News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by vonmoltke on Monday August 03, 2015 @10:25AM (#9996031)
> This is an absolutely baffling article. The job market for developers is not glutted by over-supply, it's one where marginally-qualified people get hired for salaries well above the national average because companies need SOMEONE to do the job. And virtually nowhere cares about degrees, especially for experienced devs.

What is baffling is this Valley-centric, web and mobile development-centric line being repeated constantly in this thread. Most of the world is a different story. Outside the Valley and a couple other metros, and outside the web and mobile fields in general: 1) degrees are usually required; 2) employers are much pickier.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by nordic_nomad on Monday August 03, 2015 @10:55AM (#9996295)
So I'm self taught, no degree, and I get job offers and headhunters out of the blue from all over the central US. Denver, Kansas City, Omaha, Des Moines, Chicago, and small cities I've never heard of.

The best thing I ever did was look at my friends early on who were getting found on linked in and organized my linkedin profile to look as similar as theirs as I could truthfully. The next best thing was taking 6 months off from freelance work to just build a portfolio of small projects that demonstrated the skills people were looking for, and it made interviews much simpler.

I honestly refuse technical interviews at this point because they're a waste of time and I don't study the crap they ask for and it indicates technical leadership can't spot a good developer by looking at what they've built and talking to them about their methodology.

If I really want a new job pronto, I email 5 recruiters who send me the most random postings and tell them what I'm looking for. Last time I did this I had 6 interviews scheduled that week and was in a new job that met my requirements in 2. This is in Kansas City, and while there is a fair amount of tech worker shortage here it's no where near what it is other places.

Honestly the OP's story doesn't sound all that different from my own. Started a tech company in grad school, taught myself javascript and front end work, left just before what we started was sold for a small amount and didn't get anything out of it except exhaustion and credit card payments on top of student loans. But my "40 hour a week vacation" as I called it didn't work out and I got dumped in an executive reshuffling. Did one of those code bootcamps to learn back end C# .Net MVC work in 6 months and got my first developer job at $40k, got the next one at $60k 6 months later, $75k 6 months after that, and $100k 6 months after that.

It's very doable anywhere in the country right now, but you can't just float down stream. You have to have a plan and actively work it and check yourself against the market and learn stuff people want you to know to get to the next level. Your skillset is not a constant, and it's up to you to demonstrate that you have it. If you leave it up to someone else to figure out how to do all that you're screwed, because if they knew how to do that they wouldn't hire so many developers who don't know what they're doing.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by philbarr on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:26AM (#9996652)
Lessons from this post:

1. If you're going to swear, don't use an asterisk to try and make it look good. We can take it, honest.

2. Something in between two asterisks on HN gets shown in italics.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by nordic_nomad on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:58AM (#9997007)
Huh. Yep, all I did was use the asterixesses. Clearly the site was offended by my attempt at modesty.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by doktrin on Monday August 03, 2015 @12:28PM (#9997372)
You can edit it. It's a weird nitpick, but it actually detracts from the legibility.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by nordic_nomad on Monday August 03, 2015 @12:44PM (#9997563)
Done, sorry for the eye strain.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by FLUX-YOU on Monday August 03, 2015 @12:50PM (#9997629)
>Did one of those code bootcamps to learn back end C# .Net MVC work in 6 months and got my first developer job at $40k, got the next one at $60k 6 months later, $75k 6 months after that, and $100k 6 months after that.

That's a ridiculously good trajectory actually. Did you go to each next job based on what you built previously (plus the business experience), or were you also doing your own stuff in parallel to work?

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by nordic_nomad on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:09PM (#9997820)
So the first 2 years I was significantly underpaid with the digital agency we started really, where I was the only person doing front end and everyone else being a data scientist or strictly back-end person.

Front-end work was really undervalued as we priced our work, but the only thing that was less valued were my MBA and business operations skills, so I kept doing that until student loans kicked in.

I did a lot of community centered work for free and freelance stuff on the side after I left especially after my Senior UX job at a startup that was making money fell through, but it wasn't until I built my portfolio and assembled what I could that was all over the place and used it as my initial resume that I realized people would hire me as like an actual employee web developer.

