HaskellMuppet
Re:New haskell-lang.org
on Saturday July 09, 2016 @09:26AM (#12061230)
Then I don't understand why you're deliberately spreading FUD about the PvP.
Re:New haskell-lang.org
on Saturday July 09, 2016 @09:18AM (#12061211)
The fallacy of that argument is assuming that tool X being able to build artifact Y means that X is "sane". The only thing this says is that tool X is able to build Y, nothing more and nothing less. For instance, I could easily implement a tool which is only capable to build `yesod`, and only `yesod`. Would that be a "sane" build-tool?
Re:New haskell-lang.org
on Saturday July 09, 2016 @09:13AM (#12061193)
Can you restate your argument more clearly please? I'd like to respond, but you're not making it easy.
Re:New haskell-lang.org
on Saturday July 09, 2016 @05:10AM (#12060746)
You're implying everyone's equal. But the fact is that the haskell-lang.org team is made up almost exclusively high-profile Haskell developers who everybody knows already, including backing from a commercial entity which can promote it via their company site, as well as a book author who can promote haskell-lang.org via his new book. So while anybody could just do what the haskell-lang.org team did, it wouldn't have the same impact/effectiveness without a comparable endorsement.
Re:New haskell-lang.org
on Saturday July 09, 2016 @04:05AM (#12060629)
and how do I get people to notice my haskell-lang.org fork?
Re:New haskell-lang.org
on Saturday July 09, 2016 @03:05AM (#12060493)
You should read up on the PvP before you comment on something you clearly don't understand well yet (unless you're knowingly misrepresenting the facts and using hyperbole on purpose in the interest of spreading FUD).
Re:New haskell-lang.org
on Saturday July 09, 2016 @02:16AM (#12060358)
You can't deny there's pattern emerging of reinventing existing Haskell infrastructure under the pretense to "move away from infrastructure that is showing its age" rather than help improving the existing one
Moreover, this new tooling/services are operated and maintained by FPC employees which, quite conveniently, moves control away from the community board to FP Complete which by design has commercial interests at its heart.
I'm not saying FP Complete is doing evil things right now but this creeping shift of powers into the hands of a commercial entity is making me uneasy.
Re:New haskell-lang.org
on Saturday July 09, 2016 @02:06AM (#12060334)
Sure, I could fork Stack and implement features I consider important. But how do I get my Stack fork advertized on haskell-lang.org to reach as many people as possible?
Re:New haskell-lang.org
on Friday July 08, 2016 @05:53PM (#12058897)
What are the important parts of the PvP and why are they important?
Re:New haskell-lang.org
on Friday July 08, 2016 @04:27PM (#12058399)
It's more subtle than that. Sure, Stack is OSS and all that. But Stack's developers have a vision of their own how Stack and Stackage (and by extension the Haskell ecosystem) are supposed to work. They may even make Stack rely on services controlled/hosted exclusively by FPC rather than a neutral entity. And they will reject feature-requests or PRs which don't fit their agenda rather than because you didn't pay them enough. As long as Stack doesn't add any essential functionality over Cabal which would make a package unbuildable with plain Cabal we're good.