Just to be clear, the argument here is that censoring Google is an act of aggression against Google and all of its users regardless of what is being censored. So forcing Google to censor illegal material would be beholden to this argument as well?
As a business grows larger and sets up multiple offices in many countries, this can make things quite complex.
Now, as to the original point, Google is required by many nations to censor certain material regardless of if that information only is kept in servers in some other country. Are these laws an act of aggression against Google? (Ignore for a second that Google would likely choose to censor most of that material anyways due to the negative publicity in not doing so, similar to reddit's banning of borderline legal subreddits not because the law, as they were borderline legal, but due to publicity.)
Do you have a cite for that please?
As I understand it the "sex tourism" laws cover behaviour that is not legal in the US, but is legal in some other country. If a US citizen travels to that other country they're still breaking US law, even though they're not in the US and even though that activity is legal in the country they're visiting.
Also, for some activities, the travelling US citizen will face justice in the US for some crimes no matter what the legal status of that activity is.
Well, in the best example, it is a bit complicated. Take age of consent. Within a state, state law rules. Between states, federal law rules. In most cases, federal law is stricter than state law. So it would be an action that would be legal in the state you were a resident of, but not in another state.
Also a counter example. Prostitution is illegal in most states, but it is, to a limited extent, legal for an American to engage in such abroad (much like it is legal for residents of Texas to go to Nevada).
In short, I believe there are laws that do what I describe and laws that do what you describe.
(Note I'm not a lawyer and the laws have changed a bit since I last read them.)
Google has the right to spread whatever it wants as long as it is not aggressing against other people in doing it.
Again this is is just cynical flaunting of sovereignty on Googles' part, and another example of a supra-national entity lauding its power over democratic governments.
Very, very cynical - and Google have lost yet another point in their race to dominate culture as a corporate, global power..