It's a couple years out of date now, and really starting to show its age, but this is what I used when doing my initial job hunting early in 2013. http://www.startup-designs.com

So some of the trajectory is due to the foundation I had already, but most of it was talking to people I knew who were where I wanted to get to and blatantly copying what they told me I needed to do. It's not rocket science the stuff that actually works, but it's not intuitive either.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by dba7dba on Monday August 03, 2015 @06:08PM (#10000242)
it wasn't until I built my portfolio and assembled what I could that was all over the place and used it as my initial resume that I realized people would hire me as like an actual employee web developer.

I second this experience. In fact having an easily accessible portfolio (aka website) was what got me interviews and current job.

I was let go from help desk position about 3-4 years ago. I admit I was over paid help desk tech. I tried to use that time to restart my career (study) as a linux admin/tech. Despite my years in IT working as IT tech and Windows admin, I didn't get much response. What really helped get my current job was putting up a blog with tutorials explaining how to do certain tasks on Linux/webdev. I have a few dozen articles and each blog post is 2000+ words. Each took many hours to complete, some days. It goes from learning something, start writing, editing, going through the steps again to ensure it works.

For anyone who's having a hard time getting a job in tech industry, your goal should be putting up online an example of what you can do that others can view easily. Our industry is blessed with workers having this option. In most other career fields, this is not possible.

I would encourage the original poster of pen.io to put up his work as part of his resume. I feel his pain as I'm also not in the early 20's age bracket but don't give up.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by thekingofspain on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:25AM (#9996630)
Um, whatever key you used instead of 'u' in 'fucked' made almost your entire message italicized.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by derekp7 on Monday August 03, 2015 @12:31PM (#9997403)
As I was reading the post, I couldn't wait for him to swear again so the italics would be turned off.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by s73v3r on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:23PM (#9998543)
"Started a tech company in grad school"

How could you do that if you don't have a degree? Very few grad schools will admit someone without an undergrad degree.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by ClashTheBunny on Monday August 03, 2015 @03:17PM (#9999049)
I think he means that his degree is not in Computer Science or a related field. Not that he does not have a degree.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by nordic_nomad on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @02:10PM (#10005144)
Yep, undergrad was in finance. Grad school was an MBA in entrepreneurship.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by mkozlows on Monday August 03, 2015 @10:37AM (#9996138)
I have friends who are devs and hiring managers (several of whom have no degrees, even) in many cities -- Detroit, Columbus, Portland, Chicago, SF -- and the same thing is true in all those places.

If you live in a small town, I can believe that the opportunities are limited, but in basically any metro area of any size, it's a developers' market.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by vonmoltke on Monday August 03, 2015 @10:43AM (#9996187)
Well, I live in Dallas. I have been fishing in Dallas and Austin over the past several months and can't get any interviews. I would like to know where all these "desperate" companies are and what domains they are in.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by vpeters25 on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:38PM (#9998101)
You must be doing something seriously wrong if you are a dev in Dallas and haven't found anything after a couple weeks.

I live in Fort Worth, I was in the market last month and I got flooded with offers for interviews from the North Dallas area (Addison, Plano, Frisco). Not talking about these "urgent requirement" emails from indian recruiters, this is actual local recruiters I have dealt with before.

My background is pretty much like OP: I learned to program BASIC on the C64 and dropped off college, the difference is I did all that in South America. Since I came to the US in 1999 I haven't had trouble finding a dev job besides being unemployed for 6 months after the dot-com bubble.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by HillRat on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:29AM (#9996678)
What's your skill set and background? I hired a dev team a few months ago in Dallas and it was incredibly difficult to find qualified candidates, of whom only a few made it through the tech interviews (and I'm not that tough an interviewer) -- twenty resumes (from a very good headhunter who culled out marginal candidates) meant a dozen interviews meant one hire. I'm not in the hiring market right now (and may not even be in an industry you're interested in), but if you want to shoot a resume to careerbasetx at gmail (it's a throwaway account) I'd be more than happy to take a look at it, for whatever that might be worth.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by vonmoltke on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:06PM (#9997784)
Thanks, I'll do that. For the record, my professional programming experience is about 2/3 real-time embedded signal processing code, 1/3 NLP research and prototyping. I have also had a straight EE role that involved some embedded and test set code.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by milspec on Monday August 03, 2015 @04:52PM (#9999715)
I think I recall getting you an interview. (at http://advancedsecuritylabs.com/ in Florida) Did we not give you an offer? Did you reject an offer?

