towards young CEOs (many of whom are dropouts) becoming the new "rock stars"; combined with dramatically lower start-up costs for entrepreneurialism, which usually doesn't require formal credentials; combined with a "red ocean" effect in the oversaturation of BAs on the job market---all of these are pointing to what I think is likely to be a groundswell of young people questioning formal higher education in the next 3-5 years.

Watch this space. I believe it will be an absolutely undeniable movement within a few years.

(Author of the article you are critiquing.)

Re:The Coming Disruption on Thursday May 26, 2011 @05:21AM (#2587116)
I'd say it's a bit harsh to say Dale Stephens hasn't achieved "any tangible success," Michael. He supports himself fully as a professional public speaker, at age 19, and he does so without being "famous" (movie star, athlete, musician, etc.)

Tens of thousands of professional speakers, many into their adulthood, would kill to have the professional life he has. Indeed, as someone who supports himself fully as a freelancer, I'd say that's already a level of success that many adults seeking to strike out on their own dream of.

True, he's not a gazillionaire, but I specifically chose to write about him for that reason. Had I written about, say, the usual suspects when giving examples of successful young people without college degrees (Mark Zuckerberg, etc), someone else might have said, "But they're the outliers! Average kids can't expect to be like them!" He has reached a level of success which I believe is impressive for his age, and which many adults would envy.

BTW, he was just named one of the Thiel Fellows, and was chosen as one of 24, among 800 applicants, to win $100,000. I'd say that's a pretty impressive accomplishment, compared to what many 19 years have accomplished so far.

(I'm the author of the article you're critiquing here.)