We could easily put you in San Antonio or Austin. We might even be able to do Seattle or Cambridge (near Boston), though those are tiny offices.

If I remember right and we did reject you, try a different office.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by mmorett on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @11:27PM (#10007890)
First sentence: "Did we not give you an offer? Did you reject an offer?"

Third sentence: "If I remember right and we did reject you..."

---------

Where do I even begin with this.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by kodablah on Monday August 03, 2015 @12:15PM (#9997220)
I am a dev in Dallas and I am constantly inundated w/ recruiters to the point of annoyance. Based on my friends' anecdotal management/employer-side stories across several Dallas companies, it is definitely an employee market right now. Many companies are paying hefty salaries/bonuses to move people in from out of state.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by amyjess on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:54PM (#9998857)
During my unemployment spell in 2010-2012, I got lots of recruiters talking to me, and I even had some interviews come out of that.

Guess what? The employers were pickier than the recruiters.

I've learned to deeply distrust recruiters: they are known to make up lie after lie just to throw as many names in front of an employer as possible on the off chance one of us gets hired so they can grab their commission. They'll ask employers to interview blatantly incompetent candidates (including myself: I was absolutely not competent for some of the positions recruiters tried to get me) just because they're that desperate.

Then, when I was looking for a new job in 2014 (employed, but unhappy at my then-current position), I got innundated with so many recruiters lobbing utter shit at me. This time, I could afford to be picky, and I wasn't afraid to say to some of the shadier ones, "never contact me again". I had multiple recruiters try to offer me a six-month contract in another state, despite my profile on every job site saying both "unwilling to relocate" and "full-time only, no contracts". I had recruiters try to get me positions that required twice the amount of experience I had in technologies I've never touched. I had one recruiter repeatedly send me calls and emails for a position I explicitly told them I wanted no part of the first time he contacted me, and he didn't stop until I sent an email saying "please cease and desist from contacting me again, or I will take legal action against both you and your firm" (I should've also called his firm's HR department, but c'est la vie...).

Oh, and now that I'm happily employed at my current employer, I still get frequent calls from recruiters. I legally changed my name (first, middle, and last) in June 2014, but most of the recruiters calling me ask for me by my old name, and I'm at a point in my life where even hearing my old name causes me emotional distress.

In short: recruiters are sleazy, and being contacted by recruiters has no bearing on whether or not you'll actually get a job.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by mkozlows on Monday August 03, 2015 @03:13PM (#9999014)
There are different types of recruiters. Some are those worthless spamlords, who pester candidates with irrelevant jobs and submit worthless candidates to hiring managers.

But the good ones look for good matches and good candidates, and don't waste people's time with junk. One recruiter placed more people on my team, with a much higher hit-rate, than any other one I dealt with; when I was interested in changing positions, I let him know, and after a month in which he didn't bother me at all, he pointed me toward an opening that was a perfect fit for me.

If you build up relationships with recruiters, you'll learn which are which, and how to ignore the Robert Halfs and Manpowers while still getting the benefit of the good ones.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by Yhippa on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @03:58PM (#10005847)
Recruiting these days seems like what real estate agents were from 2000-2008. Lots of people were cashing in on the wave. I feel the same thing is happening now with tech recruiting. Because of that there's so much crap out there that just taking the time to filter is an exercise in frustration.

I had one recruiter call me and sell me on a position as a portal developer. At the end of the call he finally asked "by the way what is a portal?" He was dead serious. I was livid.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by nordic_nomad on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:01AM (#9996345)
Well the quick answer is JavaScript is needed everywhere.

I'd bone up on that, and learn angular inside and out as well as a couple of other JavaScript frameworks for good measure. That's what gets me hired as a C# developer in php, ruby, and java shops where I can then gradually show them I know UX, devops, and other little valuable things. The trick is that the hot thing in short supply will change this time next year and you'll need to keep a finger on the pulse of it and learn that if you're looking to job hunt.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by vonmoltke on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:13AM (#9996483)
Hence the reason I said "web and mobile development-centric" in the post that started this sub-thread.

I'm actually writing a UI in Angular right now or a Java-based system I wrote. I hate it. It is a pain I'm going through because I need a UI for this prototype, but there is no way I would want to do this full-time.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by mkozlows on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:37AM (#9996768)
Let me put it like this: If you're an unemployed developer writing sob-story posts about how it's impossible to find a job, I'm going to assume that you're not wedded to a particular tech stack and are willing to work on the technologies that are in-demand.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by vonmoltke on Monday August 03, 2015 @12:05PM (#9997091)
Absolutely. If I found myself out on the street tomorrow I would suck it up and take an Angular job if it came along. Beggars can't be choosers. In fact, I'm glad I have that flexibility if I really need it someday.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by nordic_nomad on Monday August 03, 2015 @12:15PM (#9997224)
Honestly I don't tend to use angular with pure .net stuff. Razor and Linq handle all the templating for a single page app and data piping. Really all I'd add to the standard environment is something like this ( https://github.com/SignalR/SignalR ) so you can get real time data and refresh the page without postback.

For node work you really need it, but if you're using .net you're running a framework on top of your framework. So kind of more of a pain in the ass than you need to deal with for most things.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by vonmoltke on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:15PM (#9997880)
I designed the system as a set of (mostly) REST services, with the goal of keeping it as flexible as possible. Not only is the UI completely separate from the system, it is actually optional. The system is designed so that our current or future customers could slot it into an existing, larger analysis system if they wanted to.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by nordic_nomad on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:40PM (#9998114)
Ah, yeah definitely need something like angular then. Very cool sounding project.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by s73v3r on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:31PM (#9998615)
If you hate it, why are you using Angular?
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by tracker1 on Monday August 03, 2015 @05:01PM (#9999783)
Angular gained a lot of popularity by being an earlier contender at the time it was released... React is on the rise now, and may overtake it... Angular2 is more like React and a departure from it's prior take.

Businesses move slowly, and new project uptakes on technology is usually 3-5 years after initial release... .Net was out int 2002, but it wasn't until close to 2005 that it really started getting popular... jQuery was 2006, and almost an exception, but still not really strong until 2009... 2009 started Node, but it didn't start to shine until 2012-2013... it takes a while.

As it stands, at this point Angular is out there and a lot of current jobs are using/require it... if you can't sell a better option (polymer, react, etc), then you're stuck with it.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by manyxcxi on Monday August 03, 2015 @10:57AM (#9996315)
I'm in Seattle and am getting lots of contact from recruiters in DFW and Austin, and not just the usual LinkedIn spam BS. My background is heavy on DevOps and I've got about a 50/50 split on .NET and Java.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by eropple on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:12AM (#9996475)
I can corroborate this, though more from the LinkedIn side of things. Out of every twenty LinkedIn messages I get, probably six are SF, four are Boston (I'm local), two each are NYC and DC, and two or three are between DFW and Austin.

(The last couple are usually Idaho or Nebraska or one of the other corporate-fief states.)

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by milspec on Monday August 03, 2015 @05:08PM (#9999829)
Depending on the town and your specialty, you might be surprised. Not every place outside of the typical hot spots is corporate-fief. Specialization means you can have a good job market without the crowds causing traffic jams and running up the cost of living.

For example, you might not expect much good in Melbourne, FL. You'd be wrong if you happen to like low-level code (assembly, reverse engineering, vulnerability research, embedded development, etc.) or EE stuff. There are both larger companies (Harris, Lockheed, Northrop Grumman, and the http://advancedsecuritylabs.com/ part of Raytheon) and lots of startup-ups.

Since a specialized area (like Melbourne, FL doing low-level stuff) doesn't have too many nerds outside that specialty, the cost of living stays low. You can get a cheap house within a mile of work and there isn't much traffic.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by eropple on Monday August 03, 2015 @07:05PM (#10000490)
I said what I get, not what does or doesn't exist. =)
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by proksoup on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:18AM (#9996551)
What are the corporate-fief states? What does that mean, or what is that in reference to?
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by HillRat on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:34AM (#9996739)
Roach-motel markets: you can get in, but you can't get out. More technically, monopsonistic or oligopsolistic factor markets, where the number of employers is small and thus control hiring in the local market. (Though I would expect Nebraska to be fairly competitive in hiring, given its surprisingly large number of finance and insurance companies.)
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by eropple on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:58AM (#9997004)
That's another possible way to look at it, but wasn't what I meant. The companies I know that went to Nebraska (or Idaho) pretty much had everything handed to them and they're not exactly states known for being big on protection of the middle and lower class. (People in favor of the approaches taken by these states might call them "business-friendly" climates; I think being friendly towards corporations, in an age where people cheer them for being amoral, is kind of stupid.) Monopsonic/oligopsonic concerns are another one to keep in mind, though.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by tracker1 on Monday August 03, 2015 @04:48PM (#9999671)
If you're relatively competent and current in .Net (C#) or Java, you should be employable in the southwest (Dallas, Houston, Phoenix etc)... There's a lot of business programming in those cities (I'm in Phoenix)... it isn't exciting, or front end centered for the most part, but tends to be consistent (except the year following 9/11 was pretty harsh).

I don't know your background, but would suggest going with a modern Java framework, or ASP.Net MVC and build something... go through the latest Apress or O'Reily book on the subject in question... At the same time start going to user group meetings locally. This will tend to get you at least in the door as far as interviews go... from there you're on your own.

Yes, some places you won't get past H.R. without a degree, but I've been at this for a couple decades now, and as long as you get current or keep up, you should be employable.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by amyjess on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:08PM (#9998407)
I'm in Dallas as well, and I can back you up. I was unemployed for two years from 2010 to 2012 after getting laid off because all my experience was specialized experience that didn't transfer to other companies well, and being unemployed so long took a huge toll on my mental health.

I've found employment since (and even changed jobs over the new year), so it's definitely something one can recover from, and for all I know the job market might have changed since then so things are better now.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by bitshepherd on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:13AM (#9996481)
My experience with fishing in Austin is that they love you when you're not in Texas. If you're in Texas, you don't exist to them, so you don't get an interview.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by zanek on Monday August 03, 2015 @12:31PM (#9997411)
I put my resume online 10 days ago (I live in Austin). I've had over 200 companies/recruiters call me. There are a ton of software engineering jobs in Austin and all over. I've gotten over 30 calls for jobs in Dallas, San Antonio, Plano, etc.

Anyone saying there are no jobs in this area has a crappy resume or no skills

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by stock_toaster on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:43PM (#9998149)
Just curious, what kind of place did you put your resume online?
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by vonmoltke on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:15AM (#9996510)
I have definitely got that impression. Over the past few years I have seen a parade of articles about "missions" from Austin to the Valley to try to recruit people, yet they seem to think Dallas and Houston don't exist.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by karlkatzke on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:25AM (#9996627)
I didn't get that experience at all, and I moved from College Station.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by nilkn on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:33AM (#9996724)
Are you open to Houston? I can provide suggestions on where to apply there.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by vonmoltke on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:09PM (#9997823)
Absolutely. I have made a few attempts to break into the oil and gas industry there, since my wife is affiliated with the industry.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by sharemywin on Monday August 03, 2015 @10:50AM (#9996247)
same thing in Ohio.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by wiz21 on Monday August 03, 2015 @12:15PM (#9997225)
Agreed. We're pickier. I work on application that ditributes about 1E9 euros a year (so it's smaller than a bank but that's not exactly a small application either). We're maintenance-mode now. When I hire, I need : some who : - can actually code (many of the applicants can write code, but they don't know important things like : how does a hashtable work, recursivity, etc) - can write reliable code (i.e. ability to test, ability to imagine failure before they happen) - can write readable code (because you knw, we're working in a team) - can handle harsh customer (because when you fail, well, they're not happy)

believe me, we don't have millions of those ready. Many can code, but code in "real" life where you don't have luch room to learn from mistakes, well, there ain't many...

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by javajosh on Monday August 03, 2015 @12:35PM (#9997451)
>where you don't have luch room to learn from mistakes

I enjoyed that.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by sargun on Monday August 03, 2015 @07:58PM (#10000767)
Why do you need to know how a HashTable works?
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by greenyoda on Monday August 03, 2015 @08:12PM (#10000834)
So you could predict its performance and know when it's not the best data structure to use?
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by analognoise on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @03:50AM (#10002139)
Because it's an easy canned interview question that can replace the effort to determine how a candidate thinks and see if their skills actually align with the role?
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by drzaiusapelord on Monday August 03, 2015 @10:34AM (#9996108)
Agreed, sometimes people aren't aware that HN is its own little echo chamber.

I was talking to a recruiter recently for a managerial job and somehow got onto the topic of hiring. I asked him what's the hardest jobs for him to fill right now. He told me he's dying for entry level .NET/ASP and Java developers. Corporations have built their castles on these technologies, not FOSS/Mobile and need staff. Degrees were an issue but he said he could place people with two year degrees.

We talked about pay, and it wasn't terrible impressive, but for someone straight out of community college it sounded pretty good to me and he also revealed that if the person wasn't a complete nightmare socially, he could expect to be promoted quick.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by outworlder on Monday August 03, 2015 @10:52AM (#9996263)
> He told me he's dying for entry level .NET/ASP and Java developers

Why does he need so many entry level programmers?

> We talked about pay, and it wasn't terrible impressive

Is the recruiter trying to staff a company with mostly entry-level programmers, paying low wages? I've seen plenty of companies like that, including those who used mostly trainees. Usually, the work environment was the crappiest possible, and word gets around.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by sjcrank on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:21AM (#9996584)
In the interest of building an experience-diverse workforce employers need entry level, mid level, and experienced developers with skills in their core stack, which in many cases is Java or .NET.

My theory is that technology trends are leading the entry level developers to learn Python, Ruby, and JavaScript rather than .NET or Java, thereby reducing the supply and putting these candidates in high demand.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by tracker1 on Monday August 03, 2015 @05:12PM (#9999846)
So, they could hire another senior person at 2.5x the pay instead of 3-4 junior devs. The problem is a lot of younger managers don't understand the different in ouput can vary a lot from developer to developer. And on top of that quality output can be far more maintainable.

All they care about is # of jira/tfs tickets that are open, and the number of features, and how many warm bodies based on their averages they need. The smoothest project I ever worked on was staffed by all senior people, with relatively diverse and overlapping skills. That wouldn't be possible with 3x the developers if 2/3 of them were junior to mid level.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by mkozlows on Monday August 03, 2015 @10:41AM (#9996177)
HN may be an echo chamber, but look what you're saying: Employers are desperate for developers, including entry level ones, mostly using older tech stacks, and they'll pay solid money for them.

It doesn't sound like you're describing a world in which someone with 10+ years of solid experience with techs is going to be struggling to find a job, right?

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by doktrin on Monday August 03, 2015 @10:54AM (#9996285)
> It doesn't sound like you're describing a world in which someone with 10+ years of solid experience with techs is going to be struggling to find a job, right?

Overqualification (or the perception thereof) happens. The development world, like most others, is a bit of a pyramid. More experience doesn't necessarily translate to more positions being available. Some (many, even) are specifically targeted at young, entry level devs.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by tracker1 on Monday August 03, 2015 @05:13PM (#9999857)
And a lot of these companies should consider bringing on one more senior person instead of 2-3 junior ones.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by ryandrake on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:17AM (#9996537)
> He told me he's dying for entry level .NET/ASP and Java developers.

How many years of experience and how much demonstrated expertise did he require from these" entry-level" candidates that he supposedly can't find?

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by drzaiusapelord on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:45AM (#9996873)
None. Straight out of community college were being placed.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by aidenn0 on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:55PM (#9998291)
After I had landed my first job out of college (10 years ago), I got an offer from a company like that in the midwest.

It took them 9 months from the interview to get back to me with an offer (which is why I was already working somewhere else) and the offer was $30k for a one year contract.

If that's still typical of their hiring process, I'm not surprised they're having trouble hiring people.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by Bluestrike2 on Monday August 03, 2015 @10:48AM (#9996235)
Companies like that would benefit from being more flexible on the degree issue; there are a huge number of programmers out there who are self-taught. It makes things seemingly more difficult in judging qualifications, but if you aren't filling the positions to begin with, that would seem like a good problem to have in the first place.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by milspec on Monday August 03, 2015 @05:21PM (#9999926)
Oh my. I know somebody who needs that job. Probably the "Georgetown, KY" on his resume is the difficulty, but he's willing to move. He can do C#, Java, and C++. He even has a traditional 4-year computer science degree.

Pass along his email if you can: [email protected]

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by djKianoosh on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:47AM (#9996889)
what does "complete nightmare socially" mean? :)
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by tracker1 on Monday August 03, 2015 @05:19PM (#9999900)
Well, my own quirk is I'm a later day starter... it's almost impossible for me to start consistently at or before 9am... outside of that, I tend to take more time to understand the problem and the desired solution than hacking away. Both of these have cause me a lot of issues in positions for companies that are more rigid in their desire for a homogenized work environment.

On the flip side, I share knowledge and work to leave code better when I'm done than when I start. Others will show up/leave on time, but won't share anything and will leave very obfuscated code in place.

Lets face it though... the personality traits that make one adept at somewhat technical and often mundane tasks have a pretty high correlation to some generally less than desirable personality traits. Programming is much more of a craft (or even art) than it is an engineering discipline in most places, but we have to interact with business roles where expectations and mindsets are vastly different.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by LyndsySimon on Monday August 03, 2015 @03:13PM (#9999016)
I completely disagree. I was working at FedEx as a programmer in 2012, and decided to make a move due to some internal changes. I made that decisions about two months before PyCon - at PyCon, I had two interviews, one of which landed me a great job at a significant pay increase.

During those two months, I had phone interviews with two other companies, one of which I bowed out of the process because as I learned more I didn't believe in their mission, and the other I got turned down on.

The sum total of my "trying to find a job" was making a profile on StackOverflow Careers and answering a Reddit ad.

For what it's worth, I have no degree and am self-taught. In 2012, I had ~5 years of experience as a full-time dev, and none of it was in a traditional environment.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by pmelendez on Monday August 03, 2015 @04:27PM (#9999532)
You are still in the states aren't you? The story is very different outside of NorthAmerica.

In several countries in Europe and in LatinAmerica, landing in a well-enough job can be a matter of several months depending of the skill-set.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by jimbobimbo on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:11AM (#9996465)
I'd say, it's opposite of (2). I keep reading horror stories about multi-day interviews with "take home tests" and other insanity, here on HN - and these are usually traits of the interviewing processes of newly minted startups. I had a bunch of interviews with "regular" companies on the East Coast and the process is way more sane and much less grueling.

My advice to the OP would be to find and get in touch some of the older recruiting companies, the ones that exist more than 10 years on the market, and work with them. Steer clear from the startup scene. Normal companies still need the job to be done - why not by you?

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by doktrin on Monday August 03, 2015 @12:30PM (#9997395)
> I keep reading horror stories about multi-day interviews with "take home tests" and other insanity

2 actual interviews that were offered to me early in my career :

1. The weekend hackathon (which actually ran from Friday until Monday)

2. The full-week trial

I took #1, but not #2. I was working at the time, and in no way could justify taking a week of vacation just to work for free for someone else.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by mindcrime on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:55AM (#9996971)
What is baffling is this Valley-centric, web and mobile development-centric line being repeated constantly in this thread. Most of the world is a different story. Outside the Valley and a couple other metros, and outside the web and mobile fields in general: 1) degrees are usually required; 2) employers are much pickier.

I haven't found that to be the case here in the Raleigh/Durham, NC area. I never finished my bachelors degree (although, I do have three different associates degrees), and I have never found it to be an inhibition to my career.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by klibertp on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:39PM (#9998110)
> outside the web and mobile fields in general

Why don't you just change the domain your working in? Why not web dev? If you're a programmer, you should be able to code anything, anywhere, with a bit of effort.

I skimmed your post (https://wmkrug.com/on-the-technical-skills-shortage-and-hiri...) and honestly I'm not sure. I mean, you're saying that requiring "years of experience" in "specific technology" makes "good candidates" to get rejected. But why do you think that someone without these years of experience would be a good candidate?

Experience and skill are necessary. People without experience have little skill by definition: you only improve your skills by doing and remembering what you've done (well and badly) is called experience. Such people are not worthless, but as employees they are worth significantly less than people who demonstrably have both experience and skill.

You seem to be thinking that the employers should let you learn your profession on the job because the college failed to do it. I don't think so. I believe you're the (like we all are) one responsible for teaching yourself enough to be a viable choice for at least an entry position. It's not that hard if you have a passion for the craft and patience to continue learning over the years.

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by ForHackernews on Monday August 03, 2015 @04:59PM (#9999763)
> If you're a programmer, you should be able to code anything, anywhere, with a bit of effort.

Is that really true? I do database programming, and I feel like I would be absolutely screwed if somebody demanded I do, say, embedded programming for small microprocessors. I guess theoretically I could study up, but it would be at least a year or two before I could be competitive in interviews, right?

Maybe I just suck and there are genius programmers who are equally competent at embedded systems, mobile development, distributed systems...

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by klibertp on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @02:55PM (#10011969)
> Is that really true?

Yes, I believe so. And it has nothing to do with genius!

First: of course you wouldn't be able to get senior dev positions in a domain you never worked in. You have to be prepared for this. Pay cut is obvious just after the change, and you need to decide if you can afford it.

Second: it's a matter of how long you're going to stay junior in your new domain. In practice, this is a question of how solid your foundations are and how experienced you are already, and also how determined you are. I believe in what jwz said in "Coders at Work": different domains have different vocabularies, best practices, and myths, but deep down it's still just standard coding. There are variables and loops and branching constructs everywhere, no matter the domain.

> there are genius programmers who are equally competent at embedded systems, mobile development, distributed systems...

I doubt there are many people who are competent in many domains at once. There are such people out there and they're very expensive specialists. Still nothing to do with genius, but rather hard to achieve. However, you don't need to be like that: you just need to change the domain, not master a new one while retaining all your skills specific to the previous domain.

The two most important things for making a switch are your foundations and experience. In your example - embedded dev - you'd need to have a good prior understanding of how CPUs work plus knowledge of C and Asm. Given this you're almost immediately ready to code, after maybe a week of reading the codebase, manuals, and refreshing AT&T asm syntax (for example). You - every programmer, really - should know at least the basics of such things from college or self-study.

The experience is important because it gives you an intuition as to where the potential problems and hurdles in your learning would be. More than anything, experience provides you with an essential skill, a systematic (working for you) way of assessing and learning a new technology. It's much easier to change your domain for the fifth time than it is for the first time. Even if the previous areas you worked in have nothing to do with the one you're learning right now.

For me, programming is a lifelong career choice. That means I have ~50 years of programming still ahead of me. I can't imagine working for such a long time in a single domain! In a bit more than a decade of my professional programming, I already switched domains four times. Despite the fact that I'm self-taught, and my foundations were lacking for quite some time. (I like to believe I fixed this after a couple of years.) It wasn't easy, but if I did it, then I'm sure almost anyone can :-)

Re:The Unemployable Programmer by andywood on Monday August 03, 2015 @01:42PM (#9998141)
I've never worked in the valley, and I usually don't have much to do with the web or mobile. I don't have a degree, and the subject has literally never once come up in an interview. In 17 years, I've never encountered anyone who cares. Also, the vast majority of job descriptions read something like "Degree in CS OR equivalent experience" and therefore explicitly do not require degrees.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by tracker1 on Monday August 03, 2015 @05:05PM (#9999803)
It will vary from company to company and culture to culture... I have a friend at a large aerospace company who was basically told he had 3 years to get his degree or he was out... He's now a mid-level project manager and does 2-3 the workload of his closest peers, but H.R. policy was that he shouldn't have been allowed into his current position without it.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by ScottWhigham on Monday August 03, 2015 @10:35AM (#9996117)
If that were true, it would mean that The Valley hires, on average, lower quality developers than non-Valley employers. Is that what you are suggesting?
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by vonmoltke on Monday August 03, 2015 @10:46AM (#9996217)
I don't think it means "on average", since I do think the average quality of a dev is higher in the Valley is better than elsewhere. However, I am saying that getting hired as a marginal dev is easier in the Valley than elsewhere, since there are not enough warm bodies in that area and Valley companies only seem to be willing to reach outside the area for really good people.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by nordic_nomad on Monday August 03, 2015 @11:03AM (#9996367)
There aren't nearly enough warm bodies everywhere else. But you need to figure out what the term warm body actually means in your area.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by cgearhart on Monday August 03, 2015 @10:56AM (#9996307)
It may be more accurate to say that The Valley has different standards for software development on web & mobile than employers in other regions and in different categories. The quality of a developer depends on the overlap of their skills and the employer's needs; never judge a fish by how well it can climb a tree.
Re:The Unemployable Programmer by s73v3r on Monday August 03, 2015 @02:21PM (#9998512)
Employers are generally picker in companies who's primary service/product isn't software. But they're still among the loudest to complain when they can't find anyone to come work for them for peanuts.